About
Tony nominee Taylor Trensch (Floyd Collins) stars as Edgar, a half-human, half-bat teen whose discovery in a cave sparks chaos in a small West Virginia town in Bat Boy: The Musical. When Edgar is taken in by the kind-hearted Meredith Parker—played by original 2001 cast member Kerry Butler (Heathers The Musical)—he embarks on a journey to win over a skeptical community with charm, grace, and a few unexpected dance moves. But as tensions rise and secrets unravel, the town must confront its own hunger for scapegoats. Is Edgar the monster they fear—or the mirror they refuse to face?
Inspired by a 1990s tabloid sensation, Bat Boy became a cult classic after its Off-Broadway debut in 2001. With a pop-rock score by Tony nominee Laurence O'Keefe (Legally Blonde: The Musical) and direction by Tony winner Alex Timbers (Just In Time, Moulin Rouge!), this revival balances horror with heart, turning a tale of fear into a darkly comic story of belonging. Now, with expanded orchestrations and several brand-new songs by the original creators, this production delves deeper into the musical’s themes of identity, acceptance, and the healing power of love.
Perfectly timed for the Halloween season, this joyfully twisted tale invites audiences to laugh, cry, and cheer for the bat-boy who just wants to belong.
Cast & Creatives
Story and Book by Keythe Farley and Brian Flemming Music and Lyrics by Laurence O'Keefe Directed by Alex Timbers
Seat Views
View all 12 seat viewsCommunity Discussion
Batboy was amazing! I went in not knowing anything about the original show, solely for my favorite actors/broadway performers (Andrew Durand and Alex Newell). Little did I know their parts were “small”… but wow let me tell you Alex Newell as the God Pan, gave Shucked Independently Owned #iykyk. But of course the show was beyond spectacular with so many laugh out loud moments amazing performances by Kerry Butler, Taylor Trensch and the entire cast! I’m unsure if Batboy is in my top 3 shows of this year or if its my number one. (Edited)
this was sooo good!! i loved the music and it was soo funny. taylor did so good as bat boy and loved kerry butler. i went in blind and i was gasping by the end, such a good show!
LOVED ITTTTT. I had never seen this or listened to this musical before and omg. Such a crazy funny zany time - actors have scripts in hand sometimes which I did not expect, but enjoyed. Overall still a very polished show with some mega stars. Gabi Carubba and Taylor Trensch are rising stars for sure.
Wow, I love a wild ride show like this one! The insanity and laughs from start to finish make each moment worth it. I did miss a few songs from the older version of the show (I’ve been a Bat Boy stan for awhile) but the new updates, specifically the additions for the daughter Shelly were still a fantastic evolution for the piece. There is also an incredible number of stand out performances in this piece and I’m so glad a show like this, that doesn’t often get the spotlight, got some real stage time in a wonderful theater like City Center!




sleeping in a tent doesn’t match the levels of camp this show reaches. they could have brought michael jackson back to life on stage in MJ and it would’ve been less shocking than what happened on stage at new york city center tonight. who can say if ive been changed for the better…