Stranger Things: The First Shadow
So good
Amazing set!
Wow. Just wow.
RUN THIS IS SO GOOD
MIND BLOWING THEATRICAL EXPERIENCE
Out of this world, one of the most amazing shows.
Amazing
Amazing
Incredible
Amazing
AMAZINGGG!!!!
Outstanding. Amazing. Fabulous!
My teen daughter thought it was spectacular,, but I am not very invested in the Netflix series. Unlike Harry Potter and the Cursed Child, if you don’t already know the show (I’d only seen 2 seasons of it years ago), the whole storyline is fairly complicated to follow. The set design is compelling and it does have some very cool special effects,. In that respect it was worth watching. Nevertheless, I doubt I would’ve enjoyed the overall experience that much had my teen daughter not been so thrilled about seeing it. She actually ran into a friend who proudly boasted that it was her TWELFTH time seeing Stranger Things. In all seriousness , that’s basically my idea of torture, because I’d almost rather do my laundry than to go back and see this show even one more time. (Edited)
Disclaimer: I have never seen the TV series, but know some bits and pieces about it and was told that watching the series isn’t necessary. Is it necessary? No. Will you like it as much if you’re not a fan of the show? Probably not. As a play, this was exhausting and insufferable. Could I follow it? Yes. Does it make sense? Sort of. Was it intensely annoying? Definitely. From the lead actor’s histrionics, to thirty-year-olds pretending to be high schoolers (with horribly dumb dialogue), to constant loud jump scares (which, if you’re a smart theatergoer, you see coming a mile away), I was both aggravated and somehow bored. Are the special effects great? Meh. It’s a lot of very well done video projections, but there were no “how did they do that?!” moments like there are over at Harry Potter. Also, because this show doesn’t attract the typical theatre crowd, the audience was not on their best behavior — lots of people trying to video, texting, eating, talking, etc. My companion — who watched the TV series — felt that this wasn’t very “special”. He thought it was like another episode of the series, and felt that it spoiled things for someone like me who might watch the series after seeing the show. Which I now have no intention to do! I really wanted to like this, or at least enjoy the special effects. Instead, I couldn’t wait for it to end.
The friend I went with had never seen Stranger Things the series, so he was super confused. Because of this, I recommend knowing the show before going. Some directing and misdirection for illusion/effect sake was splitting my focus. The overall feeling captured the show pretty well. The teenage versions of Joyce, Hopper, Bob, etc definitely had the feeling of a musical without the music: campy, farcical, and provided a good amount of the comic relief for the show. Otherwise, the show goes for shock value like the series. Lots of flashing lights, loud noises. The effects are super cool when they work. It feels like the director has never watched the show from the mezzanine because sitting in the mezzanine, you can see a lot of the people doing the stage magic entering and exiting. I don’t think I’d recommend sitting center mezzanine if you can help it because your view upstage during a big effect moment will be blocked by another effect. If you know the series, I think you’ll enjoy it. It gives background on the characters growing up together in small town Hawkins. The casting of young Joyce was solid. *maybe spoiler?* The story could use more of Henry as the good guy with dire consequences and experiencing personal rejection leading him to embrace the shadow. We only have one real moment of someone realizing what that he was fighting and advocating for him. His dad is written off as a drunk so no matter how much he said he believed in Henry, it didn’t matter. I was expecting something that happened to his dad to connect to the issues with Henry, but no. So that was a weird plot point. Maybe a red herring/misdirection, but it just felt confusing. The added play within a play plot was more funny than anything and gives you a break from the suspense. I feel like I’m being nit-picky, which is what happens when I like the show and want it to be better. I think it will sell on the show audience alone. The preview audience was packed and gave them a standing ovation.
