Punch
This entire cast is impressive. I see a few names that won’t be forgotten around Tony season
This show was incredible! The acting was superb and incredibly raw. This show is absolutely worth the hype and the message is really powerful. Highly recommend.
True story, fantastic acting. Photo of my seat.
Intense subject matter but an absolutely beautiful play, I cried through the entirety of act II. Wasn’t sure I was in the right mindset for Punch but it turned out to be more touching and heartfelt than sad and still had a lot of laughs throughout, so very glad I ended up seeing it! The whole cast is amazing, Will Harrison’s delivery and charm is a standout for the NY theatre scene. (Edited)
Fantastic performances take us on an emotional journey.
great show it was very moving (Edited)
Very moving. Great acting. Beautiful set.
very powerful
Powerful story of redemption and resilience..
An amazing production with an important topic that should be seen by everyone.
Amazing actors, such a strong story (Edited)
It's a really moving story and a great ensemble of actors. I did genuinely cry a lot.
A very powerful story
Every adult should see this
Review: Punch Manhattan Theatre Club – Samuel J. Friedman Theatre Directed by Adam Penford | Written by James Graham Based on the true story of Jacob Dunne, Punch takes audiences deep into the heart of a tragedy and the long, uneven road toward redemption. Adapted from Dunne’s memoir Right from Wrong, playwright James Graham invites us to confront the consequences of one impulsive act and the extraordinary grace that follows. What begins as a story about guilt and punishment slowly transforms into a meditation on forgiveness, healing, and the radical humanity of Britain’s restorative justice system — a process that asks not just what was done, but what can still be repaired. The first act struggles to find its footing. The pacing feels uneven, almost like the chaos inside Jacob’s own mind — spinning, restless, constantly in motion. There’s a lot of narration, a lot of movement, but not enough space to truly feel what’s happening. Despite the strength of the ensemble, I found myself disconnected, frustrated by how distant it all felt. Yet beneath the noise, you sense and hope that something is waiting to break open — and when it finally does, it hits like a tidal wave. Act II is where the play earns its name. The storytelling slows, breathes, and dares to be still. Then it quite literally punches you in the gut — so raw, so honest, that the emotion becomes almost unbearable. You could hear tears throughout the theater as the story unfolded, mine included. It all felt so deeply real that, for a moment, the boundary between audience and stage disappeared. Will Harrison, in his Broadway debut, delivers a performance of such aching authenticity that it doesn’t feel like acting at all — it feels like truth. Victoria Clark meets him with equal grace and humanity, her every glance and word carrying the quiet force of lived experience. Together, they create something transcendent — as if we were witnessing the two real people at the center of this story, stripped of pretense and performing straight from the heart. Adam Penford’s direction keeps the focus grounded and human, while the minimal design — stark lighting, pulsing sound, and an open stage — strips everything down to what matters most: the truth. I only wish the play had lingered longer on Jacob’s fractured family, the unspoken love and loss that shape him. His brother’s brief coming-out moment, the shadow of his mother’s death — they appear like passing ghosts, leaving you longing for more understanding. Still, the play’s emotional weight is undeniable. Punch doesn’t moralize or lecture — it opens a door. It asks what justice could look like if empathy were part of the sentence. It’s not just about one man’s redemption, but about a system that dares to believe people can change, and a world that’s brave enough to let them. When the cast took their final bow, I felt both heavy and hopeful — reminded that true reform doesn’t erase the past, but builds something honest from it. Final Verdict: After a turbulent takeoff, Punch soars — and lands with the kind of impact that lingers long after the lights fade. This one’s cleared for takeoff — go see it. (Edited)
Takes a while to get going, but packs the proverbial punch. Excellent leads. Very moving, especially the second act, & benefits immensely from fine performances from Will Harrison, Victoria Clark, & Lucy Taylor who deliver heartbreaking portrayals. But, the playwright includes extraneous scenes (e.g. why does a minor character suddenly come out to his brother only to never be seen again?) Play deals with "restorative justice," but did not succeed in convincing me that I could be as forgiving as some of the main characters here. But, you believe them & their motivations & journeys. Bravura performances from the 2 mothers & the convict, but other actors playing multiple roles haven't yet distinguished each of their characters from each other which leads to some initial confusion. (Edited)
I went into this show not knowing what to expect and still left disappointed. While the actors are really great, I wasn't a fan of the script nor the pacing of Act 1. I saw a reddit review that compared this play to the plays we were forced to watch in HS and that was absolutely accurate for how this feels. It's not uncommon for people to leave during intermission.
Strong acting and direction. Will Harrison and Victoria Clark were great at times the writing or motivations seemed off but the key revolves about the main conflict and I wish it focused more on that.
I found this to be good, but not phenomenal, mainly because the first act is over an hour’s worth of narrated exposition. When there was scene work between two or more characters, it was much more affecting, especially in act two when the real payoff happens. The acting is solid and the direction is fine, though it seems burdened by a prescriptive script that sees multiple actors double-cast. It’s also burdened with an unnecessary amount of choreographed movement, which seems interesting at first, but looks kind of faux modern-dancey after a while. (It’s like Steven Hoggett-lite, and not nearly as good.) The sound design is good, and the accents are easily understood. The lighting is impeccable, but the static set leaves a lot to be desired. I think this would’ve been more interesting in a smaller, off-Broadway space.
21–40 of 57 comments
Extremely powerful show. Supreme acting by the main lead.