The Disappear
Standout performances by Miriam Silverman and Madeline Brewer. (Edited)
The very end could have been tighter, but overall enjoyed. Almost didn’t go because of the reviews but glad I did.
We are situated in the living room and study of a country house with rustic finishes, from where we can see an exit that leads to the kitchen, another with stairs leading to the bedrooms, and a final one that reveals part of the lawn and the outdoors, through which all the characters in this story will enter and exit. In the study is the central character of this story, Benjamin Braxton, played by the magnificent Hamish Linklater, who through his gestures, the constant trembling of his hands, his unsteady walk, and his excess of words presents an egocentric film director who appears incapable of writing his own projects and who now, using his position, intends to redirect his life. In this way, he places us inside a time bomb in which any element can become the trigger for his imminent collapse. Two great actresses enter the frame: Miriam Silverman as Mira, a bestselling author and Ben’s wife, and Madeline Brewer as Julie Wells, an actress. Both are at the top of their form, with solid and contrasting characters that will majestically weave this web. Mira is a successful and seemingly perfect wife, while Julie Wells is willing to use her attributes to secure a position in the industry. To balance the drama, two more ingredients are added to this recipe: Michael Bloom, Ben’s boss, finely portrayed by Dylan Baker, who brings bittersweet, comic, and refreshingly necessary tones; and Dolly, the sweet and adolescent daughter of our successful artist couple, embodied by Anna Mirodin. Last but not least, we season the mix with Raf Night, the handsome and talented actor of the moment who happens to be a devoted fan of Mira’s work, portrayed by Kelvin Harrison Jr., adding balance and refinement to our blend. Now all the elements are laid out on the table. It is a perfect recipe in which what is familiar and acceptable will begin to feel acrid and oppressive, while the unknown becomes that refreshing halo of light, that small breath of air that will grow necessary and for which one would risk an entire life. A magnificent set design, impeccable lighting and sound design, a blend of good taste and intelligence, and the closeness to the actors achieved by Audible Theater at Minetta Lane Theatre, envelop us in a hyperrealistic journey, leaving theater as the living art that survives the technological hecatomb of our future days. In the finest style of the classics of Tennessee Williams, and directing her own writing, Erica Schmidt delights us with this piece, exploring loneliness, truth confronted with illusion, and the fragility of the human being. We left the theater fulfilled, amazed that this was the opening night, predicting the inevitable growth of the show over its run. Our prediction was confirmed as at the time of posting this review we have learned that due to popular demand The Disappear has been extended past its initial 6 week run at Audible Theater at Minetta Lane Theatre in New York City, now running until February 22nd.
Beautiful acting.
Great cast, just not many jokes for what’s billed as a comedy. And the daughter character is superfluous; the show would be tighter without her.
Great acting but dialogue feels a little weak
Not laugh out loud, but cool set
Erica Schmidt’s THE DISAPPEAR is one of those plays that gives you a lot to think about - sometimes all at once, sometimes more than it knows what to do with. It’s an ambitious, idea-packed evening that oscillates between sharp satire and earnest drama, occasionally tripping over its own reach but never entirely losing your attention. At its center is Benjamin Braxton, a mid-career filmmaker with a carefully curated reputation and an impressively fragile ego. Hamish Linklater plays him with total abandon, leaning hard into the character’s self-absorption. Benjamin is the kind of man who believes his artistic temperament excuses him from daily life, emotional labor, and basic courtesy. His wife, Mira, is a bestselling novelist whose professional success somehow coexists with her near-invisibility at home. Their teenage daughter Dolly, meanwhile, channels her anxiety about the collapsing world into hyper-awareness about carbon footprints and quiet emotional withdrawal. The arrival of two outsiders destabilizes this already brittle ecosystem. Julie, a young actress hungry for opportunity, becomes both muse and mirror for Benjamin’s worst instincts. Raf, a movie star with real clout, threatens Benjamin’s authority simply by recognizing Mira’s talent and treating her as an equal. What follows is a slow, often uncomfortable unraveling of power dynamics - creative, marital, and generational. The cast is uniformly strong, with Dylan Baker, as Michael Bloom, offering a grounding presence and well-timed humor whenever the play threatens to tip into self-seriousness. Miriam Silverman brings a sharp, contained intelligence to Mira, making her restraint feel deliberate rather than passive. Anna Mirodin’s Dolly is quietly effective, embodying the emotional residue left behind when adults intellectualize everything except their own behavior. Madeline Brewer is, without question, a beautifully talented actress, and her commitment to Julie is clear. That said, her performance here felt familiar in ways that occasionally pulled me out of the play. The cadence, vulnerability, and wide-eyed intensity closely echo her work as Janine in “The Handmaid’s Tale,” making it harder for Julie to fully emerge as her own character. It’s not a lack of skill, it’s more a case of a very recognizable instrument being used in a register we’ve heard before. Visually, the production is confident and cohesive. The farmhouse setting feels intentional without being precious, and the technical elements support the story rather than competing with it. On a craft level, THE DISAPPEAR is doing many things right. Where the play falters is in its tonal indecision. It flirts with farce, gestures toward tragedy, and then veers into something more philosophical, sometimes within the same scene. The humor is broad, the stakes are serious, and the transitions between the two can feel abrupt. Benjamin’s behavior is often so exaggerated that it undercuts moments meant to land with genuine emotional weight. There are also more ideas introduced than the play has time, or structure, to fully explore. Questions of authorship, artistic credit, gendered sacrifice, environmental guilt, and legacy are all in play, but not all are given room to breathe. You can feel the ambition pushing against the frame, which is admirable, even when it leads to narrative sprawl. Still, THE DISAPPEAR remains compelling, if not entirely satisfying. It’s a play that wants to provoke thought more than provide resolution, and while that choice sometimes leaves the evening feeling uneven, it also ensures there’s plenty to chew on afterward. I didn’t leave dazzled. I didn’t leave disengaged. I left thinking, and slightly arguing with the play in my head, which may be exactly what it’s aiming for. THE DISAPPEAR is messy, intelligent, frustrating, and intermittently sharp. Not a home run, but far from a miss.
1–9 of 9 comments
This was my first play from Erica Schmidt and I was blown away. The writing is sharp and engaging and keeps you at the edge of your seat throughout. It was certainly funnier than I had expected from reading the synopsis. The chemistry between Hamish Linklatter and Miriam Silverman is absolutely electric and it was truly a joy seeing them together. My only nitpick is that sometimes the sound effects drowned the dialogue but other than that, I'm very much seeing this again.