Dead Outlaw
Saw this three times in two weeks and I’m not sorry. The entire cast came out after a Wednesday matinee and they were so sweet and spent time chatting with everyone! This show is weird and macabre and hopeful and human and a little punk and just SO fun. (Edited)
Had to go back and get orchestra seats to try to catch Andrew Durant blinking (he hardly ever does 😳). Row D was perfect but nearly too close to see the scenes on top of the train car, wouldn’t go closer than that. This is the best and catchiest score of the season! And the show is so funny and also so thought-provoking. I love it so much. (Edited)
Slow to begin but after a pivotal scene, roughly 20 minutes in it became engaging and I was engrossed and musical. Such an amazing tale that is based on a true story. Quite remarkable.
Totally surprised me! Very artsy and used space so well. Everything I didn’t like about Floyd Collins felt so justified watching this because it genuinely took all my complaints and showed how to do it the right way. Music was great. Our seats were obstructed which was annoying but it didn’t impact my overall opinion. I was a little apprehensive going into this, and yes, there were some parts I didn’t love, but overall I left with so many positive thoughts. (Edited)
Dead Outlaw was such a bizarre and fun experience. The fact that it's based on a true story alone is so captivating; but this amazingly talented cast takes you on a journey, where you feel for Elmer McCurdy's character's upbringing, to laughing at the absurdity that he got into before his untimely demise and even beyond. Definitely makes you want to look up the true story after. They made such an immersive world with such little props and the cast/band can sing and jam so well! Would def watch again! ❤️
I loved it! Weirdly funny and morbid. At points you could hear the whole theatre laughing. Though my sister thought it was so different than any other plays she's seen, so she only thought it was good 😂
Won the lottery for a front row seat. Weird, dark show. The cast is great. It’s entertaining but also very sad that it’s a true story. It’s crazy that taxidermy with animal bodies is still a legal practice in 2025.
Had no idea what to expect and I really liked it! It’s definitely an interesting story to tell for sure maybe not the first pick but it sure did make a great show. Loved the band aspect I cried 3 times and laughed a lot. Overall a good time and a story about someone who didn’t get to finally rest for a very very long time.
I effin’ loved this show! A wholly original, new musical, with a very talented cast that is having a blast up onstage. I also enjoy shows where I learn something, and this is a crazy true story that I knew nothing about. Weird, wild, and funny. The band is rockin’ and I really enjoyed the music even though it’s not my normal style to listen to. I also thought it made you reflect on what we owe someone’s body after they’ve passed. Elmer wasn’t the best guy in life, certainly, but the way his corpse was used, made money off of, and passed around for decades should make us all reflect on our humanity. Each member of the cast had standout moments to me. I had such a wonderful time seeing this show, and I am already planning on seeing it again!
Had no idea what to expect, and it was awesome. Very different! If you are a fan of Hedwig, this would be up your alley for its intimate storytelling, rock n roll vibes. MAJOR gallows humor warning (if the name doesnt already indicate as such). The jokes are clever and take you by surprise while also making you think about what you are laughing at. I felt moved seemingly out of the blue but totally welcomed. Could this have remained OFF Bway? Yeah. But I'm happy it is getting the attention it is so it can be seen by as many as possible.
Finally ended a tough streak of misses for me, I’m so happy to have loved something this much again!!!! Smart, cleverly staged, zippy, emotional!! Granted, this was at an advantage for me because I basically don’t find anything on earth as interesting as the American West in the 1910s and 20s and the mythologized West as the “frontier” closes. The way the cast plays multiple characters was kind of giving Cloud Atlas (I mean that so positively). Julie Knitel, I hope that Tony is yours!!
Not for everyone, but I loved it. Almost a touch too long for no intermission, but great production One of the few shows where you don’t want to be too close. Sitting in front row, I missed most things that happened above the band due to the angle
A wild ride! It felt like the band at a bar was telling you a story and the characters would occasionally steal the mic. So much fun!
First row seats were great! Amazing band
Fun show! Great music! Some of it is loud so a bit if a warning to those sensitive to loud sounds BUT it’s only for a few songs. Definitely deserved its Tony noms! I do think it was made for a slightly smaller stage tho. Seat was great! Rows (especially towards the back) are at an incline so no worry about people blocking.
It was a good show. Sight lines from the front row were roughly with a very elevated stage and some seems on a second story platform
Bizarre and unlike anything I’ve seen on a Broadway stage, but it all worked!! Really enjoyed the show and left thinking a lot about mortality and what it means to live
Just as good the second time. My pick for best score of the season. So sad it is closing so soon. Will be listening to the recording because the songs are so catchy. Thom Sesma has the scene stealing number of the season and Julia Knitel is so great in this - can’t wait to see what she does in the future. Brought my tween and somewhat to my surprise, she loved it too.
1–20 of 292 comments
I was depressed and overwhelmed with existential dread and the feeling that I’m a failure, and a fourth (!) viewing of this was the spiritual equivalent of taking my brain out of my skull and placing it in a cardboard box with a piece of lettuce for 100 minutes. Just pure dopamine for my ravaged soul. Currently badgering every single person I know in NYC to go see this weird, goofy, macabre but ultimately life affirming show. (Edited)