The Brothers Size
third time seeing the show but this production is incredible. the physicality and the movement made the words sing and strike with heft. as always, the portrayal of this brotherhood is spectacular and much needed.
Truly a masterclass of actors, directors and a writer at the top of their form. I was hooked from the start but a half hour in, I noticed some of the audience lost focus when the actors’ mics stopped working. Hopefully this won’t happen in future performances.
First 30 minutes was pretty low tempo. Take snacks. The last hour is tremendous.
Review: The Brothers Size The Shed Directed by Tarell Alvin McCraney and Bijan Sheibani | Written by Tarell Alvin McCraney I walked out of The Brothers Size at The Shed needing to catch my breath. The first few minutes had me questioning if I was going to fully connect — the pace felt slow, the story still finding its footing. But very quickly, the power and thunder of the performances took over, pulling me in and never letting go. It’s not just the performances, but the way the play grabs you by the shoulders and forces you to wrestle with freedom, loyalty, and the ties that bind us. McCraney’s story of two brothers in the Deep South is intimate, raw, and urgent — a modern fable that refuses to let you sit back and simply watch. Every moment of this production is alive. Holland, iLongwe, Mays, and Zakee each deliver performances that are raw, electric, and deeply human. Their movements, the dancing, and the physicality of each moment are precise, intentional, and breathtaking — each gesture carrying weight and meaning. The beautiful music, the simple but precise set and lighting, and the in-the-round staging all amplify the performances, giving the actors space to make every word, movement, and gesture hit with full force. Spoken stage directions add rhythm and poetry, and the ASL interpreters weren’t just translating — they were performing alongside each character, moving with them, matching their energy, their timing, their heartbeat. It wasn’t just accessibility; it was a second layer of the story coming alive in front of you. What stays with you after the lights come up is how The Brothers Size holds a mirror to the world we live in. Oshoosi just wants to “chill,” but the play makes you feel how dangerous that simple desire can be in a society that criminalizes Black men for existing. The tension, the longing, the weight of responsibility — it’s all there, pulsing through every scene. And yet, in telling this story again, in living it in the present moment with such clarity and power, the play offers something hopeful: that change is possible, that freedom is something we fight for together, and that theatre can be a place where we confront, feel, and imagine a better world. Final Verdict: This one’s cleared for a smooth takeoff — a storm of performances, movement, and storytelling that lands in your chest and lingers long after the curtain.
4.5/5⭐️ 'Moonlight' vibes: brothers' relationship. Brothers navigating an alone, harsh world post-prison. How do they show their love in a hard, unforgiving world. Excellent rhythm/choreo staging and acting. Maybe not your thing: minimal: no set/props, some indie-film moments of vibes rather than dialogue/plot, some self narration, profanity, crime/prison. Diversity: yes. All Black cast of cis men of lower socioeconomic background/status. 2 just out of prison. Some queer vibes. 1 hour 50 minutes; no intermission
some of the cleanest most exciting physical work i've ever witnessed on a stage... a masterclass of art and acting!
I didn’t want to love it…but they made me do it!🔥🔥🔥 So good, I have to see it again to witness the magic making of this ensemble! Pure enchantment!
Stunning, truthful performances
If you have a sibling, you will connect with this show. Go see it!
Fabulous performance of a great show
Three jaw-droppingly incredible performances.
An excellent show! I would definitely recommend watching it before it closes!
Incredible acting
Wonderful show with a brilliant and very handsome cast.
Astounding.
This was a strange half hashed play. It wasn’t fully explored in any area— including the music. Also, the seating and staging is strange. My seat was way too far up and hard to see. The story was decent and sometimes funny and enjoyable, but a bit far fetched tbh. (Edited)
1–17 of 17 comments
The POET that Tarell Alvin McCraney is! Constantly found myself awestruck by the language and lyricism of this play. The production’s direction (co-directed by McCraney and Bijan Sheibani, associate directed by Kemar Jewel) astutely leaves so much space for the text and performers to breathe, move, and play their way through the story while giving the audience license to put our imaginations to use. While McCraney’s text is very economical with actual words, the production’s direction offers so much in the space and silence between the Size brothers and Elegba. Juel D. Lane’s choreography is and delightfully transfixing, perhaps most so in the moments when the Black men in this play are living fully in their tenderness and whimsy, which is so meaningful to see. André Holland (Ogun), Alani iLongwe (Ooshoozi), and Malcolm Mays (Elegba) elegantly and precisely portray a complex set of relationships where fraught histories collide with love, resentment, compassion, and betrayals in the present. This sparsely and simply designed production relies heavily on the these performers (and musician Munir Zakee) to make the world of the piece as they perform it, and their efforts yield an extremely lush and vivid playworld on in addition to brilliant individual performances. One of my favorite parts of the experience was seeing the production staff’s names painted directly onto the wall, including that of my friend Sam, who’s the production stage manager. Iconic!