Trophy Boys
Trophy Boys – MCC Theater Tonight I had the chance to witness Trophy Boys at MCC Theater, a play that doesn’t just confront the performance of masculinity — it explodes it. Written by and starring Emmanuelle Mattana, the piece is an absurd, often disturbing satire that dives headfirst into the world of high school debate and the toxic systems it reflects, rewards, and reproduces. From its first breath, the show is jarring. It’s loud, uncomfortable, exaggerated, and purposely off-balance — but none of that feels accidental. Instead, what unfolds is a meticulously constructed dismantling of patriarchy and its many masks. Mattana’s writing peels back the layers of “the good boys,” those elite, articulate, morally polished young men trained to dominate any space they enter — including ours. Watching them twist logic into power games is both hilarious and horrifying. And beneath the satire is something much deeper: a painful truth that sits just under the surface — that feminism, as it stands, has failed women. That the systems we’ve been told to trust were never built with liberation in mind. That gender, as the show so clearly asserts, is not only a scam but a performance that hurts all of us, especially those forced to contort themselves just to survive inside it. The performances are bold and committed across the board. While some moments feel so overacted they almost slip into chaos, that excess often serves the piece — because it’s not trying to feel real, it’s trying to feel true. The non-binary and trans representation throughout the show was not just refreshing, it was essential — this play doesn’t work without it. These are bodies that have lived outside the binary being asked to reenact the very rituals that tried to erase them. It’s haunting. And it’s powerful. Matt Saunders’ set is minimal, soft around the edges, almost deceptively sweet — which only makes the violence (psychic and otherwise) hit harder. The play knows how to wield contrast. Not everyone stood at the curtain call, and maybe that’s the measure of its success. Trophy Boys isn’t about giving you a satisfying arc or clean applause line. It’s about showing you the mess — the kind we inherited, the kind we perform, and the kind we have to undo if we want something better. Mattana closes her program note with a question: “If we can put this on, what can you take off?” After tonight, I’m still thinking about that.
i love gay ppl!!!!!!!! i didn’t know this would take a heavier topic turn but it did a good job of it. really made you face what young boys still must think and feel about girls/women, especially ones of privilege. they’re listeners of the same news, podcasts, rhetoric, etc of the same media that we as adults are but don’t have the experience or even developed brains enough to make understandings of it any different than their peers or parents. a thoughtful play, a lovely and talented cast.
it closed too soon :( it made me laugh and gasp and feel ALL the emotions in the best way possible
Possibly the play I've enjoyed most this year. Sharp, funny, and insightful, with spot-on performances from female and non-binary actors as an all-boys' prep school debate team preparing arguments about feminism. Playwright Emmanuelle Mattana is a standout, as is The Gilded Age's Louisa Jacobson.
I really enjoyed this show! Trophy Boys is about a high school debate team of boys preparing for the championships all played by a stellar queer/gender bending cast. It takes several unexpected twists I won’t give too much away but it really gets into themes reminiscent of John Proctor is the Villain (from the same director). It has some excellent performances especially by Emmanuelle Mattina (who’s also the show’s playwright) and Esco Jouléy. This is a show that really left me thinking about these issues when I left and felt really nuanced. I’d highly recommend it! It sounds like it was previously sold out but it’s been extended. It’s a small theater and I think any seat would be a good one. They also have a rush program.
It was great and really funny! The topic was well written even when brought up a heavy and serious topic. Would watch again!
I adored the writing, the performances (Esco never fails to shine). This play is twisted and is a fun venture into grappling with different forms of masculinity. The play reminded me a lot of sensitive guys by MJ Kaufman. That’s not to say the two can’t coexist. Just noting.
An uncomfortable and highly relevant piece on young men and their connection to feminism.
Really well done and entertaining from start to finish. The actors all did such a good and believable job. This play was both a parody and a serious and nuanced takedown of masculinity and “elite” intellectualism. Not satire though, I don’t think. Highly recommend.
Well done! The acting and themes were clever and deeply familiar in a troubling way.
HIGHLY RECOMMEND! This show is casted with 0 cisgender males, and it adds a lot to the play. I’m loving this pride season on stage! This show was fun but also so relevant and real. Very thought provoking. Go see it ASAP! Also, the set was phenomenal. (Edited)
What a beautifully written, intense, thought-provoking journey through the minds of young men trying to look the world through a different set of eyes. What's most meta for me about this show is that the entire cast is non-binary individuals, playing boys debating feminism! Emmanuelle Mantanna is a genius, and so so young! I can't wait to see all the incredible things stuff they'll do
Very interesting story. Thought provoking. Excellent cast.
it was so funny!! the actors were incredible!
Trophy Boys is a powerful piece, which will give one pause to think. Attached is a photo of the cast plus The Outsiders' Brody Grant in the center.
So necessary.
Outstanding show!!
7/10 strong acting and interesting premise that I think could’ve been pushed further
1–20 of 25 comments
Rushed this morning!!!!!! Tried to not leave crying but got to talk to Emmanuelle Mattana afterwards and started sobbing #SorryGodImNotYourStrongestSoldier