All In: Comedy About Love
So funny, all star cast. Coming back to Broadway in a sequel, story of life.
I love goofs.
Loved this so much! Fantastic cast and story telling!!
Closest I’ll come to an SNL performance
it was amazing
Hilarious
Sweet - fun
𝐀𝐋𝐋 𝐋𝐈𝐍, 𝐍𝐨𝐭 𝐀𝐥𝐥-𝐈𝐧 The only reason I wanted to watch this was ALL because of LIN—and he did not disappoint. His performance made this show bearable. While some of the other cast members had their moments, Lin was the most consistent, truly performing rather than just reading. I had already seen the negative reviews, and I completely agree—it felt like just a staged reading, with eight stories that were mostly a miss. I honestly don’t understand why this show is so overpriced. Thankfully, I got to see it for cheap because spending more than $50 would have been a waste—unless you’re only paying to see the celebrity, not for the show itself. On a positive note, there were three things I liked that made the show at least somewhat enjoyable: 1. The music and score – It fit the mood perfectly, and while there weren’t many musical moments, the singing was beautiful. 2. The stage design – Visually stunning, and even from the balcony, the view was great. 3. The background animations – Each story had a creative visual element, but it still felt lacking in helping the audience connect with the narratives. As a graphic designer, I also have to say—why use Cooper Black for the logo and playbill?! The font used in the stage background was much more elegant and would have suited the show better. As for the stories themselves, I kept asking, where is the love? It’s Valentine’s season, and yet most of the stories weren’t compelling or lacks the heart of a good love story. I was expecting to laugh or cry, to walk out thinking, “somehow heartbreak feels good in a play like this”—but this show failed to make me feel anything. Overall, I’m not ALL-IN on recommending this play. If you’re a visual person like me, you might struggle to appreciate it. The concept of telling multiple stories in one play is interesting, but it needs to be an actual performance, not just a reading. FAVORITE STORY: New Clients (Edited)
I loved seeing a cohort of artists that I’ve looked up to since middle school and I enjoyed the stories; however, I’m conflicted about the show’s price point and relaxed format on a Broadway stage. The lighting and set itself became a character in of itself which helped add to the bare bones format of a reading. Some of the stories ran a little long for me, and I wish there were more short stories to help split them up. All in all, I enjoyed myself at the price point I spent; however, if I paid more, I would find myself disappointed.
I was extremely stoked for this (and don’t get me wrong, I had a great time) but couldn’t help but be slightly disappointed; it’s a cast of incredible storytellers reading these adorable little stories backed by The Freaking Bensons but,,, I was left wanting so much more!! it’s less a play than it is a star-studded staged reading and I feel like Simon’s stories would lend themselves way better to a full staged production than this. still a fun time!!! Def worth seeing 3/5 (Edited)
Once I lowered my expectations for what this show was (readings of short stories from armchairs and not actual skits), it was fun and enjoyable. It was nothing groundbreaking and the stories were funny but not hilarious. Had the marketing been straightforward from the beginning of what this show was I might have felt different about it, but the prices they charged for what it was doesn't seem worth it to me.
I saw Jonathan Groff in the audience, and Fred Armisen and Richard Kind signed my playbill! Fred also signed a drumstick for me!
I really did enjoy this show / staged reading. I just puzzle at the prices and marketing. The stories and the music were good but did not seem to fit a Broadway stage with Broadway prices. (Edited)
Pretty much just a reading. I felt disappointed about the performance. The actors read stories from a script while seated for the entire performance. The stories themselves are ok, but not special.
It was amazing seeing some of my comedy heroes, but the show itself is kinda simple. Glad I didn’t pay more than I did! (Edited)
Insanely great seats and show! Thank you!!!
really sweet show! loved the stories. left something to be desired though. def not traditional broadway. enjoyed but wouldn’t pay more than $70! def don’t pay $100 something. nick kroll and Andrew Rannells were great together and so were Aidy and Lin!!! amazing cast of actors :) didn’t love ending… but great show still
41–60 of 83 comments
Very cute