Reunions
Jeffrey Scharf and Jimmy Calire’s REUNIONS is one of those evenings that feels modest at first, then deepens beautifully as it goes along. What begins as a gentle, almost old-fashioned musical gradually reveals unexpected emotional contours - small, well-placed moments that accumulate in surprising ways. With a compact cast and an intimate musical ensemble, the show somehow manages to feel both cozy and expansive. Scharf’s book and lyrics and Calire’s music pair two early-20th-century plays that share an undercurrent of wistfulness and what-if longing. Under Gabriel Barre’s direction, the production flows with an easy confidence. Edward Pierce’s set, centered around a rotating circular rug, gives the staging a continual sense of motion without any fuss. And the lighting design by Ken Billington and Mitchell Fenton, those soft memory-laced blues and warm afternoon shades, adds an emotional vocabulary all its own. “The Twelve-Pound Look” The evening begins in a London home buzzing over Harry Sims’s upcoming knighthood. Bryan Fenkart nails Harry’s self-satisfied energy. He’s amusing precisely because he believes every inch of his own hype. The day takes an unexpected turn when he hires a typist and realizes she’s his first wife, Kate. Chilina Kennedy’s performance brings the entire act into sharper focus. She plays Kate with calm intelligence and a quiet resolve that rewrites the emotional dynamic of the scene. Through their conversation and brief returns to the past, we see how she bought herself a typewriter and carved out a life that wasn’t defined by Harry’s expectations. Courtney Reed, as Harry’s current wife, adds sincerity and brightness that soften the household’s harder edges. “A Sunny Morning” A lyrical transition delivers us from London to a Madrid park, where Joanna Glushak and Chip Zien meet as two strangers sparring over a bench. What starts as petty irritation slowly exposes a shared history neither is ready to admit. This second act leans delightfully into comedy. Zien’s dry, grumbly wit and Glushak’s sly, warm charm create a rhythm that’s almost musical in itself. Their escalating back-and-forth culminates in a very committed sneeze bit that sent a nearby group of ladies into delighted, irrepressible laughter. A ripple that only added to the atmosphere. The musicians help shape that atmosphere as well. Sonny Paladino’s orchestrations give the score its nostalgic glow, with violin, accordion, and guitar painting an intimate soundscape. One musician, in particular, appears now and then inside the scenes themselves strolling through with an instrument, offering vocals, or simply observing like a friendly ghost drifting through the stories. It’s an unexpectedly enchanting touch that reinforces the show’s theme of memory lingering at the edges. Jen Caprio’s costumes bring both acts into crisp period focus, while Megumi Katayama’s sound design keeps everything clear, warm, and close. Reunions isn’t a musical that tries to dazzle you with spectacle. Instead, it works its way under your skin through its quiet confidence, thoughtful staging, and the very human performances at its center. It’s tender, funny, a little nostalgic, and ultimately surprisingly moving. And Chip Zien? He doesn’t just shine, he practically waltzes off with the entire second act, umbrella and all.
The second part is really cute but the first half drags.
Sweet and well done but not my favorite.
The story in the second half is better than the first but tbh, I’d skip it all together. Checked my watch a lot as I felt bored. The space is super intimate though, a secondary theater at NYCC, so you’re up & close and personal in practically every seat in the house.
Acting was good but the story and music were boring, Kate was a highlight
1–6 of 6 comments
I have been seeing a lot of plays about love lately, and I don’t enjoy romance much, but this play was great. It wasn’t the normal play about love. I LOVED it. The story about the older couple was so cute and the story about the divorced couple was empowering. Happy I saw it, as I originally wasn’t going to. The songs and singing were very enjoyable. The instruments were great as well.