The Seat of Our Pants
It’s trying a lot with and adding a lot to a play that was already pretty divisive (and pretty long) for a lot of people. Michaela Diamond and Ruthie Ann Miles are doing such good and interesting work, and it’s always a treat to see Ally Bonino given fun material. I will admit a 48 minute first act and then a 98 minute second act and third act performed together without another intermission is a big ask for some people, but I went in knowing word of mouth was mixed and had a great time. Glad I saw it
I found this play incomprehensible at LCT, but as an unhinged musical with this absolutely stunning cast (Micaela Diamond is a standout, but no weak links at all) I somehow loved it?? I want a cast album, there are so many songs I want to hear again.
Really fun, a bit messy in all the best ways, and a great cast.
wild and wacky and everything i love in a show about the end of the world it's not far from it's origins in skin of our teeth, and for that i'm grateful - why do too much to a perfect vehicle? it is not going to be everyone's cup of tea, but it's silly and exciting and worth seeing imo
Best to know a bit about Thornton Wilder's Skin of Our Teeth ahead of time. Great musicalized version of the original. I loved it but know it might not be everyone's cup of tea.
Really interesting show. Great prrformances. Very ambitious and moving
Good thinking material. (Edited)
What an ambitious undertaking! There are lyrically rich songs that I definitely would like to hear again. My favorite moment in the show was “Stuff It Down Inside” sung by Mrs. Antrobus, a marvelous Ruthie Ann Miles, Sabina (the maid) played terrifically by Michaela Diamond. The Newman theater at the Public has been rearranged so that the stage is set with audience members on each side of the stage. I really liked that the 11-piece orchestra is split with each half having a prominent space on either side of the performance space. There is a dinosaur and mammoth that show up during the Ice Age that won me over just when I was starting to roll my eyes. In Act II during “Everybody Loves to go to Conventions” sung effectively Shuler Hensley, the parade of animals appears all wearing masks or complete headpieces. I felt a bit mesmerized and thoroughly enjoyed all of the animals especially the monkey for some reason. My mistake, I guess, was going in cold without much knowledge of the source material, Thornton Wilder’s play “The Skin of Our Teeth.” Now that I have reviewed the Wikipedia page for that play, I feel a bit better and recommend it as a pre-course. Ally Bonino is the Fortune Teller and has two solo’s. She sings a song “The Future” which I had a hard time hearing because the band was drowning her out. This song I definitely want to hear again as it fondly reminded me of “Our Disease” from Kimberly Akimbo. It felt like Bonino pointed right at me and predicted a cirrhosis death. Yikes. The pacing at points especially during act 3 felt glacial. It needs trimming as it was getting hard to sit after 2.5 hours. There was a brief stop 1 minute in and a restart. The scenery, especially the application of wallpaper multiple times, seemed to be eating up a lot of time. I’d rethink that element for sure. If you’re a fan of the source material, then it is a must see. Otherwise know what you’re getting into and fasten your seatbelt
We went in blind and were completely confused in the first act, but the show was certainly entertaining even through our confusion. It started to make a little more sense as time went on and the music and acting were all very enjoyable. That said, the time taken to change up the sets and the too-frequent breaking of the fourth wall were annoying, and added little to the experience. The last 20-odd minutes were a complete drag and I couldn't wait for it to be over. Given that we saw it the night after opening night, don't anticipate many changes/trimming at this point. As others have said, would highly recommend reading the wikipedia page for Skin of our teeth before going if you're not familiar with the source material.
There’s some interesting writing here. For those who know the play, you know how odd and off-the-wall it is. Fortunately, the writer leans into that — the script is funny, the book kind of works, and the music is quirky, different, and enjoyable. (It’s kind of indie rock, kind of “Natasha Pierre”.) But because of that weirdness, it makes for a not-wholly-fulfilling musical. You’re kept at arms’ length no matter how much the characters break the fourth wall and try to reel you in. Once the wall goes back up, you’re left peering in, trying to make sense of it all. And this comes from someone who really enjoyed the last NYC production of the play (at Lincoln Center). This musical is in three acts with one intermission between the first and second acts. Only act two really takes off. Act one is a lot of exposition, and act three kind of drags. The cast is amiable, but only Micaela Diamond really stands out. Didn’t love it, didn’t hate it — I’d be interested to see another of Lipton’s musicals. (Edited)
Really fun! There were some great songs and the cast is stellarDefinitely a new musical that still needs developing though. You definitely want to sit on the traditional audience side, not the side they added, they don’t play to that side as much
I really love absurd pieces of theatre and I had a great time at this show (especially the music was gorgeous) but I feel like it’s still in early stages of development so it just needed a bit of tightening in places. All of the performers did fantastic work and the orchestra was a stand out though! I’m glad I got to see it and would come back to see how it grows the next time it goes up!
