Stephen Sondheim's Old Friends
I was pleasantly surprised by this celebration of Sondheim’s legacy. I expected to enjoy it but also was thinking since it was a revue it would be more like a concert than a fully staged performance. Of course the performances are stellar (Bernadette Peters and Lea Salonga? I don’t need to tell you this), and it’s such a joy to listen to these beautiful songs with a full orchestra in a Broadway house as nice as the Friedman. It’s sort of like if someone made a Sondheim playlist, and then instead of burning you a CD, presented it as a fully staged show with sets and costumes and props. For me it was also a nice mix of familiar and unfamiliar pieces, and it’s curated in a way that finds throughlines between songs from different shows. Also the best audience I’ve been in for a WHILE, especially for a Wednesday matinee. I hate that it’s notable when no phones go off and people are actually sitting quietly but it was a breath of fresh air after some shows I’ve been to lately. So shout-out to all y’all who can make it through 2.5 hours without scrolling TikTok, providing a running commentary to your companion, or eating snacks out of crinkly packages. You’re wonderful and I appreciate you. (Edited)
there are no words to describe just how magical this show was. every number felt like a showstopper, and despite the length, the revue flew by. i'm admittedly a bernadette fan, and despite knowing better, i was still so surprised at just how good of an actress she is. her comedic timing during "broadway baby" and "you gotta get a gimmick" had me in stitches. and her "losing my mind," hearing that live was a dream come true. and her "not a day goes by," i just couldn't stop crying. again, the emoting is the best i've ever seen, she's a legend for a reason. AND "SEND IN THE CLOWNS," UGH. honestly, i could go through every song and just gush. i want to give a special shout out to maria wirries. she is a freaking star, i could barely take my eyes off her. she shined so brightly during "a weekend in the country" and "waiting for the girls upstairs." okay, enough about the performances, because this will be way too long if i give as many compliments as i want to. okay one more. beth leavel's "ladies who lunch" was the best i've ever heard–and this is coming from someone who's favorite musical is "company." the lighting in the show was phenomenal. the red during "the ballad of sweeney todd"? CHEF'S KISS. and honestly the pacing was so good here. there was such a good balance of tear jerkers, patter songs, 11 o'clock numbers–i never felt fatigued as an audience member, or like the show was lagging. order was truly perfect. i will also say, despite not having many songs from "sunday," something i will always treasure from this revue is that i feel like it made me finally, VISCERALLY feel the emotion behind "sunday in the park with george." i get it now, and i can't wait to rewatch the proshot. RUN. DON'T WALK.
One of my favorites for the 2025 season. Don’t even think of missing this if you are a Sondheim fan. I feel fortunate to live during a time to witness his brilliance. Peters was touching and very funny. Salonga brought me to tears with her “Loving You.” I also adored all the Sweeney numbers and many around me did not even recognize that Lea was Lovett. So delicious. Just run to see it.
cried more than i thought was humanly possible tbh
I was pleasantly surprised by the costumes but I loved it. Im not super familiar with Sondheim songs/shows so the costumes were helpful. This was like getting a brief lesson into Sondheim’s songs and I had a great time watching the incredibly talented cast perform it live. The seat was great too. The theater is kinda small so I think most seats would work and the row I was in is raised so no worry of heads in the way.
Omggg!! Seeing and meeting Bernadette Peters, she was soo friendly and funny!! The show overall was so joyful with Stephan behind watching, and hearing some of these Broadway legends sing these songs they usually don’t sing is insane!!! I’m gonna miss it!
A lovely little afternoon out. Only hits the shows produced by Cameron Macintosh so there are notable omissions- and I would have liked more Sunday in the Park with George and less Sweeney Todd, but that’s just me. Doesn’t try to be anything it isn’t- sparkly costumes, and a lot of good songs with no dialogue. Super fun to see some real divas shine.
So it’s for the Sondheim fans and it really WORKS. It’s like a reunion of stars new and old that carefully curate from his entire catalog and legacy. Bernadette is grand (!!) but the real star is LEA SALONGA! She owns each solo monumentally. It’s a smidge long in length but that’s okay cause every fan has their favorite and should have that right. A truly magical night of theatre and theatre nerds!
Lea Salonga was epic! Hilarious and outstanding performances from the rest of the cast. I admit I wasn’t familiar with music outside of Into the Woods, Sweeny Todd, West Side Story and the some classics but NOW I have a list of musicals to watch!
I wouldn’t miss Bernadette for the world and she is as charming as ever. Gavin Lee also steals the show (and Jacob Dickey and many other members of the company). Gimmicks aside. Rehashing aside. Lea being out aside. What a lovely tribute and showcase of Sondheim and artists from different eras.
