The Adding Machine
Incredible to see each member of this cast IRL. I left befuddled.
Watched it at the press preview and was so terribly disappointed. I was really excited for it given the very talented cast, who btw did not disappoint. But the writing/editing left much to be desired - the playbill for this noted that the screenplay retains 90%+ (I'm forgetting the actual number) of the original, written in early 1900s, which might be why a lot of the scenes felt like they dragged on and on without many of the lines adding much, if any, incremental value.
This is a relentlessly dark, depressing, and bleak play, despite intermittent comic relief. Unfortunately, the show’s scenes and monologues are pretty interminable, and we all said we were phasing in and out without ever really missing a beat. That being said, the play is relevant and the actors are game, even if their performances are uneven. (As always, I tend not to like Scott Elliott’s direction.) The best part of the show is its physical production elements — the set, lighting, and sound design is probably the best I’ve seen in this venue. (Edited)
I liked the actors. I thought they all were fun to watch and they all did a great job with what they had to work with. I think the play could have been tightened up, but still a worthwhile night out with this cast. I really enjoyed seeing Jennifer Tilly on stage.
I loved the cast. There are some really good moments. It was just too weird and I was kinda bored. (Edited)
Elmer Rice’s THE ADDING MACHINE begins with a man who has already disappeared long before anything actually happens to him. Mr. Zero (Daphne Rubin-Vega) moves through his life like a ghost, stuck in a job he’s held for decades, trapped in a marriage with Mrs. Zero (Jennifer Tilly) that feels more like noise than connection, and quietly fixated on his co-worker Daisy (Sarita Choudhury). When he’s abruptly replaced by an adding machine, that fragile structure collapses, sending him into a surreal spiral that moves from workplace routine into something far more disorienting. The play lives in that tension between human existence and mechanical efficiency. A system decides you are no longer necessary and simply removes you. It’s an idea that still resonates, especially if you want to draw parallels to the current conversations around automation and AI, even if this production doesn’t fully sharpen that connection into something urgent. From a performance standpoint, the cast is doing strong, specific work. Daphne Rubin-Vega gives Mr. Zero a kind of simmering stillness that makes his unraveling feel internal before it ever becomes external. Jennifer Tilly leans fully into Mrs. Zero’s relentless presence, turning what could be grating into something oddly watchable. Sarita Choudhury brings a clarity and emotional grounding to Daisy that cuts through the more abstract elements of the piece. But this is Michael Cyril Creighton’s show. As the narrator and essentially everyone else, he moves through an entire roster of characters with precision and control, shifting voices, physicality, and energy in a way that keeps the production alive. A dinner party sequence becomes his playground, and it’s one of the few moments where the show fully locks into its rhythm. Visually, the production makes a strong impression. Derek McLane’s scenic design, a towering wall packed with lamps, fans, adding machines, and typewriters, creates a dense and almost suffocating environment that reinforces the monotony of Zero’s world. Jeff Croiter’s lighting design and Stan Mathabane’s sound design layer in texture, helping the world feel unstable without completely losing its shape. Where the production starts to falter is in how it handles its own ideas. It keeps circling the same themes without sharpening them, and the tone never fully settles. It wants to be surreal, biting, darkly funny, and unsettling all at once, but it doesn’t quite find the rhythm to make those elements land together. There are moments where everything clicks and you can see exactly what it’s aiming for. I just kept waiting for that feeling to carry through the entire piece. It never really does. Still, there’s enough talent onstage and enough visual creativity in the design to keep it engaging. I didn’t love it, but I wasn’t bored either. It’s interesting, occasionally effective, and frustratingly close to something sharper that never fully comes into focus.
out of date is the right word for it.
Can’t say this was very good, unfortunately. There was too much exposition. The pacing was off, and the last 20 min could have been scrapped entirely. Given how relevant the theme is, I’m not sure why they kept the setting in the 1920s? It felt like a skilled writer surely could have brought the script into the 21st century with a few tweaks. Great cast, but the talent was sadly wasted on this oddity.
First show I ever left at intermission. Lighting and set design were great and everything else was terrible. Tedious story. One note acting.
1–10 of 10 comments
It’s rare to find a play as weird as it is poignant. This production delivers that combination spectacularly. The depth of Michael Cyril Creighton’s talent is truly mind boggling. He drives this piece expertly. Oh and of course, Jennifer Tilly is a national TREASURE 🤩