Rob Lake Magic with Special Guests The Muppets
Statler: I love a good magic show! Waldorf: Yeah, we should go to one of those next time! Look, I actually do love even a halfway decent magic show, I am very gullible and easily impressed. I even enjoyed El Mago Pop, even though connoisseurs of magic shows were down on him. He was charismatic and knew how to put on an entertaining show. Rob Lake… this ain’t it. Weirdest vibes I’ve ever seen. Would be embarrassed if this was my kid’s birthday party! Muppets are criminally underused. An audience full of enthusiatic children and Mr Lake refuses them the opportunity to participate, even when the participation is nothing more than “choose a number between 1 and 50”. (As one reviewer said, if you don’t like working with kids, this might not be the right career? But I suppose you can’t hire kids as plants?) Amateurish camera work which often had the mezzanine staring at black screens or once, memorably, a lingering shot of Rob Lake’s nipples through his shirt as he struggled to smoothly do a connecting ring trick just like the one I once had in a childhood magic kit. No narrative throughline as he mixes history lessons, personal anecdotes, flashy tricks set to thumping pop music and strobe lights, cringeworthy audience participation / sleight of hand tricks, and occasionally a Muppet showing up to do exactly nothing (to the loudest applause of the show) and then leave again. Embarrassed for this guy and everyone involved with the production. It was fun to see the Muppets live on stage though, however briefly.
The illusions are good, the muppets - scarcely used enough or creatively - are what the audience screamed for. But Rob Lake has no charisma and just never connects with the audience. After every trick he stands at the front of the stage as if begging for applause. The use of a live camera to show the audience is a HUGE mistake when the theater isn’t even half full. It just spotlights how bad the show is selling.
No wonder this is closing early! This feels like an off-Strip Vegas act circa 1985. The magic is generic, cheesy, and nothing you haven’t seen before — sawing a woman in half, disappearing/reappearing, and conjoining rings. Rob has a fair stage presence, but does nothing to give the audience a throughline and The Muppets (which is who we’re all there for) add nothing to the show. They’re mostly animatronic, with prerecorded voices. They’re barely in the show and act as a sort of comic relief, but the audience is only smiling because we love them so much. This is not the vehicle that should’ve been used as their Broadway debut. Additionally, Rob’s magic wasn’t meant for Broadway. He never involves people in the mezzanine, his lighting designer is shining lights in everyone’s eyes for most of the show, he’s hired so many noticeably bad plants, and his final trick is confusing because only a few people in the audience can see the result. This was bland, boring, and lazy all around.
No thought was put into sight lines (we were all the way in the back and were hardly able to see the screens where a lot of the magic was being performed), Rob Lake was pretty stiff with a lot of his line deliveries, and the Muppets were in the whole show for a combined fifteen minutes. The illusions and tricks themselves were also pretty pedestrian for what a Broadway magic show could or should be. The Muppets deserve better!!!
One of the most boring magicians ever. His tricks were all done before and there was no excitement or enthusiasm. Plus don’t advertise the muppets if there are on it for 8 minutes total.
It was great to see the Muppets make their Broadway debut for all of 10 minutes. The Magic seemed like something we have all seen before.
It’s already closed so I’ll make it short and sweet. This was not a good show. I found his magic to be lackluster and the Muppets were hardly in it. And when they were in it, it didn’t make any sense.
Some tricks were ok and others were cool but he is pretty bland. The scripted parts were rough.
Needed more muppets.
barely any muppets (Edited)
21–32 of 32 comments
If you like classic magic tricks then this is the show for you!