I sobbed
It was amazing everyone is so incredibly talented and you can really see the that everyone has for Sondheim as a person and as a writer. You can feel their connection to the pieces from any spot in that theater.
I wanted to watch the show to see Lea Salonga perform live and I was blown away, not just by her performance, by all performers. It didn’t matter that I don’t know all the songs. Every second of the show was sooo worth to watch. Loved it! Wow!
Saw it at the beginning of May and hoping to see it again before it closes. A few members were out for illness but Bonnie Langford, Bernadette Peters and Lea Solonga were outstanding.
A fantastic revue of Sondheim’s work! I really enjoyed this. Lea Salonga stole every scene she was in and the remaining ensemble members were all incredible. They did a lot more than I expected with set pieces. It was a really incredible production.
A fun night for any Sondheim fan - songs from many different shows, brilliant work with the sets, and probably one of the most talented casts out there. End turns into a bit of a weird memorial, but overall very enjoyable.
Great seats in the mezzanine and a really fun show.
I always thought one wouldn’t catch me in a variety show, but how could I resist a Sondheim fest? Great acting, singing, star-power galore.
This is a revue and obviously the songs are fabulous because it is Sondheim. Lea Salonga is my absolute #1 favorite theater singer, and she did not disappoint. Bernadette Peters is of course a legend, and it is always a treat to see her perform. As a total aside, she is possibly the most incredible looking 77-year old woman on the planet. She is as beautiful as ever. In fact, this whole show was an ode to the vitality and appeal of mature theater actresses because there were many of them in this cast. There are other consistently enjoyable performers here - I have never seen Beth Leavel or Gavin Lee not rock a performance, and this is no exception. Daniel Yearwood was a favorite in the revent Sweeney revival and he was great here too. I was not familiar with Bonnie Langford before and she was a standout for me. Same for Jacob Dickey. Lots of this is straight forward revue stuff, but there were some fun surprises I won’t spoil including the choices in You Gotta Have a Gimmick and the casting for I Know Things Now. Finally, I really wish Lea had been Mrs. Lovett in this last revival as opposed to Annaleigh or Sutton, because she was unbelievable here with the Sweeney songs.
1–20 of 120 comments
𝐓𝐡𝐢𝐬, 𝐦𝐲 𝐟𝐫𝐢𝐞𝐧𝐝𝐬, 𝐨𝐥𝐝 𝐨𝐫 𝐧𝐨𝐭, 𝐢𝐬 𝐚 𝐡𝐞𝐚𝐫𝐭𝐟𝐞𝐥𝐭 𝐜𝐞𝐥𝐞𝐛𝐫𝐚𝐭𝐢𝐨𝐧 𝐨𝐟 𝐚 𝐌𝐮𝐬𝐢𝐜𝐚𝐥 𝐋𝐞𝐠𝐞𝐧𝐝. First of all, if you’re going into this expecting a traditional narrative show, this is not the show for you. Sondheim’s Old Friends is a celebration of Stephen Sondheim’s legacy, a showcase of his work performed by a powerhouse ensemble. If you’re a fan, this will definitely bring back so many memories. I haven’t seen all of Sondheim’s work since I’m a new Broadway fan, but as someone who loves musicals, this show was such a treat. I specifically went to see it because of Lea Salonga, who I’ve admired for so long as a fellow Filipino. She continues to amaze me, and I couldn’t be prouder. I may be biased, but she absolutely stole the show!! There were several segments that stood out for me, especially the ones I was already familiar with—like songs from Gypsy, Into the Woods, Sweeney Todd, and West Side Story. I was also impressed by how cleverly some of the set changes were executed to match the tone of the songs. Even though I didn’t know most of the songs, the show still managed to move me. There was something really powerful about seeing audience members tear up during the finale. It was a beautiful reminder of just how much Sondheim’s music means to so many people. That emotional impact was truly inspiring. I do wish I had been more familiar with the entire song list because I think that would have deepened my appreciation. Some of the song segments felt a bit underwhelming in their staging. But my personal favorite was the Sweeney Todd performance. Lea Salonga as Mrs. Lovett completely blew me away. There were a few things that didn’t work that well for me. Some of the segments felt a bit too simple, and not knowing all the references made it harder to connect at times. I also found myself wishing there were more appearances from Lea Salonga and Bernadette Peters. Personally, I’m not a huge fan of Bernadette’s singing voice, so a few songs I had been looking forward to didn’t quite land the way I had hoped. At the moment, I wouldn’t rush to see it again until I’ve watched more of Sondheim’s musicals. But I was glad I got to see it. If you are a Sondheim fan, whether you’re new to his work or have loved it for years, this show is a heartfelt tribute that has something to offer for everyone. (Edited)