Caroline
Brilliant play. Very affecting.
TodayTix Rush - really enjoyed this story
Amazing performances by all, especially Chloe Grace Moretz.
I loved it…..
Soooooo gooood!!!! Beautiful story beautifully told. I cannot recommend it enough.
Excellent
I love plays that promote compassion and understanding. To me that’s what theatre is all about; Caroline by Preston Max Allen is exactly that and so much more. Allen has crafted a play that feels deeply personal and completely unique. The show covers a wide range of topics from trans youth, to substance abuse while avoiding harmful stereotypes and oversimplifications. Every line is crafted with such care and delivered by a masterful cast. River Lipe-Smith brings Caroline to life with nuance and much needed humor. Amy Landecker is both perfectly soft and devastatingly harsh as Rhea. The true standout of the piece is Chloë Grace Moretz as Madeline. Moretz delivers a masterclass in subtlety and passion. It is thrilling to be so immersed in a performance that you forget you’re watching a celebrity you admire. I would see any production featuring her once in a generation talent. With all there is to love about this production, there are still some aspects of the show that feel disjointed. The staging by director David Cromer is often awkward. It seems Cromer struggled to balance the multiple scene settings as much of the show’s action takes place in the far sides and back corners of the stage. This causes many audience members to leave with stiff necks. To avoid this, I recommend sitting at least three rows back and as close to center as possible. The set itself feels incomplete, with bare walls and plain set dressings distracting from an otherwise intricate story. It’s important to note that the production was still in previews when I saw it, so there is still time to make adjustments before opening night. Even with its flaws, Caroline should not be missed. This production encourages empathy along with the thought that anyone can grow and change. Ideas our world could certainly use more of right now. Don’t miss this beautiful play at MCC now through November 2nd.
A relatively sad, somber, solemn play — albeit touching — this is more of a character study than anything else. Fortunately, Moretz (in the lead role) gives an exemplary performance, filled with deep-rooted feelings and pathos. As this was an early preview, I sensed that some of the moments were still being polished, but the direction was relatively sharp. Overall, it’s a relevant play and felt unique enough for a family drama about addiction, perseverance, and dealing with the struggles of raising a trans child. It’s just such a quiet and slow play that I don’t think it will stick with me, especially because it felt lacking and not as fully fleshed out as it could’ve been in certain moments.
There’s an emotional rollercoaster in Caroline. Themes of addiction, abuse, identity, manipulation, and family all swirling together. At its center, the young star, River Lipe Smith delivers a beautifully complex, emotionally mature performance. My personal perspective is that the play itself tries to hold too many issues, and in doing so, story lines, including Caroline's identity as a transgender youth, gets lost. The focus becomes much more on addiction and generational trauma and the result is a plot that is a bit muddled. There are moments that hit hard and others that blur together, leaving you unsure what to feel. Maybe that’s the point? That life is painful and complex and we're all just trying our best?
Quality play. Well acted. Disappointing end. Realistic illustration of addiction, recovery, and family dysfunction. Accessible portrayal of non-binary gender identity in adolescence. (Edited)
Acting was great. The story was relevant and true and that's not enough to make a great play.
21–33 of 33 comments
I liked it so very much! Excellent job by all three actors!!