Caroline
Great casting and acting by the 3 performers! Punch lines made me both laugh and teary
What talent River Lipe-Smith has. The core of the play is how to love or trust an addict, whether that addict be yourself, your daughter, or your mother. Everyone’s right and wrong when the future is uncertain. Be prepafed to sob.
this was great!! the cast is incredible and the theater is small enough that you can really see all their facial expressions. its a pretty short play but i think every second is worth it!
Very heavy and moving. Great actresses and amazing way to deal with family dynamics, substance abuse and transitioning.
It was really well done and the actors are brilliant. It was such a small venue but that was the charm of it. You felt like you were part of the show and feeling all the family conflict and love.
This is an incredible moving play that covers so many topics in incredible fashion. The theatre is small so you can really see some incredible acting taking place. This play is extremely emotional and really makes you think how you would act in each characters shoes.
Preston Allen (who I am NOT despite occasional cases of mistaken identity) is a dear friend and colleague whose oeuvre I am very acquainted with. His plays and musicals cross genres, but he is known to write Horror. But this one felt even scarier to me than those capers… because it is so real. As a sober person, as a trans person living in America today, this was an emotional watch made so well. It also had a number of bangers joke wise and music choice wise. River, Chloe, and Amy all did a fantastic job. The direction by David Cromer was meticulous. the set was breathtaking. And once again, shouts to MCC for platforming a trans voice. Happy almost opening!
Exquisite. As per usual, stunning, delicate, tender, focused direction by David Cromer. Fabulous ensemble, with special commendation to Chloe Grace Moretz who left it all on stage- raw, devoted, moving, full- bodied, as well as little River. The bond between mother & child & the evolution in this play as well as the play's subject matter is as vital as it is timely.
Review: Caroline Robert W. Wilson MCC Theater Space – Susan and Ronald Frankel Theater Directed by David Cromer | Playwright: Preston Max Allen Caroline begins quietly, almost deceptively so, but it grows into a play that grips you by the soul and refuses to let go. Walking out of the theater, I overheard other audience members echoing my own mix of awe and lingering questions—a shared sense of wonder that speaks to the play’s ability to resonate on a deeply personal level. Preston Max Allen’s new work, directed with understated precision by David Cromer, places three generations of women on a collision course—Maddie, her nine-year-old trans daughter Caroline, and the estranged mother she hasn’t seen in years. Addiction, estrangement, and the broken patterns of family weigh heavy here, yet what rises to the surface is not despair but a raw, urgent portrait of survival. Cromer’s direction, paired with the set, lighting, costumes, and sound design, makes this world tangible and immediate. Each element works quietly but powerfully, amplifying the tension, intimacy, and raw emotion that pulses through Maddie and Caroline’s journey. Chloë Grace Moretz delivers a stunning performance as Maddie, embodying a mother who carries the scars of her past but refuses to let them define her. Maddie is perpetually in recovery, fighting like hell to earn back trust in a world that punishes her for every mistake. But it’s in her relationship with Caroline where the role truly soars—her fierce protection, her quiet encouragement, her refusal to let the world diminish her daughter. Maddie’s strength lies in her ability to stand tall under shame and doubt, proving that love, above all, is its own radical act of redemption. River Lipe-Smith, in their Off-Broadway debut, is nothing short of extraordinary. You would never know this was their first time on a stage of this size. River’s Caroline radiates intelligence, humor, and authenticity, but beneath her confidence is a child still deeply aware of the world’s cruelty. Caroline desperately wants to be seen for who she is, yet longs for the safety of her mother’s protection. It’s in the tender push-and-pull of that dynamic—the daughter testing her wings, the mother shielding her but never fully holding her back from her own growth and consent—that the play’s heart truly beats. Watching River and Chloë together, I was in awe; they anchor this story with a humanity so raw and precise it feels less like theater and more like life unfolding before you. Amy Landecker brings Rhea real dimension, showing glimpses of a mother beginning to soften, to recognize Maddie’s growth, to imagine forgiveness. And then, with a single offstage phone call to the father—a man who never appears, yet clings to his grudges—everything shatters. His harsh decision wipes away the fragile steps forward, and Rhea folds under the weight of his judgment. It’s a gut-punch moment, one that mirrors life’s cruelties all too well: progress undone by someone unwilling to witness it. The pain in that instant was visceral—you could feel Maddie’s anguish, and the audience’s too, as if a knife had pierced straight through the heart of the play. What makes Caroline even more moving is how it entwines the struggles of mother and daughter. Maddie’s relentless fight for sobriety mirrors Caroline’s own determination to assert her truth in a world that questions it. In one of the play’s most devastating moments, Caroline worries she will “never be a girl” because someday a scientist might identify her skeleton as male. Maddie’s instant affirmation—spoken with unwavering love—becomes a lifeline. From a bracelet beaded in a hotel room to a name declared in a diner, the play insists that identity is more than biology; it is love, recognition, and the courage to be seen. Final Verdict: Caroline is a fierce and luminous flight—funny, devastating, and profoundly humane. With unforgettable performances and a story that dares to wrestle with truth, shame, and resilience, this play soars straight into the heart. In a world that can be harsh and unforgiving, Caroline reminds us of the importance of love, understanding, and allowing every person—especially children—to live fully and authentically as themselves.
Second preview! Incredible performances all around and great script. Chloe was amazing! Highly recommend. (Edited)
Chloe Grace Moretz was superb. A challenging but very topical subject matter, handled delicately with bold passion and excellent delivery.
Chloë Grace Moretz was superb.
Best (and only?) use of a Jojo Siwa song in a serious play. Diva.
Great! I’m glad I got to see this before it closed.
Amazing. The young River gives an amazing performance. The adults are good too.
Fantastic acting in a riveting story.
I loved it! Great performances. Closing this weekend.
What a beautiful and touching piece that is masterfully complex and a wonderful spark of queer joy in the world right now. Top it off with a fab trio of marvelous performers and it’s sure to be a satisfying night at the theater!
Caroline is a great dive into an intergenerational story about women confronting their hardships and relationships. When Madeline takes her transitioning daughter Caroline to her estranged mother’s house, the two reconnect and try to mend their relationship, all while Caroline getting stuck in the middle of it. The story was very tight, and every scene was necessary to tell it. I like how Caroline was used as a device to get Madeline and Rhea to open up in a way they wouldn’t with each other. The play is definitely a Drama with a capital D, but there are some moments of levity that create some contrast, especially from Caroline herself. The performances were incredible. I was especially impressed with River Lipe-Smith’s portrayal of the sharp and observant titular character. Chloe Grace-Moretz’s performance as Madeleine took a while for me to get into, but during the character’s emotional height it really landed. For me, Amy Landecker stole the show as Madeleine’s mother Rhea, who portrayed a well-intended but clearly hardened parent traumatized by her daughter’s decisions. The three worked very well together and looked like they could be related. The set design and direction clearly showed a split between Rhea and Madeline. There was very smart use of wallpaper and couch setups to show how far apart they were in some ways and how connected they were in others. Caroline offers a great glimpse into motherhood with all its ups and downs, as well as a great exploration of living as a trans person and being a parent of one. I highly recommend it for anyone. (Edited)
1–20 of 33 comments
Wow! Wonderfully written and performed. Everything about this show is heartbreaking and beautiful at the same time. I loved that our seats were so close to the stage that made it feel as if we were a part of Caroline's world.