Water for Elephants
Beautiful show and the acrobatic acts are insane!
Beautiful show and the circus acts are insane!
“Water for Elephants” has its cool moments but didn’t fully deliver a spectacular show. I tried my best to keep an open mind, but having watched the film, I couldn’t help being disappointed by the change in the overall mood of the story. This show turned the entire story into a comedy circus when it was supposed to be a romantic drama, making it hard for me to connect emotionally. I couldn’t take the dramatic parts seriously because of the poor writing and directing choices. Kyle Selig and Isabelle McCalla have beautiful singing voices, but the songs weren’t powerful enough to make a lasting impact. The acrobat stunts were incredible to watch, and it amazes me that they do that every single show. However, the costumes and production felt underwhelming and lacked creativity. Using scaffolding to represent the train didn’t quite work for me, and I think the LED background could’ve been used better to make the scenes feel more real. The scene-to-scene transitions were also messy, with people moving set pieces during monologues, which was so distracting. I also was not impressed with the puppetry because it felt amateur, though it improved when the full elephant puppet appeared. The choice to have Isabelle and Paul play multiple roles was confusing, the show should have hired additional cast members for those roles. Overall, while “Water for Elephants” had some thrilling stunts and strong vocal performances, it missed the mark in capturing the depth and emotional tone of the story. (Still watchable for the acrobat)
Whoof. I heard mixed reviews so I didn't have extremely high expectations, but I was holding out hopes. And on paper, it was great! The use of acrobatics was so freaking cool and unbelievable. The set design was awesome, the costumes were beautiful, the use of color in the lighting was incredible... but the book needed to be WAY tighter. Act one was worse in this regard. It felt so long and the scenes were so boring. Then, oh, the poor music... the ENTIRE score needs to be almost entirely scrapped and restarted. The songs are unremarkable and forgettable. Overall, I'm glad I saw it. The acrobatics and puppetry made it worth it. But it has sooo much potential and totally fell flat!! (Edited)
It is only right to start with this fact: the physical work of this company is extraordinary and they deserve all the praise in the world for the stunts they pull off every night. I unfortunately did not enjoy much else of this production. Not having seen the movie, I thought the plot was predictable and clichéd. I found the score to be almost entirely sub-par, with the exception of Easy, which was actually breathtaking thanks to Isabelle McCalla and Antoine Boissereau. In particular, there were several moments of ensemble “counterpoint” that were 100% unintelligible, it was honestly shocking that they kept incorporating multi-part singing throughout the show because every single example was a train wreck (pun intended). Sondheim would’ve wept. Always thrilled to see Sara Gettelfinger; Gregg Edelman is a treasure; Stan Brown was a standout amongst the feature roles. I’m also a bit put off by this trend (as in Outsiders) for like, deliberately unattractive/nondescript sets that never really transform or transport.
Came to NYC specifically to see Grant Gustin in his Broadway debut and the show left something to be desired. Never have I ever watched a musical where I hated ALL the songs! It doesn’t move the story forward and no song stood out. The acrobatics is super cool and impressive, but otherwise was quite a disappointment. I read the book and enjoyed it, never saw the movie, but definitely skip this musical. (Edited)
The cast is really talented, and the acrobatics are cool, but there’s many instances where the suspension of disbelief is broken. I can’t say I necessarily enjoyed this one. It feels random and the story is a little hard to follow at parts, with random acrobatics thrown in it. I can see why it’s closing.
isabella mccalla was amazing, truly made the show. also the “horse” arial acrobat was so incredible he had us in awe. the circus acts in general were very cool to watch. that being said, the acting from the other principals was mostly mediocre, and the story wasn’t that memorable. the score was also pretty basic it felt like they were trying to be the greatest showman, but really just weren’t that great.
There are aspects of this show that were enjoyable (the acrobatics, though repetitive and not central to the plot, are fun to watch) but the music is utterly forgettable (sounds like an AI wrote it) and the scenery/puppets seemed cheap looking to me. I wanted to love it. I did not.
…why am I the only one who disliked this show. The book sucked, the direction was meh, circus stuff was kinda cool but THERE IS NO EXCUSE FOR THAT TERRIBLE ELEPHANT PUPPET DEAR GOD.
It was a little underwhelming. The actors did put their best work, but some scenes were dragged out or flat out boring. Music was easy to forget. They leaned heavily on their acrobatic numbers. It could be so much better, but was average IMO
Lots of talent onstage trying to do their best with an underwhelming score and book. I would save your money for this despite the impressive acrobatics and vocals by Kyle Selig. I found myself bored and felt the show was dragging the majority of the time... (Edited)
The acrobats were fun to watch but the show itself isn’t good
The music had to feeling and no where to go. I couldn’t remember one song. Sad
So plain that i fall asleep, so did to my friend
First time walking out at an intermission
my mom says this is the worst show
sooooo boring and they don't even give water to the elephants in it. book is more interesting if anything
161–180 of 186 comments
music was awful but the story was interesting