Romeo + Juliet
some of the most promising actors on broadway overshadowed by fan culture sadly :/ i was elbowed in the face when walking out of the theatre by somebody trying to stagedoor. i’m all for people being excited about something but not at the cost of hardworking ushers trying to prevent a stampede / disruptive behavior during a show! anyway!!!! gabby bean’s mercutio was a completely fresh and innovative take on the character, and she is really solidifying herself as the next big face of broadway. i enjoyed her take as the friar, but most of the doubling didn’t make sense in the context of the story. i think gold’s idea was to stage a bunch of kids at a club putting on a production of romeo and juliet — but it didn’t really make sense. pull up gimmick was cute; song didn’t have to do anything at all with the plot. happy i went though??? had some really genuine moments of joy watching one of my favorite plays.
Beautiful but not flawless. Loved my location at times but I felt excluded at crucial moments. The doubling of certain characters was executed expertly, it made the relationships more layered and the ensemble deserves more applause. The chemistry was sweet and individual performances shone, but it lacked the passion that was advertised. Loved the use of space. I read certain reviews that were confused about the placement of the songs, but in my opinion they MADE this production stand out and were some of the most memorable moments of the show. My heart broke most for the teddy bear, which says a lot.
Review was that it’s very Zillenial and a nice way to bring Shakespeare to the youth and feel modern. A fresh take on Baz Luhrman movie. I don’t know if it’s worth all the money but Rachel & Kit definitely have star power & amazing chemistry!! A cast of 10 v the 22 characters in R+J in think they needed more costume/items to differentiate the character mid production. Was confusing at times.. Lots of color, music was dope, felt fresh and updated. The way Kit & production used the WHOLE theatre was amazing!!
The acting was incredible. I had a little difficulty discerning who was which character throughout the play and I didn’t get how the beginning fit into the rest of the story- their opening addition didn’t really tie into the play well enough for me. But the acting was fantastic and the story was beautifully told. I intend to see it again. Also- barely any seats in the house that aren’t incredible seats. (Edited)
First things first, this cast is outstanding. I did not know Kit Connor before this production, but his performance was simply perfection. I could listen to him recite Shakespeare any time, any day. Rachel Zegler is immensely talented and (spoiler!) what a treat it was to hear her sing live. Gabby Beans was also a standout for me. Secondly, I love the idea of a modern Romeo and Juliet, but this production was a little confusing to me. Modern set, modern costumes, modern jokes, but recited in shakespearean english. It took me out of the immersion because what I was hearing and what I was seeing didn’t mesh well in my brain. Still very entertaining, but I didn’t quite see the point in mixing the two ideas.
TLDR Top pros: Gabby BEANS; bringing young people into the theater even if it’s just to terrorize kit connor (who’s wonderful!) Top cons: the vibes are not my vibes. why?!?!? Pacing a bit odd. Doubling a bit confusing and side note didn’t love the extra violence towards femmes. For me. Accessibility gets a C- Acting overall gets an A- Direction/Concept gets a C+ Design gets a B. But y’all can enjoy it if you like! The concept is lost on me as an old tm. Then again I’m younger than the director and at least some of the cast. I’ve hit my threshold for shows this season of bloody people screaming in their underwear. They each had their merits, but one more of these and I swear I might be next. I’m also now more confused about the marketing after seeing it. I know the department of education is almost gone but I’m pretty sure kids know this show for now. Longer than I was hoping it was going to be. The songs are well sound especially by Zegler but the songs themselves are so unmemorable. Aren’t there enough musicals being taken over by pop composers that we don’t need plays doing it too? Kit Connor is a wonderful actor, Rachel and Tommy are great. I believe their chemistry and their youth. For sure. Gian was hilarious, like him in Sing Street a lot too. I always love Tommy. And again. Hell yes. Tony for Gabby Beans. I would not see this twice. I don’t mind that I saw it. If you know me, you know, I review an audience and the kids were not as badly behaved as I was expecting, but they were still kind of annoying. I’m glad they’re seeing theater though. The theater is in the round and they use every inch of it. No bad seats no perfect seats. Midway through the theater was nice. Accessibility wise, it’s pretty harsh sound and lighting, and the entire theater has stairs and tight ish chairs. Oof. (Edited)
I think there were some stellar performances in this show (Kit Connor as Romeo being the standout). And I think any show that can bring Gen Z to theater belongs on our stages. However, I think the directing was really lacking. Some staging was incredibly beautiful, while some felt awkward and juvenile. The actors are great, but it felt like they were on different pages stylistically, and some struggled with the language. I think the doubling would be quite confusing with people not as familiar with R+J, and there was little character distinction acting wise. Act 1’s cuts and lack there of dragged on - which is common with many productions, but especially prevalent here. But the most disappointing aspect was: for a production with the central thesis of “The youth are F***ed!,” beyond the production having the aesthetic of a 2023 FYP, the play struggled to outline the tension between youth and the authority that surrounds them. Dorfman and Fadiran are older than the rest of the cast, but don the same fashions and lack distinction from the rest. In all, a lot of the underlying themes Gold attempts to highlight (toxic masculinity, its relationship to homoeroticism, love and hate, etc) come across as undercooked and have little follow through.
