Bat Boy: The Musical
There are nights when theater feels like pure magic. And then there are nights when you watch a cast of Broadway all-stars throw themselves into something so bizarre you start to wonder if you’ve stumbled into a social experiment. Welcome to Keythe Farley and Brian Flemming’s BAT BOY: THE MUSICAL at New York City Center. A show that begins as delicious, campy fun and ends in a full-blown melodramatic meltdown. Inspired by a 1990s tabloid story and first produced Off-Broadway in 2001, Bat Boy has always hovered between cult favorite and chaotic curiosity. Now it’s back with a newly revised book, additional songs, and direction by Alex Timbers, who brings his usual mix of style, humor, and total commitment. And honestly? For a while, it really works. Act I is a riot from the jump. The show opens with thunder, lightning, and the gloriously catchy “Hold Me, Bat Boy.” Within minutes, it’s clear the cast is stacked and having a blast. Taylor Trensch is magnetic as Bat Boy with twitchy limbs, haunted eyes, and impeccable comic timing. He somehow makes the leap from feral cave creature to posh British gentleman feel completely natural. Kerry Butler, as Meredith Parker, is the show’s heart - funny, grounded, and singing like a dream. And Christopher Sieber, as Dr. Parker, delivers deranged-dad energy at its absolute best. His barked “Get back in the chair!!” had the audience in stitches. Visually, the production is simple but striking: wooden stairs and platforms surrounded by acid-yellow light that glows against City Center’s ornate gold interior. Purple light spills over the stage, giving everything a weirdly pulpy sheen that’s part Southern Gothic, part comic book. Act I rides that tone perfectly. The accents are ridiculous, the choreography is charming, and even the subplot involving a mysteriously pregnant cow somehow lands. Kerry Butler teaching Bat Boy to speak is laugh-out-loud funny. It’s camp done right. Sharp, self-aware, and powered by total conviction. And then… Act II happens. The revival scene opens strong with Jacob Ming-Trent’s booming-voiced preacher practically brings the house down, but after that, the plot veers off a cliff. Suddenly, there’s a tragic backstory told through shadow puppets, a surprise appearance by the god Pan (Alex Newell, who sings “Children, Children” like a divine being), and then a storm of blood, secrets, and animal imagery that has to be seen to be believed. Still, the cast never wavers. Trensch’s commitment makes Bat Boy oddly sympathetic even at his most unhinged. Butler sings every number like her life depends on it. Newell stops the show cold with powerhouse vocals that shake the rafters. The ensemble matches their energy beat for beat, giving everything a sense of purpose and fun even as the story careens wildly. By the end, the audience was audibly reacting, laughing, gasping, cheering, caught up in the sheer audacity of what they were witnessing. The energy and skill onstage are impossible not to admire. I left the theater humming “Hold Me, Bat Boy,” laughing at the audacity of what I’d just seen, and genuinely impressed that this cast managed to keep it all together. “Bat Boy: The Musical” is a spectacular mess, half brilliant, half bonkers, and never boring. Act I is tight, witty, and full of heart. Act II feels like someone spilled three different scripts on the floor and decided to stage them all at once. If you like your musicals big, bloody, and completely unhinged, this one’s for you. Everyone else might want to duck and cover.
It was fine. Silly story which I can get on board with but the songs aren't all that memorable and the ridiculousness of it just isnt clever enough to hit the mark. Cast was still great. The sound design was difficult though. The band felt muted and even out of sync at times with the cast.
Definitely needs work. The cast was fun and the story is very camp which I loved. We had fun but the songs are forgettable and the set was very lack luster. I think it could be great but not where it would need to be to extend imo.
The crowd went wild. There were some great moments like the beloved Three Bedroom House, though the ending still feels like an afterthought. Nonetheless, a fun production for the spooky season.
That book was fucking ridiculous but it had its good moments! Incredible performances by all. (Edited)
Over the top campy horror comedy.
Silly campy musical. Unfortunately, you won't leave humming any of the songs.
I couldn't stop thinking about the "baby boy I need you" song from It's Always Sunny
#OffBroadway
I was so excited to see this show back onstage..after seeing it 5 times back in 2000…but they changed so much! The humor is gone, the good songs are gone. I was happy to it alive again, but wish they kept it edgy. Kerry Butler is absolutely fantastic!!
Had to give it a second chance and I was still let down. The original in 2001 was everything! Campy, hysterical, dirty and amazing music. Now they cut songs and jokes. I will say Kerry Butler’s performance was absolutely brilliant!
I- huh?
It’s extremely funny with great music. A fantastic cast! They changes a lot from the original 2001 production
A horror musical comedy in the vein of Little Shop, Evil Dead, and Toxic Avenger, but not nearly as funny, sharp, or tuneful as any of those three. The score is generally weak, save for 3-4 numbers and, despite a gleefully game (and starry) cast, the comedy doesn’t always land. While the first act gained momentum after a rocky start (and I generally enjoyed it), I couldn’t wait for the second act to end. While the always excited-to-be-there crowd at City Center was dolling out a lot of applause, I overheard several audience members offering their friends very tepid post-show reviews. (Edited)
This show is not for me. Though I didn’t care for it, I’m very happy to have seen it. I love City Center for that reason exactly!! I love that they do shows seldomly produced with a great production value and excellent talent so that we’re all given the chance to see them.
What even was this show? Everyone was laughing but the jokes were not funny at all. The storyline was poor and made no sense. The songs sucked but the singing was good. The set looked like a child’s jungle gym. I was bored out of my mind that I was instead of being engaged in the show I was counting the number of songs left. Waste of money
Community Performance that had such a supportive audience! Fun show. Just miss the stuff they changed or took out.
I love this show and the music, so I was a little disappointed to see so many awesome songs cut and replaced with different songs that did not fit as well in my opinion. I didn’t get the approach they took, and struggle to see where they were coming from. I feel like the show is popular for what it is, and redoing a surprisingly large amount of the plot and music took away from the identity it had in my mind before.
Who’s the real monster here? 👀🦇 The answer comes wrapped in rock riffs, blood, and delicious camp in this production of Bat Boy. Beneath the laughs and larger-than-life chaos, the show bites into something real: how every generation rediscovers its monsters and disguises cruelty as righteousness. It’s outrageous, clever, and uncomfortably current, daring us to see who’s really hiding behind the pitchforks. The satire may sparkle, but the mirror it holds up is deadly serious.
61–80 of 80 comments
I will admit that sometimes you just don't like the plot of a show. This one made me uncomfortable. Maybe it was because of weird bloody gore, but more likely it was because Taylor Trench is so freakishly good at the physicality of Bat Boy that you almost forget he isn't actually half-bat. This show itself is part Death Becomes Her (if Chris Sieber loses it more quickly), a bit Heathers (with Andrew Durand being such a mean teen that I almost wish he was a corpse again), and a bit Little Shop (with puppetry and lots of cravings for blood) Every performance, particularly the vocals, from this stellar cast was memorable, I'm just not sure I this plot is one I want to remember.