Dead Outlaw
Fun
Loved it!
Fabulous
𝐘𝐎𝐔𝐑 𝐌𝐀𝐌𝐀’𝐒 𝐃𝐄𝐀𝐃! 𝐓𝐇𝐈𝐒 𝐒𝐇𝐎𝐖… 𝐈𝐒 𝐀 𝐋𝐈𝐓𝐓𝐋𝐄 𝐃𝐄𝐀𝐃. I really wanted to love this show because the music is totally my vibe, but the story just didn’t live up to the hype. Part of the issue was my seat. I was front row center orchestra, and while that usually sounds like a dream, it ended up being a disadvantage. I couldn’t see important parts of the set—especially the mummy corpse and the top-level visuals—which definitely affected my overall experience. If you’re planning to watch, I highly recommend sitting farther back or in the mezzanine or balcony, where others said they got the full view. Story-wise, I struggled to understand why this particular tale needed to be told on stage. Sure, it’s based on an absurd and unusual true story, but I couldn’t connect emotionally with it. The book felt flat, and there wasn’t enough emotional weight for me to care about the characters. It felt like I was watching a play with musical intermissions—there was so much narration, I found myself wondering, “When’s the next song?” And honestly… how do you connect with a dead person being exploited? It’s literally dead! I kept asking myself, “Am I supposed to feel sympathy for Elmer McCurdy?” Because I just couldn’t. The show raises the question of whether his story really needed to be told on stage, and I’m still not convinced. Visually, the production didn’t feel big or bold enough for the Longacre Theatre. The staging and design lacked that Broadway-level ambition, and the overall vision felt too small for such a large space. In the end, this just isn’t the kind of show I’m looking for, and that’s okay. It’s not for everybody. But despite everything, I’m still going to the Dead Outlaw concert… because the music is a killer! (Edited)
this is a horror story that they’re trying to get laughs out of?? and it works for half the audience??? there were folks cackling next to me by the end and i was genuinely disturbed. show itself is solid, i enjoyed it. got a little antsy towards the end, but it was very warm in the theatre so maybe it’s fine when you’re kept comfortable. but again, it’s a HORROR story. actually disgraceful that this happened, and it is disheartening that we are still parading this man around, even after he’s been laid to rest. idk. great performances by the cast, the band on stage is fun and i liked most of the songs.
Dead Outlaw is unlike anything else on Broadway right now. It has quirky off broadway energy in the best way. The music is super catchy. I’m not a big country music person and I wasn’t sure how I’d feel about this show but the music feels like its own thing with some real flair. The entire cast from the side characters to the band to Andrew standing stiff as a board do an incredible job. At times the plot feels a little meandering—it’s hard to have a corpse as a protagonist. But there’s plenty to enjoy here. I’ll be eagerly awaiting the second half of their cast album. I saw this show from the sides of the orchestra for first preview and came back and saw it from the front of the balcony. Both views were pretty good and I actually really enjoyed the higher vantage point for some moments of the show.
everyone has been raving about this show so i was excited to go. i was disappointed. the music good but the plot moved extremely slow and his life was not the most interesting for me. feeling unsure about the tony noms for this one. i wish i had connected to the show and enjoyed it more. people also left and moved seats in the middle of the show so maybe that added to it. good music and cool set. and quite funny. my 89th show. 5/10.
I had higher hopes for this show. I sat in the very front row, so I was very immersed and I think my favorite part was watching the band on stage the whole show. The narrator was very good also. Overall, I found the show. A bit boring. The music besides the one main song was a bit forgettable., and a lot of characters rotated through many roles, and I found it a bit hard to follow at times. Besides the band being on stage, I didn’t love the plotline, even though it definitely was weird and I appreciated that. It’s definitely a good watch if you’re looking for something different in a bit odd but I wouldn’t say it’s memorable for anything other than it’s strange story arc.
I went in knowing absolutely nothing about the show and I was just a little bored halfway through. Super talented cast, there are some funny moments, and the music was alright. Really needed an intermission. Impressed with how long Andrew was able to play dead on stage. He didn’t move for so long.
Fun show. I thought the pacing could have been a bit faster. Loved the Coroner's song! Great view except for the forward leaner who kept moving around.
The story was unconventional, and the songs were excellent. However, the stage setup could have been better. I was seated in the rear central section of the orchestra, and many times I couldn’t see clearly because much of the performance took place in the far corners of the stage. This limited visibility took away from the overall experience.
I wanted to like this show, but the music was so loud and the sound mixing so poor that I could not make out the lyrics in at least half the songs. Actors were great.
Not sure if it’s big enough a show for a Broadway transfer. The theater felt too big for what they had to offer. The central mic sound was also really loud and ended up being a bit disruptive overall.
What is it about corpses on Broadway this season? Someone should do a Dead Outlaw and Operation Mincemeat double feature to honor all the weird things humans have done with corpses. Where Mincemeat brings humor, face-paced lyrics, and clever choreography, Dead Outlaw brings great music and at times you feel as if you're at a concert with a story happening around it. This show starts strong and ends strong, but drags a bit in the middle as characters are introduced but minimally developed. (Understanding that of course, it's hard to really develop a character who is dead, I guess). Go see this show for the impressive feat of watching the lead character stand absolutely still as a corpse for at least 30 minutes while people sing and dance around him.
Hear me out, the music is great & I love original musicals, but I was left disappointed by the book and its abrupt ending before divulging into the fascinating themes at play in such a high concept, inventive show!
Show was great, though the music was too loud to the point of having a hard time understanding lyrics at times
201–220 of 292 comments
an irreverent comedy that spans 100 years and involves a mummy