Jerome
This is a play that slowly sinks into its audience. The struggle, fear, tenderness, and love are conveyed through words, a glance turned away, a trembling hand, a lingering hug. Are there smutty moments, fierce kisses, and heated scenes? Yes — but the play offers far more than that, much like Prince Faggot. Its portrayal of watching a loved one age and approach death feels painfully real. We do our best to face it, yet at the same time we can’t help looking away. Their fading becomes difficult to witness as it symbolizes the one inevitable truth in life . Not only for them, but for ourselves as well. The emotional tensions and shifting dynamics between the characters all feel incredibly authentic. Nothing comes across as forced or manufactured for the sake of the plot. That brings me to another topic: the stage design and lighting are REALLY good. I initially expected the play to rely mostly on dialogue, but every scene is lit with such precision and atmosphere that it genuinely surprised me. The set design honestly feels on the level of a Broadway musical, which left me both amazed and slightly bewildered. Overall, I highly recommend it — though the pacing is undeniably slow. “Slow burn” is probably the perfect way to describe it.
It was so heart warming and sometimes heart wrenching. I enjoyed this thoroughly. Finally some queer theater that isn’t all shots, giggles, and shade throwing. It was very real and authentic. Not a caricature. Went deeper into gay male life than I have seen on stage and also touched on what it’s like opening from monogamous to polyamorous. Blessed to have seen it!
100% not perfect, but amazing job by all involved. Highly recommend. Tons of laughs and tears and joy! Beautiful story. Such a unique LGBTQ story and perfect for this Pride season. Having been to the real city of Jerome, I found it very compelling and interesting to watch. Set design was impressive! Specially for the small space. This show has a ton of potential! Recommend!
NYPL Culture Pass I appreciated that this play didn't shy away from the themes of aging and mortality, contextualizing them in an older gay couple seeking to bring in a third. The themes resonated with me and lent a realness to how the characters act and react with each other.
“Jerome” by John J. Caswell, Jr. plays at Playwright Horizons until June 21. The show follows an aging gay couple as they introduce a mysterious stranger with a painful past into their lives. It is quite rare for me to get mad at a pause for intermission ; however, when watching “Jerome,” I was antsy to hear the rest of the story. Although it took a moment for me to become invested in the story, but once the dinner scene started, I was hooked. Frankly, I would have happily welcomed a four hour, intermission-less version of this play. The cast is phenomenal and creates wholly emphatic characters that you want to invest your time getting to know. Each actor was a standout in their own way, but I found myself watching Ken Barnett (Bruin) the most. Barnett is a master in minute expressions and gazes that showcase the character’s inner world. Dustin Wills’ direction is nothing short of stunning. I was impressed by the range of ways he found to stage scenes that could easily become “park and barks.” Additionally, Wills’ scenic design is gorgeous and unfolds beautifully. Lastly, if theater is an empathy machine, then John J. Caswell, Jr. (playwright) is a brilliant engineer. As unassuming as the play may seem at first, the more it unravels, the more haunting it becomes. The show deals with profound questions of the lengths one can change and what forgiveness means for both parties. Also, the choice to focus on older characters—notably gay men—does not go unnoticed in a world that sees to solely focus on younger stories. “Jerome” is a perfect play to kickstart pride month. If you are a fan of Samuel D. Hunter or Tony Kushner’s writing, you’ll enjoy “Jerome.”
A beautifully touching and funny new play about gay romance, aging, and illness. Set during the AIDS crisis of the 1990’s, this is a terrific addition to the canon of plays about that era. The trio actors are all very good, but Stephen Spinella steals the show in his most memorable role since Angels in America. The dialogue feels very real, and the characters very lived in. I’d highly recommend this, especially to gay men of a certain age.
Innovative and so well acted the dialogue was really fun
Affecting and forever timely
Very original
Not to yuck anyone’s yum, but when a gay couple brings in a third, how frequently does it work out? It’s probably an uphill battle if the threesome originated out of some issue with the two-person dynamic, but Jerome by John Caswell Jr. is more concerned with exploring how this type of arrangement evolves, rather than harping on how or why it was initiated. Set in Arizona in the early 90s, Cornelius and Doane come across Bruin, who recently fled San Francisco for reasons not immediately clear. Things between the three of them start off with a bang (wink, wink) but over time, a cold mortality looms over their relationship, evoking questions around responsibility, care, and self-preservation. The triangular lens becomes really interesting here when you consider a world where only two of them remain, but not the original two. I was fascinated by the dynamic this play presented, and while it had its clunky moments, it offered just as many funny or tender ones, too. This was also a rare case where I wouldn’t have minded a little more exposition. I felt like some areas of the story deserved more attention than they were given, or vice versa. I’m glad it has more time to cook before it officially opens, but I enjoyed it regardless. The post-apocalyptic aesthetic, the interesting progression of the story, and the fantastic performance by Tony winner Stephen Spinella was more than enough to make the two and a half hours fly.
Well acted play about relationships in the face of aging and time running out. The production design is beautiful but overly ambitious causing some slowing of the pace when making dramatic set moves.
good performances but something was missing in the play -
1–13 of 13 comments
Jerome is the story of queer devastation, and reconciliation that my heart desperately needed right now. In yet another collaboration on a deep-cutting Arizona-set piece at Playwrights Horizons, playwright John J. Caswell Jr and director/scenic designer Dustin Wills conjure characters, relationships, and a world in a state of fallout. With Caswell’s unflinchingly truthful dialogue, Wills’ clever staging, and seismic scenic surprises signature to Wills’ style, the production offers glimmers of hope in the depths of abandonment. This is an early preview and it’s my understanding that one performer joined the production as a very late replacements, so I’ll be gracious about what appeared to be some awkward blocking and line slip ups at times. I would definitely be interested in seeing this again later in the run, and not just for another opportunity to vicariously live my fantasy of being a live-in third for the an older gay couple who celebrate their anniversary on Halloween 🎃🌈 (Edited)