Dead Outlaw
Went in completely blind, came out a big fan! A hybrid of a book and narration musical, this was super funny, unique, clever, and crazy that it was a true story. It's an eight person cast with a minimal set, which proves the old saying, "Limitation breeds creativity." The stage pictures created were all great, every different setting is clear and concise, and the lighting is used masterfully to tell the story. Not only was this laugh out loud funny many times, but it had wonderful core questions and themes. We're all gonna die. Everything will eventually be nothing. What do you want to do until then, and will you be happy with what you left behind? Andrew Durand was great in part one, but I'd be interested in arguing the weight of a Tony nom for his performance. However, Julia Knitle and Jeb Brown were shoe ins for their noms. This show really surprised me! Give it a shot, I promise you'll have a good time. (Edited)
Catchy songs, was getting a little bored of the western plot toward the end of part 1, then part 2 I didn’t want to end. Amazing band and cast, loved it. (Edited)
Final show, the cast cried and did a encore
At first I thought are they doing a whole show with just a band…boy was I wrong. And it’s a true story about an outlaw in Oklahoma . As an Oklahoman ..I was shocked, and delighted cause as crazy as the story it…it definitely tracks. Bonus …it’s all true.
Came in with no expectations and had such a fantastic time! The music is unlike anything else currently on Broadway. I would recommend trying to be as center as possible because the sight lines are pretty harsh at times, but it was an enjoyable show nonetheless.
Devastated this is closing but so glad I got to make it! This is my petition to bring back the “Best Ensemble” award at the Tonys
Loved the soundtrack of this show! Super refreshing sound! Lottery seats at the back of orchestra were pretty good but tight. Price ($30) can’t be beat!
Had no idea what I was getting into going into this but I was pleasantly surprised by the performance. It’s definitely a smaller scale musical, the runtime and stage do give ‘off-broadway’ but that didn’t detract from my enjoyment of it. The lead performer in this musical is up for a Tony nominee for best actor in a musical and that is definitely worth pointing out, as he most certainly gives the performance of a lifetime. You’d like this performance if you enjoy dark comedies and broadway shows that prioritize content over spectacle.
Jaunty and a blast! The whole audience was in stitches for a solid two minutes at one point during the show. This is a big year for county/folk music on broadway and also strangely a big year for musicals about corpses. This show was a lot of fun. Well costumed, well designed, well acted.
This was my second time seeing the show, having seen it initially off-Broadway. It’s a wholly original musical, and you definitely have to enjoy dark comedies to like this. The story is so intriguing, and the music is really outstanding. It’s kind of a “small” musical and while it’s great that it’s on a Broadway stage, I wouldn’t recommend sitting in the rear mezzanine or balcony. The lighting is dim, and some of the show can seem quiet and slow. That all being said, the show is very affecting and effective. It’s one of the oddest subjects for a musical that you’ll ever see. While I liked it better the first time, the second time allowed me to appreciate the music more — it’s really a tremendous score.
I thought this was a really fun show; I have very few complaints. The entire cast is made up of Broadway lifers giving great performances. The absurdism of the show, both in terms of plot and the writing of the show itself, were welcome changes from the current commercial theater landscape. I wish they had gone further, in fact. Andrew Durand is giving a Tony-worthy performance: physically specific and riveting, emotional, and with his quintessential soaring tenor. It’s also crazy that the man stays onstage, still, for the entire second half. Jeb Brown has this gravel to his character that’s so satisfying, with a Springsteen-like energy as the band leader. Trent Saunders shines in his number, what a voice! My only complaint is the show never really decides what it’s about. But I kind of don’t mind? It simply tells the story and lets you draw your conclusions, and that’s refreshing.
So glad I got to see this show in its last week!! I’ve always been fascinated by the story of Elmer McCurdy, and they did a great job of bringing his story to life (pun intended). Songs were very catchy!
This show was HILARIOUS. I would say its like if Operation Mincemeat and Book of Mormon had a baby and that baby was a folk rock musical with a Hermes-like narrator. So fun. Great music.
I wish I was sitting closer, but the songs were amazing. The show was wonderful and the acting was great.
Loved seeing a show without a box office name attached be full of people enjoying the hell out of it. So glad something so fun and unique like this is on Broadway. Great performances from everyone! #firstpreview
Loved it - the whole audience was leaning forward the entire time
Dark and funny, a soulful little light on 49th st. I love a musical with a bluesy/rock score, and this one delivers on all fronts! I laughed, I teared up, was deeply moved, and will be singing that recurring theme for months and months. Worth trying to get in before it closes next weekend!
21–40 of 292 comments
I’ve read this described as “a collection of songs, more rock concert than play,” so went in with tempered expectations. I found that to be completely untrue! There’s a clear narrative, told through song and spoken dialogue. Music was fantastic, especially loved the pedal steel guitar.