The Other Americans
Review: The Other Americans The Public Theater - Anspacher Theater (Seen in previews) Directed by Ruben Santiago-Hudson | Written by John Leguizamo John Leguizamo’s The Other Americans feels like stepping into a Forest Hills living room — full of soap opera novela intensity, wrapped in intimate Latin-American family drama. Leguizamo plays Nelson Castro, a laundromat owner juggling a failing business, family trauma, and long-buried secrets. When his son Nick returns from a mental wellness facility, the tension ratchets up, and you feel every choice and misstep as if you were right there with them. Ruben Santiago-Hudson’s direction keeps the action taut and raw, letting the story breathe but never losing its emotional punch. The cast is incredible — Rosa Evangelina Arredondo, Sarah Nina Hayon, Rebecca Jimenez, Trey Santiago-Hudson, Bradley James Tejeda, Luna Lauren Velez, and of course Leguizamo all give performances that feel lived-in and real. Even in previews, when little hiccups like calling Nelson “John” popped up, it barely mattered — the energy and truth on stage carried the night. But the real MVP of the production is the set. It doesn’t just suggest a home — it is the home, fully immersive and alive, making you feel like you’re right there in the family’s world from the first moment. The lighting complements it beautifully, adding depth and life to every corner of the space. The play has a novela vibe, reminiscent of Purpose in its intensity, but with a fully unique story rooted in Latin-American experience. There were moments when I wanted to yell at the characters, frustrated and invested as if I were part of their family, which says a lot about how immediate and engaging the play feels. The actors weren’t miked at all, which made it hard to hear some lines when they had their backs to the audience, but it didn’t stop the show from landing. The heart of the show is undeniable. Final Verdict: The Other Americans lands like a perfectly executed descent — intimate, tense, and emotionally gripping. With a bit of fine-tuning, this one is cleared for a bigger runway.
They call it the melting pot, but some of us are still on the stove. 🥘 What a joy—and heartbreak—to see Leguizamo wrestle with identity, legacy, and sacrifice onstage. His physicality, his tone shifts, his silences… they all carry weight. The Other Americans is a play anchored by its lead, and his presence is what lingers with you after.
Real deep story line. Great cast.
One of the best plays I've watched this season. The production, writing and cast are all stellar. I would put it at almost the same level as Purpose!
Awesome storytelling!
Wow. A new classic American family drama. (Edited)
Amazing cast!
Huge fan of John Leguizamo and went for that reason. The play is less funny and more dark than I was expecting. It’s an emotional theme that can be challenging for some for different reasons.
I had high hopes for this play, but unfortunately, it misses the mark. While the story shows promise, it feels underdeveloped and could have benefited from more depth and clarity. That said, the performances by John Leguizamo and Rosa Evangelina Arredondo are definite highlights—both bring strong presence and emotional weight to the stage. What didn’t work for me was the portrayal of the son. The performance felt exaggerated and lacked the nuance needed to make the character believable. It pulled focus in a way that disrupted the overall tone of the play. (Edited)
I typically love Leguizamo’s theatrical ventures, but this really missed the mark. While it’s striving to be a realistic and authentic story, it’s burdened with unrealistic, wonky dialogue and stilted direction and performances (especially from the director’s son, whose histrionics are forced and phony). While the second act reveals a nice twist, sitting through this was penance. I kept noticing lines and story moments that made no sense, and even set and music design elements that were weirdly off-kilter. The first 40 minutes is a boring introduction (I hesitate to say “exposition”, because nothing is explained), whatever humor exists doesn’t land (a surprise for Leguizamo), and the second act is a big ole melodramatic mess.
It was an ok play. Star power was great!! It needs some work. Great book.
another american family drama, with not quite as much of a new take as it claims to be. mostly great acting all around, but the story itself sags throughout. wish there was more to make this a "new take" than just it's demographics. not bad, just not great either.
looking for one please
1–15 of 15 comments
The Other Americans was a jaw dropping look at a columbian-American modern day family and brought to light a lot of the struggles that the present day has placed on POC achieving an “American dream” in today’s society. It feels like an American kitchen sink drama like an Arthur Miller play in terms of your look into behind the households walls which brilliantly are lifted away at the top and reconstructed into a cage at the end of the piece. The fella who sat next to me and I both had many audible moments of connection while we were taken through dramatic beat after dramatic beat on our way to the shockingly beautiful conclusion of the piece. Very happy I got to catch another wonderful show at the Public!