About
Jerome, a ghost town in the secluded Arizona backcountry, is home to Con and Doane, an aging gay couple who’ve built a quiet life far from the chaos of cities and other people—until a stranger arrives, fleeing his damaged past, and falls into their arms. Set at the height of the AIDS epidemic, John J. Caswell, Jr.’s new play is an unexpectedly funny, delicately wrought story of survival, even in the harshest of deserts.
Cast & Creatives
Written by John J. Caswell, Jr. Directed by Dustin Wills
Seat Views
View all 1 seat viewCommunity Discussion
This is a play that slowly sinks into its audience. The struggle, fear, tenderness, and love are conveyed through words, a glance turned away, a trembling hand, a lingering hug. Are there smutty moments, fierce kisses, and heated scenes? Yes — but the play offers far more than that, much like Prince Faggot. Its portrayal of watching a loved one age and approach death feels painfully real. We do our best to face it, yet at the same time we can’t help looking away. Their fading becomes difficult to witness as it symbolizes the one inevitable truth in life . Not only for them, but for ourselves as well. The emotional tensions and shifting dynamics between the characters all feel incredibly authentic. Nothing comes across as forced or manufactured for the sake of the plot. That brings me to another topic: the stage design and lighting are REALLY good. I initially expected the play to rely mostly on dialogue, but every scene is lit with such precision and atmosphere that it genuinely surprised me. The set design honestly feels on the level of a Broadway musical, which left me both amazed and slightly bewildered. Overall, I highly recommend it — though the pacing is undeniably slow. “Slow burn” is probably the perfect way to describe it.
It was so heart warming and sometimes heart wrenching. I enjoyed this thoroughly. Finally some queer theater that isn’t all shots, giggles, and shade throwing. It was very real and authentic. Not a caricature. Went deeper into gay male life than I have seen on stage and also touched on what it’s like opening from monogamous to polyamorous. Blessed to have seen it!
100% not perfect, but amazing job by all involved. Highly recommend. Tons of laughs and tears and joy! Beautiful story. Such a unique LGBTQ story and perfect for this Pride season. Having been to the real city of Jerome, I found it very compelling and interesting to watch. Set design was impressive! Specially for the small space. This show has a ton of potential! Recommend!
NYPL Culture Pass I appreciated that this play didn't shy away from the themes of aging and mortality, contextualizing them in an older gay couple seeking to bring in a third. The themes resonated with me and lent a realness to how the characters act and react with each other.


Jerome is the story of queer devastation, and reconciliation that my heart desperately needed right now. In yet another collaboration on a deep-cutting Arizona-set piece at Playwrights Horizons, playwright John J. Caswell Jr and director/scenic designer Dustin Wills conjure characters, relationships, and a world in a state of fallout. With Caswell’s unflinchingly truthful dialogue, Wills’ clever staging, and seismic scenic surprises signature to Wills’ style, the production offers glimmers of hope in the depths of abandonment. This is an early preview and it’s my understanding that one performer joined the production as a very late replacements, so I’ll be gracious about what appeared to be some awkward blocking and line slip ups at times. I would definitely be interested in seeing this again later in the run, and not just for another opportunity to vicariously live my fantasy of being a live-in third for the an older gay couple who celebrate their anniversary on Halloween 🎃🌈 (Edited)