The Fear of 13
Amazing performance and story!!!
Amazing
So powerful
LOVED IT!!!!!
Powerful performance
If you have the chance, please don't skip this one!
Loved it
The story of Nick Yarris—wrongfully convicted of rape and murder, spending 21 years on death row until DNA evidence finally set him free—is exactly the kind of true-crime nightmare that deserves to wreck you, which it almost does. Adrien Brody and Tessa Thompson make their Broadway debuts, which is a big deal, but live theatre demands something different from film and the gap shows. Brody’s accent never quite convinces, the script meanders, and bizarrely never explains what “the fear of 13” actually refers to—a word Yarris apparently taught himself in prison, left completely unexplained onstage by playwright Lindsey Ferrentino. The Tony nominators noticed: nods for sound and lighting design, nothing for its stars or the production itself. I can’t say I’m surprised. But then something happened that no script critique can fully account for. The night I attended, the real Nick Yarris was in the house. I’d noticed him before curtain without knowing who he was, mimicking prayer hands from the right box as house lights dimmed. After bows, he gently stirred the audience’s attention while folks were exiting and delivered a brief heartfelt speech—asking us to pursue our dreams, to live every day, to believe anything is possible. Twenty-one years on death row, and there he stood: grateful and genuinely moved to be alive and seen. The production didn’t always honor his story. He did it himself.
Truly terrible true story and so important it’s being told. Nick can be found in the audience on occasion and I was lucky enough to be present for one - and to have spotted him in advance. He gave a very touching speech after and took pictures / talked with people by the stage door. Well performed. Beautiful lighting. Didn’t love the writing and felt like it could’ve been shorter in moments and longer in others, though needs to be shorter overall.
This is a “very OK” play. Not bad, not great. It should be riveting — the source material warrants it — but it isn’t. It should be a tearjerker. It’s not. Brody does well in his first Broadway outing, fully inhabiting his character. Unfortunately, Thompson is very one-note, but this was an early preview. It’s two hours, no intermission. While not exactly slow, there were several moments that I noticed I wasn’t listening to, and I was checking my watch during the final monologue. Without Brody, I doubt this would’ve made it to Broadway.
I went into the play with high expectations. While the true story is undeniably heavy, I didn’t find the production as moving or riveting as I’d hoped—it felt like it was missing something. Adrien Brody delivered a solid performance, but it didn’t fully land for me. He felt slightly off during my showing, and I never quite connected with his character. That disconnect made the overall experience feel less impactful, which surprised me given how strong he typically is. On the other hand, Tessa Thompson was really compelling. I felt fully engaged with her character and what she was going through—her performance brought the emotional depth I was looking for.
I enjoyed Adrian Brody’s performance and seeing someone who can act, but is also a “star”. There were meaningful and emotional moments in the play, but at some point, you start feeling the weight of being stuck in jail for 22 years and you think let’s get on with this. I also think they have a reveal at the end which is not necessary to the play, except to bring more misery. Bottom line I liked Adrian Brody but I didn’t really enjoy the play.
Complex and thought provoking. Still in previews so I hope some of the lines land differently as it locks. Laughs to be had but the audience looked for laughs at a couple dramatic lines that would have held the tension better if it was received straight.
Went in with Oedipus-level standards, especially with the sticker over the phones rule, but found it uninspiring and unclear of the tone was comedic or serious. The dog at the end didn’t seem necessary.
It was phenomenal acting, felt the show was bout 10 minutes too long and dragged a little. Interesting story based off true story. Was intense, funny, sad, heartwarming and heartbreaking all at once. Loved the versatility of the supporting actors.
B- Note well: it is still in Previews! so maybe they will make changes. Th performances of the two leads were each captivating. Adrien Brody really embodied a Philadelphia convict. But the script was unkempt, messy. some side plots (like the choir and the “shower”) were not germane to the story, and in fact looked hopelessly solicitous for showing talented singers or Adrien’s body. the last ten minutes were very weak.
Adrian is transcendent but the staging and writing aren’t. He truly brings his character to life but the staging was not deigned for the people on the far left and the end dragged a little.
Very raw and impactful story. Adrian is incredible. My only complaint was that the humor felt a little out of place at times. Took me out of the story
The acting was fantastic! It was a little slow. Singing was great. Glad I went, but not sure I’d go a 2nd time or recommend. It wouldn’t be in my top 10. With that nerving said though, it was a good show. Adrian & Tessa were fantastic. (Edited)
101–120 of 138 comments
Absolutely incredible