The Antiquities
Very dystopian. Very disturbing. Very weird. It felt on the verge of something very interesting and insightful but instead fell a little short because of its disjointed structure. But it was good. As a historian of technology, I’m glad I saw it. And the production value was great — especially the lighting. The lighting designer did some very clever things!
Nice, a bit all over the place with the staging. The storyline moved quick and it ended with a nice little closing of the loop.
An interesting, existential play about the relationship between humans and technology over the decades. There’s something so enjoyable about reminiscing on what technological advances excited us in the past and hypothesizing about what is to come. The play asks us to consider the dangers of AI and how we program it, since it can either be a powerful weapon for us or against us. There are some fantastic performances in this show from some off-broadway staples. The design is cohesively sleek, with sharp stark lighting and an ever changing set. With so many short scenes, the given circumstances and characters are difficult to latch onto emotionally. The result is many stereotyped dramatic moments with few relatable underpinnings. The show ends up feeling quite lethargic and slow even though it’s only 90 minutes. While THE ANTIQUITIES isn’t quite engrossing, it asks interesting questions, has some great performances, and boasts impressive designs. I’d say it’s worth seeing!
How does the playwright Jordan Harrison feel about technology in our lives? Mostly, not very good, considering his framing device: Mary Shelley's "Frankenstein." In a series of time-stamped vignettes, beginning with that author and her friends by a campfire in 1816, "The Antiquities" takes on technology. (That Shelley calls her monster a "computer" is an anachronism that draws a heavy black line under the author's intent.) The technology on parade includes a crude artificial limb more than a century ago; the booo-WAAAT sound of a personal computer logging into the Internet via modem in the mid-1990s; and an artificial intelligence of the future that declares war on humans themselves. It says much that a butter churn is the only technology in the scene set in a post-apocalypse 2240. The vignettes cover a wide range of years, nameless characters and inventions. The overall effect is somewhat unsatisfying. There is no one to care about, which makes the stakes shockingly low: this is a march of time one can engage in at a safe distance. (Edited)
Terrific! Wonderful! Episodic at times but very powerful!
The Antiquities presents thought-provoking ideas about the extinction of the human race and the rise of technology through its yearly exhibits from 1816 to 2240. While the concept intrigued me at first, the execution fell flat. I was hoping for the same eerie and thought-provoking feeling I get from Black Mirror, a show I love, but this play did not deliver anything new to the sci-fi genre. I appreciated the use of lighting and set changes, but the way each exhibit and its story unfolded failed to keep me engaged. The storytelling felt disjointed, and with the cast playing multiple roles across different exhibits, it was difficult to follow their connections. Instead of feeling immersed in a gripping dystopian narrative, I found myself struggling to stay engaged, mainly because of its dialogue. The performances were great, but the wordplay was just not for everybody, especially for me as an average theatergoer and sci-fi fan. Overall, The Antiquities is ambitious but not easy to digest. It left me questioning a lot, but not in a way that felt meaningful. Unfortunately, its sci-fi concept just did not work for me.
‘The Antiquities’ is what happens if an episode of ‘Black Mirror’ meets ‘Mr. Burns, a Post-Electric Play’, another quirky apocalyptic play that also ran at Playwrights Horizons over a decade ago. The narrative is sliced into a series a vignettes that mark technological advancements throughout history. In a few of these moments, we see the introduction of the computer, the creation of the internet, and the discussions that led to voice-command personal assistants. Since we’re covering centuries of time, these vignettes are often too brief and the character relationships take the backseat. It eventually becomes quantity over quality. In 100 minutes, ‘The Antiquities’ explores the relationship that humans have with technology (for better or for worse), which is a timely endeavor given the drastic rise of AI and an over-reliance on technology. But despite the well-oiled scenic design and all-around excellent performances from its versatile cast, ‘The Antiquities’ doesn’t offer much beyond a sci-fi cliché of the inevitable human extinction.
21–30 of 30 comments
Playwrights Horizons’ The Antiquities is an ambitious exploration of humanity’s obsolescence and extinction at the hands of AI, set against the backdrop of a sterile, futuristic museum. While the cast delivers exceptional performances and the bold set design effectively contrasts cold detachment with human emotion, the play struggles to rise above familiar tropes and sometimes heavy-handed messaging. Its vignette structure disrupts emotional momentum, making it hard to fully invest in the narrative, and yet its warnings about AI feel more didactic than profound- perhaps this was part of its attempt at a morality play, though. While there are definite moments of ascension, the piece never quite achieves the magic of the only other play I’m reminded of, Mr. Burns, a Post-Electric Play, leaving it as a thoughtful but ultimately flat cautionary tale. It’s important to note that this was the first preview, and the play has a lot of time for growth during its multi-venue run in NYC and Chicago.