Romy & Michele: The Musical
Kara and Laura are incredible. Glad I saw them on stage finally!! But show was just eh
Overall, a fun, upbeat show!! Songs are a bit wordy and could definitely use some editing, but I enjoyed it nonetheless
It’s silly and fun like the movie plus you get Laura Bell Bundy’s best performance since Legally Blonde. Some of the cast and tech are shaky but hopefully they smooth it out by opening night.
miss my classmate
Just lower your IQ to 50 for 2 hours and watch this. It was so funny! Now I wanna go back and watch the 1997 movie.
Yikes. The songs all sound flat. Literally off pitch. The harmonies between our 2 POWERHOUSE leads are BAD. I think this is just the score they were given and couldn’t do much about it. Should have given these 2 women more space to sing like we KNOW they can. Heather - Jordan Kai Burnett - STEALS THE SHOW. Her vocals EAT. And I was ON my feet immediately at the end of her song. (However, not being able to remember the song 2 hours after? YIKES. And the rest of the songs are even less memorable because of the aforementioned constraints on these 2 power house leads. Let them do their thing. And please don’t have Laura bell SING in that Mira Sorvino drawl! She’s already annoying speaking in it! I think even as a cult fan of this movie - see photo. This was ROUGH. I go to musicals for the music and I can’t remember a song name or tune. Just that they sounded flat and the harmonies were off They felt muted and restricted. Also - why ADD time to a tight 90 minute film about 2 best friends who live in LA and make clothes and then go to a 10 year reunion and make up a lie they invented post its - into something MORE than that. That’s the plot. It works as a campy movie that’s a tight 90 minutes as movies WERE in 1997. But 2.5 hours with and intermission. Why!? We cult followers of the movie are definitely satisfied with the one liners and iconic costumes (and modern dance - if you know you know) Why add fluff! If a cult follower of the movie is bored - imagine the people who haven’t even seen the movie It’s a ridiculous plot and movie that works because it knows it is just that.
Generic and lackluster. I’ve only seen the movie once, so I’m not part of its cult following, but listening to the very tepid applause by the audience, I doubt they liked it much better than I did. The laughs fall flat, the ensemble is playing everything broadly, and even Bundy seems so overwhelmed by her affected accent, that she can’t play or have any fun. Lindsay fares a bit better, but neither role soars. The leaden book and the truly flat score are the main culprits here — I have no interest in hearing a single one of these numbers again. While I know this is still in previews — and given the insert in our Playbill listing several nixed numbers, I know they’re still making changes — no amount of changes (except replacing the composing team) could fix this. The second act is at least somewhat better than the first, but this should be a ridiculously stupid comedy, and no one is finding the laughs.
If reliving high school sounds like a nightmare, Romy & Michele: The Musical might remind you why. The show, adapted from the 1997 movie Romy & Michele’s High School Reunion, follows two best friends heading back to their ten-year reunion armed with a wild lie about having invented Post-Its. On screen, that story was quirky, sweet, and weirdly relatable. On stage, it becomes a neon-colored marathon that can’t decide if it wants to be satire, nostalgia, or parody and ends up not really succeeding at any of them. Let’s start with the obvious issue: this musical is way too long. It clocks in at two and a half hours but easily could (and should) be 90 minutes. Almost the entire movie script is here, word-for-word, with new songs wedged in between lines we already know. It feels like the film’s dialogue got turned into lyrics, and not in a clever way. It’s more like someone tried to rhyme their favorite quotes and called it a day. The songs themselves are rough. Not a single one stuck with me after the show, and by the middle of Act I, they’d all started to blur together into a kind of generic pop haze. The one exception was “The Lie Will Set Us Free,” which actually had a hook and fit the moment. Otherwise, it’s hard to tell where one song ends and another begins. That’s a shame, because the cast is strong. Laura Bell Bundy (Romy) and Kara Lindsay (Michele) are both charismatic and clearly having fun. Lindsay nails the quirky, wide-eyed energy we expect from Michele, and Bundy has flashes of her trademark comedic sparkle. But even they can’t sell material this