Absolutely phenomenal acting by Louis McCartney as Henry Creel. Easily best performance of the cast, he bodies the role fully! It was a really physical role as well and he absolutely nailed it. He really made me feel for the character, and his voice work is insane, didn’t even know he was Irish until after the play. Super glad he came all the way from West End to reprise the role here! Really liked Patty and Joyce’s actresses too! The play itself was a technical marvel, though I’m personally not the biggest fan of the big usage of screens etc. but I loved the usage of the flashlights and liked that the cast sometimes went into the audience. There’s a particular sequence I loved in the bathroom with Patty and Henry I thought was so cool to watch. And it was interesting to see how they portrayed Henry’s abilities, transformations, and out of body experiences. The play really lends itself to fans of the show, and I am one although I haven’t watched the show since s4 came out so it’s a bit blurry. I personally thought there were wayyy too many high school characters in the play when they were introduced, but it clicked that they were all characters we knew in the show as teenagers or the parents of the kids in the show. Joyce, Hopper, Bob dynamic I feel like can only be really fully appreciated by those who know future context, but they were cute! The story was what I expected current season writing to be, I felt though that Henry’s story was the big focal point I really cared about in the play, and everyone else (Joyce and Hopper and play subplot) was pretty meh, fan service but I understand and I was still engaged! I felt like if you didn’t know anything about the show prior that stuff feels a little out of place in the grand scheme of things. Opening was pretty great, great introduction! It’s the first horror thriller-y show I’ve watched on Broadway too, hope to see more after this one! Would see again to see Louis McCartney’s performance, maybe once the last season comes out if I get another good Theatr deal. (Edited)
𝐒𝐓𝐑𝐀𝐍𝐆𝐄𝐑 𝐓𝐇𝐈𝐍𝐆𝐒: 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐅𝐈𝐑𝐒𝐓 𝐒𝐇𝐀𝐃𝐎𝐖 𝐏𝐑𝐎𝐕𝐄𝐒 𝐇𝐎𝐑𝐑𝐎𝐑 𝐂𝐀𝐍 𝐇𝐀𝐔𝐍𝐓 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐒𝐓𝐀𝐆𝐄 𝐉𝐔𝐒𝐓 𝐀𝐒 𝐖𝐄𝐋𝐋 𝐀𝐒 𝐓𝐇𝐄 𝐒𝐂𝐑𝐄𝐄𝐍. This was my first time seeing a horror genre play, and I was honestly blown away by how well it was pulled off, especially having seen the TV series and knowing the high standard it set for visual effects. Somehow, the stage production managed to recreate that same level of cinematic experience live, and it was ABSOLUTELY THRILLING! The opening sequence alone gave me chills. It felt like watching an episode of Stranger Things! The illusions were brilliant and cleverly executed. There were moments where I genuinely found myself wondering, “How did they pull that off?” The revolving stage were also incredibly well thought out and added so much to the flow of the show. I have to highlight the score— it was intense, suspenseful, and really added to the horror mood. And the jump scares? Totally got me! I was at the edge of my seat for most of the show. Louis McCartney’s performance as Henry Creel was PHENOMENAL. He carried the role with such depth and intensity, and I wouldn’t be surprised if he gets a nomination or even a win. However, while the show excels in spectacle and performances, it didn’t completely deliver as a prequel. The story felt a bit underwhelming and predictable. There were moments that lost its momentum and dragged out but hopefully they polish it out during previews. As a fan, I left wishing for a little more substance to the backstory. Now, do you have to watch the TV series before seeing this? Initially, I’d say no—it is a prequel after all. But to fully appreciate the references and world-building, I think some knowledge of the show definitely enhances the experience. As a Stranger Things fan, this was such a blast to experience live. The production values were top-tier, and it was exciting to see such creative use of theater technology. For fans or thrill-seekers alike, it’s absolutely worth seeing. (Edited)
this is a much more serious and intense show than i was expecting. if you are a fan of the show you will enjoy this. only reason im putting mixed feelings is because the actor who played henry creek at one point had a part where he had to use the snot from his nose as a weapon. that is how im going to put it lightly. beware. shoutout next episode at the end of the show. very funny. my 93rd show. 7/10.
Visually there were some very cool moments, but overall the magic/illusions were not as impressive as Harry Potter, if that’s what you’re going for, and Lost Boys was more my cup of tea for scary/thriller, if you’re looking for a good scare/thrill moment on stage. I hadn’t seen past season one of the tv show and that was back when it originally streamed— so I was able to follow along and appreciate it (as it was a prequel set in late 1950s) but the people around me her were diehard stranger things fans really seemed to be into it much more than I was.
501–520 of 665 comments
Next level!!