What If They Ate The Baby?
Natasha Roland and Xhloe Rice’s WHAT IF THEY ATE THE BABY? at SoHo Playhouse is a show that lures you in with the familiarity of 1950s suburbia, bright dresses, spotless floors, and the trappings of domestic order, then gleefully upends it. Roland and Rice have crafted a production that is simultaneously charming, unsettling, and delightfully unpredictable. Shirley, dressed head-to-toe in yellow, and Dottie, in matching pink, dominate the stage with outfits streaked in green paint, gestures precise yet exaggerated, and smiles just sharp enough to feel like warnings. The chemistry between them is electric: there’s humor, tension, and an undercurrent of something unsaid that keeps the audience leaning forward. The two performers balance absurdity and control in a way that makes every movement and expression feel carefully calibrated, yet completely alive. The set is deceptively simple but endlessly effective. Empty window frames hang at odd angles overhead, while a small table and chairs sit on a stark black-and-white tile floor. On first glance, it looks minimal but every detail, from the placement of a chair to the tiniest shadow, contributes to a sense that the space itself is watching. The lighting and sound design are subtle co-conspirators: dings, distant footsteps, and fleeting noises give the performance a quiet tension that lingers beneath the humor. Part of the show’s magic is how it bends theatrical rules without ever losing the audience. Loops, repetitions, and carefully timed choreography create patterns that are mesmerizing, hilarious, and just a little unnerving. Rice and Roland inhabit their characters fully, committing to each beat in a way that makes the strange feel urgent and the absurd feel precise. There’s a rhythm to the performance that keeps the audience alert, amused, and slightly off-kilter, and it’s executed with remarkable skill. What makes What If They Ate the Baby? especially compelling is its trust in the audience. It offers mood, tension, and style rather than exposition or easy answers, inviting viewers to inhabit the uncanny world it builds. Every element: costumes, set, sound, and movement is aligned to that singular vision, creating a production that feels cohesive, yet unpredictable. It’s edgy, witty, and undeniably original, a show that lingers in the mind not for plot twists but for the way it makes you feel while watching. If Xhloe Rice and Natasha Roland continue to produce theater with this level of commitment, imagination, and weirdness, it’s safe to say audiences will be eager for whatever comes next. What If They Ate the Baby? is delightfully bizarre, elegantly strange, and a vivid reminder of how daring, thoughtful, and playful theater can still be.
Incredible comedy duo, they had a post show talk back but I couldn’t stay for it. Excited to see what these two do in the future
Solid show. More interesting than other shows I've seen. Know going in there are strobe lights at times.
Amazing. Only one more night!
Such a fantastic and brilliant show, I highly recommend (Edited)
After Epst33n filed being released …. I wonder more about the name of this show and what it portrayed. What it’s saying about society. I just really circle back to this show a lot and try to work out exactly what happened and what it means….
1–7 of 7 comments
Super duper highly recommend! I’ve NEVER seen a production like this !!!! I swear these women deserve everything! The dancing was …. Something strange and excellent and precise and so perfectly aligned. The words were cyclical but powerful and …. In the end your head is left swimming and spinning . You go home thinking about this play for hours and shifting back and forth from your interpretations. If you don’t see this production you’re doing yourself a disservice. I think particularly women and queer folks may love this. However, everyone would enjoy this. It’s like watching pure genius in front of your eyes and being able to enjoy it. The two actors are the writers. Fantastic work, ladies! 👏🏽 (Edited)