Well, I’ll Let You Go
4.5/5⭐️ Surprisingly heartbreaking. Well written drama on mourning sprinkled in with quirky characters. Unexpectedly interesting plot developments. Maybe not your thing: very hard to hear at times, potentially dark secrets drama. Diversity: little. A main character is a cis straight middle aged Black woman but race is not a part of the plot. 1 hour 50 minutes; no intermission. Ticket from online rush (TodayTix) for $39.
Thought-provoking show, very interesting way audience was fairly immersed in the set, excellent acting and realistic depiction of grief over the long haul, a mother’s struggles, and not depressing!
A lovely sad-but-sweet play. While the plot isn’t necessarily unique, it unfurls in a way that’s unexpected, touching, and sometimes even gasp-inducing. This is one of those plays that forces you to lean in, and the cast does a remarkable job navigating the realistic dialogue.
i died tonight. what a performance. everyone in that cast is so incredible and dedicated to telling this incredibly written story.
An understated, slow-burning play about grief and community. Beautiful and intimate performance space.
Loved it; very moving, emotional yet restrained, terrific ensemble cast.
This may be the perfect play & a quiet, beautiful, mysterious & poignant production. It is a privilege to have experienced & been changed by it. Thank you Bubba. Jack, Quincy, Michael & truly stellar ensemble.
I miss Michael Chernus, but I still love this play so much. Thank goodness original stories like this are still being produced with top notch direction and casts.
Absolutely excellent - captures so many of the real feelings experienced while grieving someone (Edited)
Well, I’ll Let You Go The Space at Irondale, Brooklyn | Written by Bubba Weiler | Directed by Jack Serio Some plays remind you exactly why you fell in love with theatre in the first place. Well, I’ll Let You Go is one of them. With this debut, actor-turned-playwright Bubba Weiler announces himself as a formidable new voice — and if this is his first step into playwriting, we should all be eager to see what comes next. Directed by Jack Serio, one of the most exciting directors working today, the production unfolds like a slow-burning candle: quiet at first, then glowing with a fierce, unshakable light by its end. Set in a small Midwestern town, Well, I’ll Let You Go is a portrait of a woman and a community in crisis. It moves back and forth through time, piecing together the collapse of a marriage, a town, and a version of the American Dream that no longer holds. What could easily feel heavy or sprawling instead lands as deeply human — expansive in its scope, yet astonishingly intimate. The cast? Sublime. Quincy Tyler Bernstine delivers a performance so raw and magnetic it leaves your jaw on the floor. Michael Chernus brings a complexity to his role that quietly builds before hitting with full force, while Cricket Brown, Will Dagger, Emily Davis, Danny McCarthy, Constance Shulman, and Amelia Workman round out an ensemble that doesn’t just inhabit this town — they are this town. Every actor feels indispensable, their contributions fusing together into something greater than the sum of its parts. Serio, whose work continues to raise the bar, once again proves why he’s one of today’s best directors. The production embraces simplicity: a bare-bones set that evolves with the story, restrained lighting that does more than any soundtrack could — particularly in the final moments, where it delivers a powerful message and a beautiful surprise — and a refusal to clutter the stage with anything unnecessary. It’s theatre in its purest form — words, bodies, and silence used with precision. There’s also a quiet brilliance in how the set tells its own story. At first, its bareness feels like a reflection of lives stripped down to survival — a marriage, a family, and a community holding on with whatever they have. But by the play’s final moments, the space evolves, revealing an unexpected beauty that reframes everything we’ve seen. It’s a simple, stunning metaphor: that even in the smallest, most fractured lives, there is something whole and worth cherishing when love and understanding finally come into focus. There are moments of humor, bursts of tenderness, and turns that hit like gut punches. Just when you think you’ve figured out where the story is going, it pivots, reminding you that life rarely moves in straight lines. The Space at Irondale, tucked into a beautiful corner of Brooklyn, feels like the perfect venue for this piece — intimate enough to make us feel like we’re part of the town itself, sitting beside our “neighbors” as they reveal their secrets. And on a personal note, meeting Serio and telling him how much I appreciate his work was a thrill. As was catching a glimpse of Bubba Weiler himself in the audience — along with a few famous faces, including Bobby Cannavale and Ryan J. Haddad, there to support this powerful new play. This one’s cleared for takeoff — a soaring debut that reminds us of theatre’s greatest power: to hold up a mirror to our lives and leave us changed.
A powerfully human play exploring grief in relation to community. This will resonate profoundly with anyone who has ever truly mourned a loved one. It captures that very particular and very heavy obligation of responsibility looming in a world that’s crumbling around you. We’re not allowed to fade away when our life is flipped by the loss of someone essential. Death may be determined, but the compassion we bring others in regard to loss is entirely up to us 🎈
If this show doesn’t make you cry, I don’t know what to tell you
More thoughts to come but what a beautifully done play. Acting writing directing all working together - beautiful. Go!
Beautiful play. I saw it in Brooklyn and again at Seaview. It’s so well done and moving. I loved it!!
Rebecca was great, and everything went smoothly.
A very moving, thoughtful portrait of loss and love. Really enjoyed. Great script and plot.
Really wonderful. So well cast, well written, moving. No muss no fuss set and costumes. A story simply told and beautifully acted. I'd see it again.
A spectacular show with a stellar cast. If you’re looking to feel the full spectrum of human emotion all in one evening, this is for you.
Absolutely brilliant. Best thing I’ve seen in a while
1–20 of 42 comments
It grows slowly, one line at a time. I let my guard down as it began, and by the end I was broken. I have a feeling i’ll be thinking about this one for a while. Def recommend! (Edited)