Redwood
Note if you get motion sickness you might not like this show or have to close your eyes. It feels like theater is moving and you’re moving sometimes. Felt sick during the show
A big ole melodramatic “meh”. While I applaud the fact that this is a completely original musical, this would’ve never made it to Broadway without a star attached. The book is oddly unaffecting and never rises above average — it feels like they were trying to write Idina a “Next to Normal” type part and simply couldn’t execute anything nearly as deep or touching. It’s like we’re visiting Maureen and Joanne from “Rent” 30 years later after they got married and had a kid. The score is generic soft rock that often seems like it might take off and then just deflates. And Ms. Menzel, as much as I admire her, noticeably sings off-key throughout the show. While I’m sure it’s upsetting for her, it’s hard to stomach as an audience member as well. The innovative production design is neat, but you feel shortchanged if you sit midway or further back in the orchestra, since the mezzanine is flanked by screens that make the design more immersive. (Edited)
Awful. Idina Menzel is tired and she was screaming the whole time. The plot was terrible and somehow the music was worse. I often found myself laughing at the parts that weren’t supposed to be funny and rolling my eyes at the bits that apparently were.
Concept was good, but music was terrible. Aerial dancing was minimal. A real snooze until it makes you cry at the very end. Idina couldn’t make up for how bad it was despite her talents.
Thoroughly disappointing. As a tree hugger and a big Idina fan, I just felt let down by the thin story line, unoriginal writing, and too many songs that kind of all sounded the same. The visuals were pretty and there were a few moments that resonated, but the strongest moments in the show were due to the fact that trees are awesome and we can learn a lot from nature…. Not from the writing itself. I just really am at a loss for words. The cast was talented and clearly passionate, but this was just a miss.
mannn not good !! I hate to say I really couldn’t get into this one. dialogue and lyrics are poorly written, Idina is doing her best but the show is working against her talent incredible vocal performances from Khaila Wilcoxon and Zachary Noah Piser !!! they rocked big tree! some cool aerial stuff but could’ve been expanded on for sure 1.5/5
I am so surprised by those who liked this show. This was the worst piece of art I have ever consumed. I found myself laughing throughout the show. Went for Idina and even her performance left something to be desired.
We felt the story was pretty thin. Great actors and a few good songs but just not enough to make up for the lack of set and storyline.
the sets were cool! and there was a good song! and i got to see idina finally! and the sets were cool! but also michael park is fantastic in this. but the sets were cool! my 80th show. 5/10. (Edited)
It seems as if someone heard Idina Menzel’s famous riff at the end of “Defying Gravity,” and thought, “Wow, let’s write a show where she can belt entire songs composed of riffs like that non-stop!” Making matters worse, the song arrangements in “Redwood” are a mashup of bluesy rock and the pounding strings and drums you’d find in a nature film – you know, that pulsing underscoring used when the cheetah is about to nab the antelope for dinner. What to blame? Is it the songs themselves by Kate Diaz and Tina Landau? Overindulgent music supervisors? Menzel’s own vocal and stylistic choices? (She is credited as the lead actor plus “co-conceiver & additional contributions.”) Or all of the above? Whatever the cause, at one hour and 50 minutes without intermission it’s exhausting – and unfortunately, catching; nearly every other song and actor ratchets up to meet her level. Even the dialog seems shouted half the time. When a lovely quiet moment does occur – “Looking Through This Lens,” as sung by De’Adre Azziza – you’re relieved. Somewhere buried beneath all the bombast is a story about life, loss, love and renewal. But darn if I could find it. What the show lacks musically is made up visually; it has the most extensive use of video projections in any Broadway show so far. The scenic design by Jason Ardizzone-West and video design by Hana S. Kim take the form to new heights, easily rivaling what you’d see in a first class Disney or Imax experience. (Edited)
TERRIBLE. Projections are beautiful but the story felt flat and Idina’s character is extremely annoying. She is going through a traumatic experience but she was not likable at all. Songs were not memorable.
I did not love it. I, also had no idea of the story line and would not have purchased if I had. Idina is a wonderful singer and the rest of the cast was good. Full two hours with no intermission in one of our most cramped theaters was a negative.
Pros: attempts to tackle loss and healing, a few excellent moving numbers, singing acrobatics by Adina, some projections were cool Cons: poor book and character development, newbie style lyrics and music, superficial treatment of loss and healing, aggressive tear-jerking
Missed the beginning of the show, seat held for 13 mins bc of late arrival 🥹 the character development in Redwood felt abrupt, and the story itself came across as rather flat. (Edited)
So sorry Miss Menzel and Miss Landau but this just wasn’t it. This show tried to cover some seriously heavy topics but didn’t land a single one. Left the show very frustrated. Everyone in it was a talented singer and actor but the book did them so dirty.
One of the worst Broadway musicals I’ve ever seen. The trite stories and bland songs didn’t surprise me, and Idina Menzel gave a standout bad performance in a cast where almost no one was giving a good performance was a surprise. The set and effects were cool though.
As much as the cast can really sing, the score feels very boring. The staging is fantastic, up there with the best such as Maybe Happy Ending. That all being said, I really didn't appreciate just how much levity was brought to such a heart wrenching topic at the worst times. I don't think the book is very well fleshed out. I don't think the show knows the story it wants to tell.
Didn’t need to be a musical. Music was not memorable, story was forced, characters were flat. However the talent was very good.
221–240 of 258 comments
Impressive! The set is beautiful and immersive and the vocal talent on stage is pretty amazing.