High Spirits
This show was so much fun! THE ORCHESTRATION!! 🤩🙌 The music was so bright and refreshing. Think 60s jazz meets Austin Powers meets classic game show music meets 60s/70s sitcom theme song. The comedy felt timeless and the practical effects were mystifying especially given this being an Encores! performance with limited staging. Andrea Martin is a comic delight who absolutely devours each scene she’s in with her impeccably whimsical and irreverent physical comedy. Phillipa Soo also displayed some hilarious physical comedy. Despite Rachel Dratchs rather small role, I could not take my eyes off of her anytime she was on stage. Brilliant!! 👏 I would kill to see a complete production of this with full effects. I think it would be true broadway magic with the right crew on board 🔮 (Edited)
a bunch of fun! slow to start but pulled together with a bow in the second half. i'd say it was a “right laugh!” with a british accent. there were also a ton of references that went above my head but older audience members really enjoyed - so prob even more endearing to go with a family member!
no one has ever been more gorgeous than miss elvira lounging across those tables girrrrrl i didn’t blink for the whole scene
FINALLY saw Phillipa Soo live and it was magical 🥲
Such a silly and fun show! I really loved the music, story, and the talented cast, especially Katrina Lenk as Elvira.
One of my favorite places to go! Encores at NY city center! Show did not disappoint and the cast was an ensemble of wonder. Have to give a major shoutout to the true ensemble of this show whose dancing was impeccable and impossible to take your eyes off.
We need a moratorium on heterosexual contact with the afterlife until we figure out what the hell is going on. Also obsessed with the heavy-handed Camelot reference happening with Philippa Soo right there lmao (Edited)
Fun, classic show with a classic score. Really enjoyed the songs and the performances. An entertaining afternoon.
Fantastic! Truly a shame that this show has been forgotten by so many. PLEASE go see it. The cast is wonderful but it’s the large grand orchestra that really made it for me! Might be one of my new favorites (Edited)
What an effervescent, adorable joy of a show! Astutely directed and with a top-notch cast, this is the type of Encores show that would normally have transferred to Broadway 20 years ago. Alas, I don’t think this show would suit Broadway audiences nowadays, but for fans of classic, Golden Age musical comedies that aren’t revived often, try to see this production! This feels like a return to classic Encores, and what they do especially well. The score is tuneful and hummable, and is, as always, highlighted by the terrific Encores orchestra. Kudos to the whole cast, but especially Katrina Lenk, who’s a perfect fit for her role.
I always love watching Encores at City Center!! I didn't know what to expect but it definitely seated my expectations. It was funny and engaging throughout
LOVED IT!! Highly recommend seeing this fantastic show. Would love to see a full Broadway revival one day. I’m shocked this show hasn’t been discovered by more schools and regional theatres!
The show was very entertaining and funny. Loved it
Andrea Martin and Rachel Dratch are the two funniest people alive
Love this show so much!
Very entertaining
Ya know, the music sounded lovely (the orchestra at encores can do no wrong) and there were maybe two really interesting twists but far too many unnecessary songs (specifically of the charm variety) that left me pulled out of the story. An incredibly hard working company though. Each performer was selling every. single. moment. There were just too many serious writing flaws. I should also mention the choreo was INCREDIBLE (the moments a dance break occurred felt very odd but boy do they DANCE) (Edited)
What I love most about New York City Center Encores! is their willingness to produce shows like High Spirits. I would argue the majority of audiences have not seen or even heard of this musical, yet it remains an important part of musical theatre history. For this reason, I would recommend this charming updated production as chances to see this musical are few. With that said, High Spirits is certainly not the strongest production New York City Center Encores! has produced in recent years. It’s important to note that this is a true concert production. The actors spend most of the show reading from scripts and are often parked in front of music stands. Though it is common for actors to carry books in Encores! productions, I would argue they are utilized quite a bit more here than I have seen in past productions. This leaves some moments feeling dull and disconnected. Director Jessica Stone’s staging unfortunately doesn’t help as it is often overly simplistic and at times stagnant. There are a few impressive special effects that highlight the supernatural elements of the story, but those are few and far between. Even as a concert production the show often feels unfinished. The music written by Hugh Martin and Timothy Gray is catchy enough but doesn’t feel necessary throughout most of the story. However, the 26-piece orchestra led by the Encores! Musical Director, Mary-Mitchell Campbell is so spectacular, they alone make every note a delight. Choreographer, Ellenore Scott perfectly captures the sultry mood of the sixties breathing life into an often slow-paced musical. Her choreograph paired with the show’s strong ensemble brings a much needed energy to the stage. The star-studded cast of principal actors is really where this show soars. Phillipa Soo as Ruth delivers her iconic silky smooth vocals with sharp comedic timing reinforcing her status as modern Broadway royalty. Sharing the stage with her real-life husband, Steven Pasquale as Charles, their chemistry is electric. Pasquale’s beautiful baritone voice fits the musical perfectly. Katrina Lenk also has her unique vocal talents on full display as Elvira, leaving audiences wanting more at the end of every number. Rachel Dratch delivers a few laughs as Edith, and is always wonderful to see onstage. Sadly, Dratch’s talents are drastically underutilized. The true star of this production is the incomparable Andrea Martin as Madame Arcati. Featured in more major musical numbers than any other performer, Martin is the perfect vehicle to keep the show moving. Her comedic genius and larger-than-life stage presence make it feel like the role was written entirely for her. This Broadway legend is in her prime, and her performance is a genuine thrill. Though it is not a stand-out production, there is still a lot to appreciate in High Spirits at New York City Center. If you can get on board with the simplicity of concert staging and appreciate the impressive star-power onstage, you are sure to enjoy this rarely produced classic.
Fun night at the theatre but felt overall it was done safely and risks weren’t taken. Just my personal opinion. Only one song was blown out of the water and wowed me. The acting was fun but several errors (which the actors had fun with and had everyone laughing). Overall the musical just didn’t perform how I was hoping. Still thankful for seeing it and experiencing it! Great work by all involved.
1–20 of 39 comments
MY TAKE ON: High Spirits, City Center Encores, February 7, 2026 Pity poor “High Spirits.” On the strength of a wonderful score by Hugh Martin (“Meet Me in St. Louis”) and Timothy Gray (“Love from Judy”), it sailed onto the stage in 1964 at the tail end of the Golden Age of Broadway. The show’s misfortune was to choose a year when two of the genre’s biggest blockbusters, “Funny Girl” and “Hello, Dolly!” also debuted. Martin and Gray’s score gets the royal treatment from the glorious City Center Encores 29-piece orchestra under the direction of Mary-Mitchell Campbell. And the madcap story about séances and ghosts gets a boost from a wickedly playful cast of Broadway all-stars: first and foremost Andrea Martin as the daffy medium and Rachel Dratch as the beleaguered maid. Inviting these two onto a set is an invitation to mania, in a good way. (No one is more adept than Martin at milking a laugh from a flubbed line. The cast works with scripts in hand, providing ample opportunity for delightful screw-ups.) Rising to meet them are Steven Pasquale and Philippa Soo, a golden-voiced couple in real life playing a bickering husband and wife to great effect here. Tony-winning Katrina Lenk rounds out the key players as the glamorous ex-wife and ghost, with vocals that are uneven but deliver well enough at full belt. It all coheres into a delightful show that woulda, coulda, shoulda in another time and place. The producers in 1964 might have been wise to contact a medium before launching.