The Burning Cauldron of Fiery Fire
Review: The Burning Cauldron of Fiery Fire Vineyard Theatre produced with The Civilians Directed by Steve Cosson Written by Anne Washburn Anne Washburn’s The Burning Cauldron of Fiery Fire is pure chaos, wonder, and heartbreak all rolled into one unforgettable evening. Set in a foggy Northern California commune, it’s a story of grief, faith, and human obsession with meaning — but told in the most unexpected, wild way. Adults playing children, a life-sized dragon, a pageant, pigs, and moments that feel like they might collapse the whole world — this play refuses to let you sit still. The set and props were stunning, every piece purposeful and often magical, while lighting, sound, costumes, and special effects all combined to heighten the surreal, immersive world of the play. My only complaint? The run is limited to just one month and it’s closing soon — a play this powerful deserves much longer on Off-Broadway. Bartley Booz, Bruce McKenzie, Marianne Rendón, and Bobby Moreno were unstoppable — raw, fearless, and heartbreaking. The rest of the ensemble — Biehl, Brown, Grays, Pecinka — completed this perfect storm of a cast, every performance sharpening the play’s unpredictable edges. Washburn’s writing leaves questions dangling in the air, and that’s exactly what makes it brilliant: you leave thinking, feeling, imagining. This is theatre you’ll never forget, a play that demands you come back, think harder, and let it haunt you. Final Verdict: Warning: may leave you burned, challenged, and thinking. Cleared for maximum altitude — 5/5 ✈️✈️✈️✈️✈️
Let me start by saying: I have no idea what I just watched and I kind of loved it. The Burning Cauldron of Fiery Fire (yes, that’s the real title) is Anne Washburn’s new play at the Vineyard Theatre, and it’s one of those shows where you sit there, eyes wide, thinking, “Wait, what?” for most of the evening. But then, against all odds, you realize you’ve been completely sucked in. The setup: A bunch of people are living off the grid in Northern California, doing the commune thing, farming, saying grace, avoiding the real world, when one of them dies suddenly. From there, things get progressively weirder. The group decides to handle the death themselves (bad idea #1), the kids think one of the piglets might be the reincarnation of the dead guy (bad idea #2), and then everyone stages an amateur fairy-tale pageant complete with a puppet dragon (bad idea #3, but also kind of amazing). It’s two and a half hours of earnest chaos, like Our Town met Midsommar at a campfire singalong. There’s a lot of talk about grace, community, and what it means to live “off the land,” but mostly it’s about watching people try (and fail) to hold their beliefs together when the cracks start showing. The production looks fantastic. The set by Andrew Boyce feels like you could walk right into it, all rough wood and misty corners. The lighting (Amith Chandrashaker) and sound (Ryan Gamblin) make you feel like you’re outside somewhere you probably shouldn’t be after dark. Director Steve Cosson keeps everything moving just enough to stop you from bolting, even when the play drifts into total absurdity. The cast is uniformly great, especially Bruce McKenzie as the control-freak leader and Marianne Rendón as a mom doing her best not to lose it. Bobby Moreno, as the grown-up narrator looking back on his commune childhood, ties it all together with a mix of fondness and horror. Does the story make sense? Not really. Does it need to? Also not really. It’s messy and meandering and full of strange little details that may or may not mean anything. But it’s also funny, creepy, and oddly touching in its own offbeat way. I left the theatre genuinely confused, but also impressed. The Burning Cauldron of Fiery Fire is one of those plays that makes you ask, “What the hell did I just see?” and then keeps you thinking about it the whole train ride home. Verdict: Weird as hell, beautifully staged, and impossible to forget. Bring a friend so you have someone to debrief with afterward.
Amazing. Anne Washburn’s inventive, sucker-punch writing is on full display and the production was beautiful. I’m going to have to see this one again for sure. Highly recommend.
Original. Different. Mysterious. Ambiguous. Tons to discuss
Anne Washburn, the playwright you are. This is a weird little culty (sorry, ‘commune’) play that has some moments of pure whimsy that change the whole watching experience. You will have to be ok with getting no answers to any of the questions you are asked to ponder.
7/10 ! Interesting material, very funny mixed with fantastical, like Anne Washburn often is. Was happy to support, although I think I like Mr. Burns more than this one.
Something was off. Very funny moments though. But tonally incoherent.
I don’t think Anne Washburn’s writing is for me. Some acting performances were better than others, but I didn’t care for the story they were trying to tell.
1–10 of 10 comments
Very good, lots to chew on. There is so much unsaid that I spent most of the play thinking hard. And the fantastical elements really fit in well. This was an unusual play, but I thoroughly enjoyed it. The ending was perfection. It was very well thought out and very well acted too. I would love to attend a talkback with the playwright to hear more about the meaning of it all, which is very strong but very amorphous in my head right now. Terrific set!