The Picture of Dorian Gray
As expected Sarah Snook is a revelation! The show was excellent but lost its footing when trying to go beyond theatre magic. I don’t want to spoil it for anyone but towards the latter half of the show it feels like they go too far into watching a movie on stage instead of having the cameras add to what’s happening in front of us.
The Picture of Dorian Gray is one of the most inventive shows on Broadway. This production blends the live performance of one actor, Sarah Snook, with prerecorded scene work and voiceover (also done by Snook) to seamlessly create a single narrator presentation of this classic story. The journey of the title character could not be more timely in an age where social media, AI and plastic surgery are altering the way we define human beauty. The most impressive thing about Sarah Snook’s performance is her timing. Working with so many technical elements, Snook’s ability to appear as if she is talking to herself while also switching between characters is spectacular. Hats off to the hardworking crew who not only create beautiful scenes on screen with their camerawork but also build the world around Snook through the ever changing set pieces and props. It’s thrilling to see all that goes into making a shot work from behind the camera. Yet even with all of these compelling components, I still walked away from the show feeling unsatisfied. I’ve said this before and I’ll say it again; in a world that is so saturated with screens, I have little interest in seeing a Broadway show where the majority of the story is presented on a large screen. I know there are plenty of other shows that have utilized this technology in similar ways. Where I would draw a distinction between this show and those that came before it is that in every other production where I have seen camerawork incorporated, it is meant only to enhance the storytelling. The majority of the plot did not rely on screens. With The Picture of Dorian Gray, there were only a few minutes of the show that weren’t projected onto a screen, making it feel more like a movie with a live performance element rather than the other way around. At the end of the day, The Picture of Dorian Gray certainly achieves its goal in telling this timeless story onstage in a brand new way by using a single narrator. Sarah Snook gives the performance of a lifetime, bringing Oscar Wilde’s words into a new age that may make you think twice before using that filter on your next selfie. If you are looking to see something on Broadway that you’ve never seen before, this show is for you. Still, I personally struggle to recommend any Broadway show where a screen looms larger than the story itself.
Wanted to love this as I recently loved the one man Vanya, but I found myself struggling a bit. I felt at times that the magnetism and energy of Snook’s performance overshadowed the storytelling. When characters are supposed to interact with each other (who are all pre-recorded and played by Snook), her performance brought in intense emotion, but it sometimes lacked in connection. But she certainly is captivating on the large screens and is giving all of herself in a near 2-hour marathon. And if that Tony comes her way, it is very well deserved.
Extraordinary acting by Sarah Snook. So intense. I was exhausted leaving the theatre after watching all of that. Just go see her! The production was equally intense, but somewhat lacking clear vision, literally, at times. It was a little concert-y. And the blocking that occurs is more annoying than useful—the window scene. Granted I had a side aisle view, but why put a video screen upstage when nothing is in front of it?
Sarah Snook is a force. This is a feat of acting — and I can’t believe she does it eight times a week. Simply impressive. On the whole, the story works well and is quite gripping. Credit to Wilde on that one!! Makes me want to read the original! (The second half especially drew me in.) This show does a lot of interesting things, and I’m not sure how well some of them work. The audience laughed at some moments (like when there were multiple characters on the screen) that didn’t feel like jokes. I also appreciated the commentary on the present day, but it didn’t feel quite fully developed enough. Like when Character Dorian Gray and Character Sarah Snook were stealing narration lines from each other: Why? What was the point? Maybe I just missed it. Also, I was basically just watching a movie. Most of the time, my eyes were on the screen (maybe due to my side front mezz seat). Jamie Lloyd’s use of the camera/screen felt more intentional and pointed than what was going on here. Here, it was just all video all the time. And mainly Snook performing to camera. But see it for Snook. And see it for Wilde’s story, which is quite gripping and chilling and heart wrenching. See with Death Becomes Her for a real “we struggle with aging and mortality” double header.
Probably the most conflicted I’ve ever felt coming out of a play. Story was very confusing throughout partially due to the format. However Sarah Snook did a remarkable job in the role and was truly a memorable performance. I think she should win a Tony. It was so unique I’d say worth going but definitely not for everyone.
Seriously impressive performance by Sarah Snook and very clever use of screens and animation. Lots more use of video in plays now (eg Sunset Boulevard and Redwood) and being used in a similar way - minimalistic, camera operators visible and ‘part of the show’. I think it’s an ok and interesting theatrical concept, but not sure that’s what I go to the theatre for - suspect it will be overdone quite quickly and then we’ll all want to get back to going to the theatre where people just perform live to a live audience without screens. If I wanted to see a video performance, I’d go to the cinema/watch TV. I think it is a bit of a cop out frankly. You are assuming the audience cannot use their imagination and are making the theatre too real. Don’t want to take away that it was an amazing performance though and would recommend it. (Edited)
Incredible feat of acting from Sarah Snook!! A true testament to her talent. I found the production itself a little difficult to get into on an emotional level due to all of the screens, my ADHD brain couldn’t focus on the story itself. I wish she was featured more downstage to be the anchor. But it really is a technical feat (big props to the crew!) and Sarah definitely deserves the Tony.
At 100% intensity the whole time. Could have used a break from that. Performance was amazing. Technology and screens were fantastic.
A little less novel on the second watch, but Sarah remains a tour de force.
Phenomenal. Pros: - Sarah Snook is an absolute force - Use of screens isn't a novelty, direction is fantastic - Very camp in the best way possible Cons: - Sarah spends a little too much time behind the screens - play is a little long
Great show , snook is a marvel unfortunately I wasn’t told that the seat’s view was abstracted and I was very disappointed that I could see all the left stage part of the play. (Edited)
Sarah Snook was excellent. Interesting use of screens. Seemed a bit gimmicky. (Edited)
so so beautiful!! not sure how i liked it plot wise but what a beautiful production. and the cameras holy shit amazing quality (Edited)
Sarah Snook gives an incredible tour de force performance. She deserves the Tony. I did like it but I would have enjoyed seeing more of her on stage than on screens. It was innovative and technically impressive how they did it… but I get enough screens and filters in my daily life. Impressed by the technical achievement and the acting, but my emotional connection is stunted by all screens almost all the time.
Sarah Snook is amazing but the staging and use of cameras was annoying and distracting
It was the weirdest show I’ve ever seen and I do feel like some time could’ve been shaved off. But Sarah is reallyy ACTINGGGG in this
Gooped and gagged all the way home
221–240 of 263 comments
sarah snook is fabulous and cannot be missed in this role. the story however, did bore me more often than not. i found myself checking my mom’s watch quite frequently. the way they use the doubles and the screens are very cool. my 96th show. 5/10.