Saturday Church
So much energy, joy, and love. Great choreography and singing that really embodies the complexity of a black queer experience!
Review: Saturday Church New York Theatre Workshop (Viewed during Previews) Directed by: Whitney White Book & Lyrics by Damon Cardasis & James Ijames Additional Music by: Sia and Honey Dijon Whitney White’s staging of Saturday Church ignites with life, refusing to be contained — a production that radiates love, resilience, soul and unapologetic pride from every corner of the stage. Rooted in the real-life Saturday Church program at St. Luke’s in the Fields — a lifeline for LGBTQ+ youth in New York — this musical doesn’t just entertain but insists on being felt. J. Harrison Ghee gave yet another stellar performance, stepping into two radically different roles with power and nuance — one as a straight Black pastor, the other as a queer Black Jesus. Watching him transition between these identities with such command was nothing short of astonishing. Bryson Battle’s voice carried the show’s emotional core with soaring conviction, while Jackson Kanawha Perry’s magnetic presence made it impossible to look away. Even with two understudies stepping in (J’Quay Gibbs and Oyoyo Joi), the performance I saw never faltered — a clear testament to the depth of talent in this cast. The choreography was bold, the lighting sharp, the costumes striking, and the ensemble filled the space with kinetic energy that was on fire. They brought not only strength and precision but also a level of sexiness and erotic charge that elevated the entire dynamic of the show. Their talent and physicality gave the production a pulse that was impossible to ignore. Musically, the collaboration between Sia and Honey Dijon delivered exactly what this story demanded: a score that fused gospel transcendence with pulsing house beats and modern pop, turning the theatre into a living, breathing sanctuary of sound. Where the production stumbled was in the writing. The script leaned too heavily on familiar clichés and never pushed beyond expected beats. Coming from such an accomplished and celebrated playwright, I wanted bolder choices — scenes and themes that would truly break ground in driving the modern conversations around inclusion and tolerance. Instead, the text sometimes felt like it was trailing behind the power of the performances and the music. What carried the night was the exchange of energy between performers and audience — a give-and-take that grew until the entire room was vibrating with recognition and joy. By the final moments, it felt less like theatre and more like community. Final Verdict: Fierce, vital, and unforgettable! This one’s cleared for takeoff — carrying pride and power all the way home. (Edited)
Amazing choreography, talented cast and a lovely message of inclusion.
Always wear your shoe, whatever it is 👠🪩✝️ Saturday Church redefines faith as something you live through love, not judgment. It’s about building sanctuaries in unexpected places: a dance floor, a friendship, a moment of truth. All are welcome. Just be you. What a powerhouse of voices, truly holy and moving. Glad I was able to catch this before closing.
Feel good gay trauma 101. But great songs and cast!
queer heart and joy
Beyond! It’s EVERYTHING. Great performances and fantastic writing. Go see it!
So much fun!
CANNOT SAY ENOUGH GOOD THINGS ABOUT THIS ONE!
LOVED THIS SHOW!!!
Amazing! The cast is fantastic!
Amazing
Ok the music by Sia was a treat! The cast that sang it blew the roof off NYTW!
There’s a lot to like in this fun, touching new musical. The music is pretty great, and right in line with what you’d expect from Sia. The choreography, lighting, and costume design are stellar. The cast is great, and J. Harrison Ghee shines in his glorified (and glorious!) supporting role. Joaquina Kalukango is terrific, but is underutilized and burdened with the evil aunt character. The book is okay (I surprisingly found myself choked up at the end), but needs some polishing. That being said, no amount of polishing can rid the book of its unfortunately generic story and character tropes. There’s absolutely nothing new here — gay kid finally comes out of the closet and is surrounded by new LGBTQ “family” who give him support (and a new pair of heels!). Meanwhile, he struggles to come out to his actual family, who are hard-working, church-going folk. But it’s all a happy dance sequence in the end! It’s surprising that a Pulitzer-winning playwright couldn’t come up with something more unique. That being said, the show is still worth your time since it’s so rare that a solid, original musical comes along.
The cast’s singing and dancing are top notch but the melodrama that is the second act feels more sappy than satisfying. However, it’s worth seeing for the divine J. Harrison Ghee alone.
Great performances. Bland script and the songs are forced.
needs some work / shortening but i like the concept. great performances
Was thrilling , the vocals were unmatched! Has some room for growth but a great foundation !
Wonderful on so many levels- Casting (save for the lead, who while his voice is phenomenal as he was a The Voice contestant, his acting left much to be desired, especially next to Tony winners like J. Harrison Ghee, & Joaquina Kalukango, and the phenomenal Kristolyn Lloyd.), music (co- written by Sia & DJ Honey Dijon) & 🔥 choreography. You'll want to see this.
1–20 of 22 comments
I have so many feelings about queer trauma and queer joy and queer liberation. This show certainly has the DNA of Fat Ham, the Jellicle Ball, A Strange Loop. It posits a world in which embodying our authentic selves is absolutely vital, not because we are in denial that the world is not trying to kill us, but precisely because we are fully aware that it is. Anyway, the show is stunning: musically, visually, vocally, philosophically. “I can have the best of both worlds.” “There’s only one world. You’re either in it or pretending that you’re not.”