Review: The Seat of Our Pants The Public Theater – Newman Theater Directed by Leigh Silverman Written by Ethan Lipton The Seat of Our Pants is irreverent, wild, and surprisingly poignant. Ethan Lipton’s clever adaptation of The Skin of Our Teeth feels entirely of-the-moment, blending absurdity with the timeless chaos of human life. The Antrobus family’s 5,000-year struggle with catastrophe becomes a lens for our own anxieties, fears, and small victories — all served with humor, heart, and some seriously catchy music. Standouts like Micaela Diamond deliver powerhouse performances, with Ally Bonino, Ruthie Ann Miles, and Damon Daunno matching that energy. The ensemble pulses with life, and the modern, sometimes self-aware interruptions keep the story playful and alive. The intimacy of the Newman Theater makes you feel fully immersed in their world, heightening both the comedy and the stakes. Set transitions and pacing occasionally drag — the first intermission comes early, leaving the second half feeling a touch long — but clever lighting, effective sound, and a smart, lived-in set keep you engaged. Once the technical kinks are smoothed out, this musical has real potential to soar. I look forward to a cast album recording of this one! Final Verdict: ✈️✈️✈️½ (3.5/5) Quirky, wild, and utterly human — buckle in for a ride that’s chaotic, charming, and entirely memorable.
This show is certainly not on my recommendation list. Was my 250th show of the year & it’s in the bottom 1% almost certainly, despite a pull of stellar casting, the show left me wanting it to end. I’d also strongly advise not going if you’re unfamiliar with the source material.
1–17 of 17 comments
A few minutes into Ethan Lipton’s THE SEAT OF OUR PANTS, a dinosaur and a woolly mammoth wandered across the stage because it was getting way too cold outside. And that’s when I realized I had no idea what was happening, but I was completely on board. Lipton’s new musical is a delightfully unhinged spin on Thornton Wilder’s The Skin of Our Teeth. It’s part existential comedy, part family drama, part fevered end-of-the-world cabaret, and somehow, it all hangs together thanks to a wildly committed cast. The Antrobus family has apparently been alive for 5,000 years, which checks out, because they look exhausted. They’ve lived through floods, fires, and pandemics, and still argue about dinner. Sabina, their maid and occasional narrator (played by Micaela Diamond), might be the show’s chaotic soul. She sings, “We made it through the recession, pandemic, wildfires, oligarchy by the seat of our pants,” and keeps repeating it until the audience laughs the way she wants them to. It’s manic, funny, and a perfect snapshot of this show’s energy. The set looks like a suburban living room that’s quietly losing its mind: green carpet, retro wallpaper, two wingback chairs, and a brick fire pit. The eleven-piece orchestra sits on either side of the stage in matching sweater vests that also match the wallpaper. They occasionally chime in with background vocals and perfectly timed side-eye. I loved it. Ruthie Ann Miles is radiant as Mrs. Antrobus, holding the whole thing together with her beautiful voice and this calm, slightly exasperated warmth. Her song “Stuff It Down Inside,” a funny, straight-faced anthem about emotional repression, brought down the house. Damon Daunno (as Henry, formerly known as Cain) has major chaos energy, and Ally Bonino’s Fortune Teller gets huge laughs when she looks audience members dead in the eye and predicts their deaths. Act II jumps to Atlantic City, and suddenly the wallpaper’s gone, everything’s beach-themed, and everyone’s in red vests. “Everybody Loves to Go to Conventions” turns into a full-on Noah’s Ark-style animal parade and I was both confused and delighted the entire time. Sure, it runs long. Some bits could be tighter. But the music is clever, the cast is stacked, and the commitment is off the charts. By the time the cast (and even a few orchestra members!) burst into a final, unhinged dance number, the whole theater was buzzing. I walked out grinning and laughing with no clue about what I just saw, but I absolutely had a blast. Delightfully unhinged, beautifully sung, and powered by chaos in the best possible way. “The Seat of Our Pants” is messy, meaningful, and very much alive - just like the rest of us trying to survive by, well, the seat of our pants.