All In: Comedy About Love
I loved it! What a cool concept to get new diverse audiences to broadway with a rotating cast! It is the same play each time but just with different people all from Simon Rich’s different works. Tonight Lin Manuel Miranda, Tim Meadows, David Cross, Annaleigh Ashford were in it and it was a relaxed environment distracting me from my single love life and the cold outside! The music sung by The Bengsons was very fresh and contemporary too. The Hudson theater is a staple itself so get there early and enjoy a drink in their lounge prior to!
A fun evening. Highlights were The Big Nap with LMM and AA and Pirate scene with Hank & Tim. Loved all the voices Hank did and he was 100% off book!
My kind of show: A live storytelling event. Felt like a Moth event or like you’re at a literary society. An excellent cast and some beautiful stories. They were so well written and thoughtfully assembled together. Some (baby detective, history report) were better than others (scientist) but overall very good. An endearing evening all around. This isn’t a play. It’s a reading — fully on book for the entire show (except for the first ten minutes). Go in with the right expectations, and you’ll come out grinning and full of joy. Wanna watch Arrested Development?
The reviews for this seem very mixed, partially because the cast changes frequently making it harder to review, and partially because it's not a classic scripted Broadway show. It's a reading, and Lin Manuel Miranda and Annaleigh Ashford are absolutely marvelous. Their ability to interact and tell stories through impeccable comedic timing and facial reactions makes this a lovely evening out. The addition of musical interludes is charming, too. Some stories were more captivating than others, sure, and I wished that all the performers were a little more off-book. I agree with reviewers who warn about the big named celebrities, so my advice is go for the stage actors as they will not disappoint. Lin and Annaleigh were "all in" and worth it.
A lot of people didn’t like that they sat there and read stories but i loved it. i thought it showed off their creative sides wonderfully. just a good fun show. my mom’s birthday present and she was happy so that’s all you could ask for. my 77th show. 7/10. (Edited)
This was such a fun show!! They couldn’t stop cracking each other up and that made it even funnier!! Jimmy was hilarious of course but Nick Kroll really stole the show. We had so much fun at this one. Also, it was snowing when we came out so that’s always fun!
Simon Rich’s writing is off-kilter enough to be adorable, and the cast I saw was led by a razor-sharp John Mulaney in top form. It’s not a play so much as an essay reading.
Very cute show! Definitely not what I was expecting, but enjoyed it all the same. The show is a very informal reading of short stories themed around love wrapped up in 90 minutes. It didn’t feel rushed or too long, the runtime was perfect. The set was gorgeous and homey, with beautiful projections of illustrations to set the scene. The stories themselves were cute, some with messages of love and some with just a funny punchline. It was a real treat to see John Mulaney, any fans of his should try to see this if they can! He is such a great storyteller (mostly off-book, king) and can command a stage like no other.
After seeing this, I take back everything bad I said about the setup of this piece because it was perfect. Seeing each actor really take the roles and add a charm to the readings was such a surprise. I now can’t wait till Simon Rich’s All Out.
I really enjoyed it, comparable to Love Letters for a modern age, although Mulaney was fully off book, and Fred Armisen mostly was too. Richard Kind relied on the book more, although it often fit the stories for him to be reading directly from "notes".
I went into this will low expectations as I read some disgruntled reviews, but I’m so glad I went. I laughed the entire night!!
very funny!!! loved the stories!!! second rotation cast first night. LIN!
The absolute best way to spend Valentine’s Day - “All In” had us laughing out loud! Seeing Lin Manuel Miranda was a gift, but Hank Azaria stole the show. I can’t wait to see “All Out!”
Was a fun comedy seeing it with Lin and Nick Kroll was something special.
So sweet and funny! Short stories, all about love with musical interludes inbetween and an all star cast. A bit like a reading, so much fun!
Got to see Lin Manuel Miranda, Jimmy Fallon and Nick Kroll and Aidy Bryant. Loved it! Laughed so much that night.
very cute! it was a dream to finally see LMM in person :)
1–20 of 83 comments
As someone who went out of a love for 69 Love Songs, not really expecting to be very amused because I don't fw SNL like that, I found it decently funny the whole way through!! The MagFields covers were to die for, of course. Some outright in between stories, some mixed in with the score of the stories. Yeah, it's a reading, but I feel like I got what l wanted out of it overall. I cried during All My Little Words, and I really do hope they record this score, or at least the fuller covers. (Edited)