High Spirits
The premise of High Spirits is irresistible: a man's dead ex-wife returns as a ghost to torment his second marriage. The Encores! production — directed by Jessica Stone with a brassy 29-piece orchestra — gives the rarely revived musical a warm, swinging sheen. The script is tight and genuinely funny. So why does the evening drag? Because half the songs don't earn their existence. In a good musical, characters sing when emotion demands it — when speech alone can't contain what they're feeling. Here, too often, the plot just... pauses for a pleasant little number. Madame Arcati alone gets "The Bicycle Song," "Go Into Your Trance," and "Something Is Coming to Tea" — all charming, none essential. I'm someone who would have argued there's no such thing as too many charm songs in a musical. High Spirits proved me wrong. I found myself tapping my foot not to the beat but in impatience, which is a rare and unwelcome feeling for me in a theater. At two and a half hours, the show desperately needed trimming. Phillipa Soo is the standout as Ruth — her "Was She Prettier Than I?" lands with real bite, and she finds unexpected physical comedy in a role that could easily be the thankless straight woman. Rachel Dratch does a lot with criminally little: her name is first on the playbill, but the maid role gives her maybe 20 distinct words to work with. Still, she makes scurrying across the stage saying "Yes, ma'am" funny on the tenth repetition, which is a real gift. Andrea Martin brings her trademark physicality to Madame Arcati, though the role begs for someone to go even bigger and truly devour the stage. Steven Pasquale's tenor occasionally disappeared under the orchestra, and Katrina Lenk's Elvira sometimes suffered the same fate — the band sounded gorgeous, but the balance wasn't always there. The paranormal effects, on the other hand, are simple but surprisingly effective for a bare-bones concert staging where most of the cast is still reading from binders. The ending is the real missed opportunity: it seemed to be building toward a neat, funny payoff centered on Dratch's Edith, the maid — who turns out to be a natural medium — but then it just... didn't. It's giving Death Becomes Her, another supernatural comedy with forgettable songs — but that one was routinely hilarious with impeccable staging. High Spirits is a diverting enough night at the theater, but it's a reminder that a great play doesn't always make a great musical. 68/100
This show belongs to Phillipa Soo. She delivers every tiny, charming detail into her character’s arc, going from slightly nervous second wife to unhinged ghost nemesis. Her vocals are, as expected, powerful and she manages to track her character’s emotional spiral in song! Overall, the show absolutely delivers on entertainment. Would it have more polish if it weren’t a short-run Encores! production? Probably. It has strong Death Becomes Her energy, though it doesn’t quite hit that level of camp and production. Audience members were triny to determine the purpose of the binder scripts—were they off-book? Were the flubs intentional? These are Tony-nominated professionals. If a line gets dropped, I’m inclined to believe it’s either for the laugh or a chance to enjoy live theater. The songs aren’t especially memorable, and while there are a few Fosse-like moments where the choreography shines, the staging is fairly minimal as the script stands make it hard to fully commit to sweeping movement. But none of that detracts from the fun. This is the kind of show where you have a brandy beforehand, settle in, and let yourself enjoy the spectacle of very talented people being unhinged, silly ghosts.
Fun show! Definitely agree with the reviews that it was an older era Death Becomes Her and that the on-book status was a little distracting/disappointing since it limited staging a good amount. Pacing felt old school, but it still moved along well. Cool to see Philippa Soo and Rachel Dratch. (Edited)
Well done Encores! production. The original material is nothing to write home about.
Vocals were great and the plot was amusing, but the music isn’t very memorable.
Great! Except I’m a little tired of the staged reading format
It’s cute enough but no real substance in the music or text. If you’re excited about the cast though, it’s worth seeing.
It was great production. I just don’t think I bought into the premise
It was fun and light with an all star cast!
This show reheated Death Becomes Her’s nachos
Very disappointing. Hated the stage-reading format but I could have overlooked that were this show a little bit funny. I left after the first act.
Despite a stacked cast, the performances were surprisingly forgettable. While the overture was beautiful and the special effects were cute, I didn’t leave the theater humming a single tune. The production didn't quite live up to its name—leaving me with 'mid' spirits.
Forgettable. Elvira had way too many songs. Way too long; they could have cut it in 1/2 and *maybe* it would have been better.
Not sure this was for me simple musical. Dry comedy presented well but the material is not particularly strong. Heavy reliance on scripts and some flubbing of the lines.
Such terrible seats, couldn't see the actors at all.
A little too old times for my taste
Bad casting. Slow show.
21–39 of 39 comments
Excellent music and interesting plot. There are some moments that seem out of place and the main plot feels like it could’ve been further explored. Sound design seemed rough from my seat and prevented some of the jokes from landing. The main cast is great, but the larger ensemble was unnecessary. The set was extremely basic.