Wonderful Town
it was meh. i genuinely can’t discern any deeper meaning than two sister move to nyc to build their dream careers, get taken advantage of until the 11 o clock number where they both somehow land jobs (not even the ones they truly aspired to) and the sister who was always second best gets a man. yay? oh and the song from glee idk there were a whole lotta men on that stage for a show about sisters navigating life together, and they were mainly just there to be misogynistic. i know this is an old one, but honestly what was the point? especially when you remember they also did urinetown and ragtime in the past year - this felt very anticlimactic. (yes i know it was supposed to be wild party, but you lost that and picked this???? out of every other show????) cast was fine, music was good, lyrics were 50/50 and the book was bleh
Directing was very poorly done, and timid. Actresses voices were stunning but it didn’t make up for a poorly paced, timidly directed show that didn’t live up to the lofty director’s vision shared in the playbill…
This show has not aged well. The jokes didn’t land and the music is not Bernstein’s best. Not to mention, this performance had many flubbed lines so pacing was off. Quite a bummer.
“Wonderful Town” isn’t much of a story, and that has seemed beside the point from its inception. The 1953 musical is a collection of bizarre situations designed to highlight two things: the music of Leonard Bernstein and the lyrics of Betty Comden and Adolph Green, and the power of its star, film legend Rosalind Russell. How else do you wind up with a football fight song, an Irish ballad and step dance featuring a lineup of cops, and a conga line with our heroine and a bunch of Brazilian sailors? In this revival by New York City Center Encores!, all that over-the-top absurdity survives intact. What’s missing is the core that holds the whole thing together. The original creative team tailored every inch of this show to 46-year-old Russell: an expressive face that registers in the upper balcony; an arch sense of humor and comic timing; a madcap energy; and a lower vocal range. (Russell was not a trained singer.) Her replacement – a game Anika Noni Rose as Ruth – has Russell beat hands down in the vocal department. But hard as Rose tries – she leans in best on “Conga!” – she’s just not ridiculous enough. (The Encores! program notes that this is the 6th revival, and previous Ruths have been broad comedians like Nancy Walker, Kaye Ballard and Elaine Stritch.) Rose’s finest moments come when Ruth and her sister, Eileen (a fine Aisha Jackson) sing the wistful ballad “Ohio.” For a minute, the Encores! Orchestra comes in quietly, allowing two beautiful voices to soar. (Edited)
Slow. Poor staging. Bad comedy.
21–26 of 26 comments
Very boring play. It's a classic and this take has wonderful singing and dancing. But it's still a boring script. Which is to be expected of the first “musical” to be produced. It was probably very entertaining in the early 20th century