Walden
Interesting plot, interesting acting, left me wanting more but happy to be at Second Stage one last time!
Very glad to have caught this play. Walden follows Cassie’s (Winters) reunion with her twin sister, Stella (Rossum). Set in the near-future, the world is past the brink of climate change, and Cassie is a successful NASA astronaut seeking to bring mankind to the stars. Stella and her fiancé Bryan have found refuge in a pocket of beautiful Earth amid the world falling apart. As they discuss Cassie’s mission and the fate of the Earth, they also revisit their own sisterhood and navigate mending the relationship between them. All three actors are very compelling, with Winter and Rossum creating a beautifully tender, tense and delicate depiction of sisterhood. The casting and direction brings it together and touches at the emotional heart of being siblings that are distant. Winter’s performance made me tear up a bit. (Edited)
Amazing and futuristic
wow! the set was immersive and beautiful, sound was great. writing didn’t flow ALL of the time, some moments seemed unnatural. BUT this show is important at a time where we are at the turning point for this earth. Also my sister’s name is Cassie, and I cried
Zoe Winters was out and I saw the show with the understudy. The understudy was lovely and put in a good performance but as a Zoe Winters fan, I was still disappointed. I can’t help but think it’s a different show with Winters. What I saw was still worth recommending.
I am so disappointed by this production, and this season at the Tony Kiser theatre in general. It’s really rare where I go see something and consider leaving early. I usually have the patience to wait to see if the play goes anywhere, but after seeing Breaking the Story here a couple months ago, I knew where this was heading. This play is an infinite hell trap of exposition. If you like explanations being verbally thrown at you for 1.5 hours, you’ll love this. There’s no subtly or subtext in the direction, everything is said to you. The playwriting is extremely weak. First draft weak. If half the lines had been cut, and placed inside the characters heads instead of on the page. Exposition lines like “she always does this, since we were a little kid. This is just like her,” At the end of the play treat the audience like they’re stupid, and incapable of understanding what a character is like after spending over an hour with them. Please. I am begging you. Show what the characters are feeling in contradiction to their words. Walden is literally what you get when you take Uncle Vanya and remove everything remotely interesting out of it. The direction does very little to make up for the already flimsy script. The intimacy work is confusing and overstated. The story doesn’t make much sense. The characters don’t really do much that’s informed by the world around them, because they’re so busy informing the audience about the world. After seeing the northern light in nyc like 4 days ago, the northern lights tech read as super corny and gimmicky. Anyways, I felt terrible about the idea of getting up and leaving right in front of these actors giving their absolute heart out on the stage, so I waited through it. I was really impressed with how much commitment the actors maintained to this production. Please please please give them a good script and some decent direction! And pleaseeee, get away from this apocalyptic climate doom season. No one likes being preached at, show them human behavior and allow them to come to their own conclusions. We know the planet is dying. We know millennials are socially confused by gen z. Stop talking at us, and show us instead. It’s annoying. It’s confusing to me that second stage produced appropriate, the welkin, and this. Everything I see outside the Tony Kiser theatre is really amazing. This This is like 2/10. +2 being for the performances and effort. (Edited)
Loved the design aspects; the set, lighting and sound were great. The acting was stellar. The narrative concept was compelling but the script was indecisive about said concept and the emotional rollercoaster felt undeserved.
Interesting and well acted. But not strong enough as a play.
Walden is upfront about its desire to pose a serious question: in the face of an environmental collapse, should the good people of earth fight to save it or pack it up and head to a place like the moon or Mars? It’s an important question relevant to our times, but oddly, this play casts the question aside in favor of a soapy story about twin sisters and their sibling rivalry. Emmy Rossum as Stella is so harsh and unlikeable that it’s a mystery that partner Bryan (an excellent Motell Foster) bothers with her at all. In the role of her sister, understudy Joanne Goodhart delivered a more nuanced character. But ultimately the playwright did both a disservice by injecting a tired theme into what should have been a thought-provoking story.
1–12 of 12 comments
A thought-provoking and moving script with a revelatory performance from Zoe Winters. Not every choice worked but lots of admiration for what did.