Kit Connor is worth the price of admission. He’s a true talent, no stunt casting. His facility with the text is so superb, it sounds so natural in his voice and is still able to be contemporary without sacrificing the source material. His Romeo is heartbreaking and effervescent and hopeful all at once. I can’t say that for the rest of the show - I do think in modernizing it for a Gen Z audience some of the tension and believability gets lost. The production design is beautiful! And the Capulet monologue in Act 2 will stay with me for a long time - next level performance there. I do think it’s worth seeing! Also Rachel’s voice is unreal.
Okay, so hear me out. It’s 80% basically just a Shakespearean play. With the Shakespearean dialogue. If you like this, then you will like this. If you’re like me, and it wasn’t really my cup of tea at all, then I wouldn’t recommend. 20% of the show was amazing and did liberties and diversions such as some dance scenes, fight scenes, Rachel Zegler singing 2 shorts songs, and some cool set designs and slight changes, but the other 80% was just a Shakespeare play. I mostly came for the amazing seeing and talent of Connor and Zegler so honestly I almost had as much fun and enjoyment at stage door seeing them than at the show lol, so for this reason maybe my recommendation would be to not see it.
Perfect seat location! I went mainly to see Gabby Beans and Sola Fadiran, who were both great, but I didn’t love the double-casting conceit. Kit Connor was terrific. The rest of the company was a very mixed bag, as was the production itself.
It was life changing watching Rachel and Kit performing. However, kind of hard to understand for someone that speaks esl! (Edited)
a rollicking, energetic, deeply creative production! I thought Act I was stellar with some of the coolest staging of Shakespeare I’ve ever seen, then Act II felt muuuuch weaker and duller in comparison. Great performances from the whole cast, I really enjoyed this one overall but wished more creativity had been implemented in the back half 3.5/5
I really enjoyed a lot of the choices they made with bodies and movement. The actors who doubled and tripled roles STOLE the show. Their versatility was mesmerizing. The rest fell a little mediocre and flat. But still an enjoyable night of theatre! The music was killer.
Kit Connor, omg, is such an amazing actor. The songs were okay, I didn’t find them necessary but I know this show was trying to do its own thing. I admire that the actors were able to make Shakespeare and the old english feel believable, it’s a hard task! I’m in between ‘Recommend it’ and ‘Mixed Feelings’, but Kit Connor himself makes this a must watch. (Edited)
i'm a bit of a shakespeare snob (and a sam gold critic) so this production falls a bit short for me pros: - highlight performances from kit connor, gian perez, and gabby beans - that flower bed is so stunning cons: - questionable setting and double casting choices; mr. gold loves to repeat Bits™️ and R+J is no exception. how many times can you direct a dead character to rise and become a new character, sammy boy??? - the music honestly feels out of place structurally and lyrically; we get it, you want to show off rachel!
Kit Connor BROUGHT IT! The same can be said for a handful of the ensemble (Juliet's dad, Tybalt). Ultimately, the production felt really muddled, and on a personal note, if I leave your Romeo and Juliet production without fully understanding why the lovers killed themselves, I think you haven't succeeded at a core level.
the use of space was fantastic, actors were all very skilled & was impressed by their performances. however, very targeted towards teen/very young adult audiences. i’m in this demographic and still found myself teetering on the edge of an opinion for this show. cool experience though.
Bad diction couldn’t understand what they were saying and switching roles is confusing.
181–200 of 256 comments
I really wanted to see this because I’m a huge fan of Heartstopper and Kit Connor — so I was very happy with this floor seat that was really close to a number of his scenes. Kit was also the standout performance here. That said, depending on what you want from a show, this may not be for you. And, beyond Kit’s performance and the general aesthetic, it wasn’t as memorable as it could have been.