Swept Away
loved. excited for speakeasy stage in boston to take a stab at it this month!
Beautiful show. Lots of emotion.
I loved it so much omg ;) everyone watch it
Go see it before it closes!
Phenomenal
SEE THIS SHOW
Very good
Swept Away beautifully brings the music of the folk rock band Avett Brothers to the Broadway stage in this moving tale of survival, redemption, and forgiveness. I honestly went in not knowing it was a jukebox musical because I was not familiar with the Avett Brothers and their songs. But hearing them for the first time, I genuinely liked the songs and their tunes, and I'm currently listening to others while writing this review. John, Stark, Adrian, and Wayne all have beautiful singing voices and great chemistry, but I just want to highlight Adrian, whose performance stood out for me. My favorite parts of the show were the slow-motion scene and the rain effect, which was beautifully lit. HOWEVER, despite these strengths, the pacing felt a bit uneven, and the story didn’t fully connect with me emotionally. The message of redemption was there, but I found myself wanting more from the plot and the way it was told. The stage design and direction also felt like they could have been more creative to make a lasting impression. In the end, while the story and production didn’t completely sweep me away, I’d still recommend it to Avett Brothers fans and anyone who enjoys strong vocals and folk rock—though, for me, it’s only a one-time watch. (Edited)
It was better on Broadway. It’s pretty amazing how well the songs actually work in the narrative. Sure, sometimes it feels awkward and forced, but on the whole, they largely click. They’re also beautifully orchestrated and song, which helps. They feel apt to be sung at sea. And, compared to DC, the show felt tighter — though I still feel the second half was a tad slow. The challenge here is character development. The short length and the jukebox musical mean you can’t develop a lot of character. And the whole thing feels like it’s ending just where it should be getting interesting — everything after the crazy plot twist (no spoilers) was summed up in about five minutes. I wish we got to know the brothers and Mate better. But also damn those three were incredible actors. All deserve Tony noms. And the set! Rachel is a top notch designer. Give her a Tony!!! I like this show because I love the Avett Brothers. If I didn’t know or care about them, not sure I’d feel so strongly about this show that ends in darkness and doesn’t really leave you with much of a moral or redemptive message. At the end I’m a bit like “why did I just watch this?” But I’m simultaneously singing the title song while walking home up 8th Ave so 🤷♂️
It’s a shame the show is closing so soon, it’s so hard for new musicals to take root. I don’t think this was on the radar long enough to gain traction and an audience. I went into this show knowing nothing other than it featured the music of The Avett Brothers. Well, it took quite a TURN. The first few scenes are a jolly sea-faring sausage fest (maybe the most guys I’ve seen on stage all at once and no ladies?). The star here is the music and it being beautifully sung by the cast. John Gallagher, Jr gives an incredible performance. The book, however, is a bit weak, predictable, and grim. Based on a true story, unfortunately - just went down that rabbit hole… (Edited)
Swept Away brings an edginess to Broadway, but I wish they had leaned into that grit more — it’s hard for a jukebox musical to have weight. As an Avett Brothers fan, I couldn’t help but to sway and stomp along to some of my favorite songs; however, at times, the transition from dialogue to song felt forced. Those transitions took away from the grittiness of Swept Away and made the show fall victim to that “why are they singing now” trope that musicals get a bad rap for. Fortunately, the story was compelling enough to reengage me — the plot kept me guessing. Adrian Blake Enscoe had a stellar performance as Little Brother. I’m grateful I got to see Swept Away before it closed, and I’m even more grateful that their closing announcement boosted sales enough to keep them going through the holidays.
While the piece is unique, well performed, and well staged, I was oddly disengaged from the proceedings until about midway through — my mind kept wandering, yet I wasn’t missing anything. I didn’t really care about the characters. My companion said the same. We aren’t familiar with The Avett Brothers’ music — our friends who love The Avetts loved the show. Though we enjoyed the music and would listen to it again, I simply don’t feel like I’m going to remember this piece down the line, and I can’t really figure out why.
Good music but the show stops dead when the boat sinks and we have to contemplate the usual cannibalism on a lifeboat for at least 30 minutes, which seems to be devoid of music, or maybe it was just boring and I didn’t notice the singing.
You could tell this show is a big labor of love for this cast and crew, unfortunately I couldn’t find myself loving it. The book struggles to provide a sense of attachment or give real purpose to these characters and story. It’s not until 30 minutes in when you say “what the hell, sure” and start to care about the people on stage because you’ve paid money and there’s no intermission anyways. An impressive feat of stagecraft overall and strong performances from the leads (John Gallagher Jr. if you read this im free on Thursday night and would like to hang out. Please respond to this and then hang out with me on Thursday night when I’m free.) (Edited)
It wasn’t exactly my type of show. It wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t that great either. Not familiar with the music or the story, so I was going with an open mind. The scene with the shipwreck was captivating. Great actors.
Wonderful view, the beginning was delightful but the pacing can sometimes feel off. The set was very creative and definitely some interesting storytelling. Looking forward for the soundtrack to be out, I liked the folksy vibe of the music - I do want to mention that there is no intermission - Enjoyed but the pacing is what sets it back for me
Great performances—especially by John Gallagher, singing his guts out in the Avett Brothers tunes—lift this otherwise becalmed musical into an archetypal realm. There’s no denying the piece is something of a downer, however, it is handled with grace, intelligence, and some spectacular design elements.
81–100 of 156 comments
Highly recommend the show.