Show/Boat: A River
Pros: Show Boat has a truly masterful score and it was sung BEAUTIFULLY in this production. The vocal performances blew me away and there was a lot of talent in the cast. I also thought the book was interesting and compelling when I was able to follow it. Cons: The staging was not great. The costume choices were just odd to me. Everyone looked like they were going to different events to do different activities in different places during different time periods. I found myself getting confused at some parts given how quickly the actors were changing roles, and also because some of the roles were oddly shared between actors. This production chose to do colorblind casting, and every time a character played a white character, they wore a sash that said “white.” The sashes were often put on backwards, worn under costumes that were hard to see, and were so big that they repeatedly fell off cast members. Overall, the poor execution was so distracting that the point they were trying to make got lost. This felt like a production where they wanted to do something new and different with Show Boat, but didn’t know how, so they just tried a bunch of new things without tying it into the actual story and ethos of the show. If you can overlook some frankly bizarre staging choices, you might enjoy this, but I do think there are better productions of this show.
I’ve never seen another Show Boat production so at first, I thought it was the reason why I was confused for a majority of the first act. It was blind casting so a sash was used to distinguish between the races, and the actors spent a lot of time trying to adjust / taking off / putting on their sash. It was distracting. I think they tried to take the musical in too many different directions, leaving it a bit hard in the beginning to grasp what was going on. My favorite part was seeing how the orchestra was part of the show and their interactions with the cast. The score is beautiful and the cast certainly did it justice! (Edited)
This was a really interesting theatrical experience for me, as Show Boat obviously has such a significant place in Broadway history. I thought individual voices and performances were very strong, I loved the score, and thought many of the first act costumes were lovely. But this was my first production of Show Boat, and at least for the first act I really struggled with understanding the plot or which actors were playing which characters. I might recommend that people familiarize themselves with the general outline loosely beforehand! And I think that while some of the choices really felt impactful and hard-hitting, I might have benefitted from knowing a bit more about the show to understand why other choices were made.
A couple of good moments but overall... it's a no for me. The music was amazing though, sitting close to the orchestra was such a bonus
an insightful re-staging of an extremely flawed classic in the musical theater canon. if you are a theater lover and historian, there is much for you here. some of the songs were sung wonderfully, and a lot of the directorial choices worked well within the context of this framing. however, some moments had me scratching my head a bit. i can’t recommend this to a causal viewer, but if you love classical musical theater GO!
A disaster! No characterization to speak of. Concept really didn't work and seemed to be abandoned as it went along. Actors seemed at sea. Lots of people left at intermission. Some really uninteresting stage pictures. No.
This needed a BLACK dramaturg. This was not a reimagining of the story. I left wondering what the point of this being remounted was, especially so sloppily.
This reimagining of a classic, golden-age musical does not go as far as I would have expected in actually interrogating and deconstructing its source material. Beyond its inventive casting, and a fascinating opening tableau whose experimental spirit seems to dwindle as the piece goes on, I struggled to come away with many future-facing insights on material that is dated. While I didn’t find the piece extremely offensive (which is a major triumph, based on what I know of the original), I also didn’t feel a spark that compelled me to lean fully into the world and experience of the show. Still, there were highlights that I enjoyed! Great vocal and comedic performances from the cast, especially Temidayo Amay and Stephanie Weeks, were a delight. Detailed costume design and accessories by Dina El-Aziz provided some interesting commentary to support this production’s non-traditional casting. Lighting Design by Cha See created a variety of fun and spectacular looks, especially after intermission. I loved the orchestral arrangements too. Admittedly, I’m not someone who has a lot of familiarity or love for the original Show Boat, so I’d be curious to know how a fan of the original would respond to this production.
The score has some real bangers… and if we’re gonna do show boat in 2025. I guess this is how. I do have mixed feelings AND recommend it to theater MAKERS. This is an important step in a longer conversation and process of engaging with the musical theater canon. In a positive way it reminded me of a lot of recent work I’ve enjoyed, such as Oklahoma! and Soft Power. I’m going to sit for a while in the discomfort with some of the elements and others I will chalk up to tech. Some of the elements really worked and others did not. I’m sure previews contributed to some of it! Very sensory friendly. (Edited)
Just missed the mark. Hard to sit through. Felt like I was living in a post-structural nightmare
confusing. the music was great, but if you haven’t seen the movie it’s a confusing show. the plot is not overly interesting and the story around the central couple is a bit all over. great music though!!
Didn’t really like it. Very weird. An old Timey show that doesn’t translate well to modern day (it’s still set back in the day). It’s just too confusing
Not a show for everyone.
Showboat Reimagined?! More like Deimagined. This production was disappointingly minimalist and felt like I was watching a rehearsal. The score is so beautiful and the musical direction was stellar - a real shame that the rest of the production elements were so lacking.
Saw this on Saturday. We — and many others — left at intermission. Not the worst production I’ve ever seen but it wasn’t good.
Left at intermission and it was hard to stay that long.
unfortunately not the revelation or shocking stage spectacle i was craving.
No boat show boat
1–20 of 20 comments
Great stripped down version of a classic. Love the simplicity.