thin. Vocally, both seemed off their game. I’m not sure if it was bad sound mixing or just an off night, but there were several wince-worthy notes. And honestly, the ensemble often sounded better than the leads. Jordan Kai Burnett, who plays Heather, absolutely runs away with the show. Her vocals are stellar, and she brings a dry confidence that cuts through the fluff. Every time she came on, I perked back up, which, considering how slow Act I drags, was a relief. The production design leans heavily on color and nostalgia. It’s all hot pinks, blues, and yellows. Very Lisa Frank meets mall boutique. The set is bright but looks a bit flimsy, and the projections do a lot of heavy lifting. Sometimes that works; other times, it’s distracting. There’s one dance number where silhouettes are projected on the back screen, and the live dancer isn’t matching them so it looks sloppy instead of stylized. Costume-wise, there are hits and misses. The quick changes are fun to watch, but the reunion outfits for the “popular girls” looked like shiny nightgowns. And at one point during Act 1, poor Toby literally had to hold up his pants to keep them from falling down. That about sums up the night: plenty of effort, but things just don’t quite hold together. The second act fares slightly better. The pacing improves, and a few jokes start to land again. The “Michelle’s Nightmare” sequence, featuring oversized fruit cutouts, is bizarre but at least memorable. Then comes an interpretive dance between Romy, Michele, and Sandy, complete with psychedelic Lisa Frank–style projections swirling in the background. It’s supposed to be emotional, maybe even profound, but it mostly left the audience confused. There are still moments of fun sprinkled in. The set’s bright color palette is eye-catching, the audience loved the nostalgic nods, and the curtain call where Romy and Michele appear in fabulous Post-It dresses finally delivers on the campy fun we were promised. The lobby setup (complete with a Post-It wall and photo booth) is also cute and well thought-out. But overall, the show just doesn’t add up. The heart of Romy & Michele - two outsiders trying to reinvent themselves - is still there somewhere, but it’s buried under too much filler. The creative team clearly loves the source material, but they’re so busy re-creating it that they never let it evolve into something new. It’s a great movie and I really wanted to root for this musical. But between the clunky pacing, forgettable songs, and some genuinely head-scratching choices, I left the theater more exhausted than entertained. If you’re a diehard fan, you might enjoy it for nostalgia’s sake. But if you’re hoping for a clever or refreshing stage version, this isn’t it.
Maybe I would have enjoyed it more if I had an emotional connection to the movie but I came in kind of blind. Powerhouse leads of course but the jokes fell flat and the jokes didn’t land. Also multiple actors broke (started laughing) at the different points, which is funny and silly once but got old quickly.
Just because you can, doesn’t mean you should. Lyrics so bad I wanted to rip my ears off. …4-5 in the cast are giving their best go vocally, but with book and lyrics like this, what’s the point? Probably my new poster child for “not every movie needs to be a musical!” (Edited)
When the majority of the show is a giant distracting screen doing crazy animations maybe you should go back to school and remember what a musical is supposed to be to look like. The book is almost beat for beat the film but the jokes don’t land at all, the choreo is unbelievably bad, and the music and lyrics are forgettable and uninspiring. Sorry to be harsh but this just was not it.
everything could have been perfect and i still would have gone sour at the CLEARLY AI photos used in the projections during act 2. unfortunately, not everything was perfect. the music is unmemorable, and some of the language could've used an appropriate update, even if they stuck with the 90s timeline. and also there's AI.
I so wanted to love it. I grew up quoting this movie. But the music was terrible. The book only had a few references to the great writing of the film. It just fell flat.
Cast was fantastic. Vocals were top notch. LBB and Kara Lindsay had the characters down. The songs were flat and non memorable. But nice to have those movie moments that made me so hard!
First preview and I’m hoping it gets better but it is in very rough shape.
how dareeeee they use ai on the stage. disgusting addition to what would’ve been cute.
21–37 of 37 comments
The cast gives their all and are fantastic. The songs are good but the book is lacking.