Proof
Fantastic
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
10/10
The lightning blocks out the right side of the stage. A more center seat would’ve been better. The show was sooo good. The dynamic between Don and Ayo on stage is top tier. Let’s talk stage door- After the show Don, Ayo & Kara came out to Stage door approximately 10:45PM and took photos and signed playbills. We waited until approximately 11PM. Jin just waved at us. He didn’t even stop. I was a fan of his performance but not his flippant treatment of the fans after waiting almost half and hour for him.
Went into Proof pretty fresh (saw the movie years ago, barely remembered it). With Don Cheadle and Ayo Edebiri, expectations were high. I left… underwhelmed. Set design first: flat, lifeless, almost distractingly bad. The neon moment hits for two minutes, then you realize that’s kind of it. Cheadle? Barely there. Feels like they stretched scenes just to justify his name on the poster—and it doesn’t add much. Ayo brings a very Gen Z, low-energy vibe that reads more “checked out” than layered. It never fully lands Overall: it wants to feel deep, but plays lukewarm. Needed tighter editing, clearer direction, maybe no intermission. That’s the proof.
Kara Young is a star, and Jin Ha is on the rise. The writing is obviously great — it is a thought provoking and surprisingly funny piece. But this revival doesn’t hit all its marks. Don Cheadle’s performance was emotionally flat and his pacing and delivery threw me off several times. I found Ayo Edebiri to be severely overacting the “later in time” sequences, which also drew me out of the play. The costume design, set design, and lighting were dull and uninspired — and what was present was underutilized. I left the theater wondering what message the producers and creatives were trying to impart on today’s audiences through this cast in this show right now. It was never clear. For a contrasting example, the current production of Death of a Salesman casts Charlie and his son as Black actors, and stages them mainly in the wings while the Lomans play centrally. The exception to this rule comes in Act 2 — Charlie is center stage as he offers Willie a job, which Willie refuses and refuses. These choices force modern audiences to confront new meanings, particularly relevant in our time, inside a familiar text. This revival of Proof lacks any such clarity of purpose in its casting choices or its interpretation and presentation of classic material. (Edited)
I saw the previous run of Proof in the early 2000s and absolutely loved it. I was in high school and fully captivated by the complexity, the emotion, and the feeling that something deeply intellectual could also feel deeply human. So I came in with high expectations, especially for Ayo Edebiri. My main takeaway is that I wanted more ownership from both Edebiri and Kara Young. There’s a version of this pairing where Young’s potential for big, slightly unhinged comedy plays beautifully against Edebiri’s specific, charming awkwardness. But here, it felt more like two incredibly talented actors merely delivering lines. Was it bad? Absolutely not. But with performers like this, you expect sparks and surprises. Don Cheadle, too, felt a bit too polished; I never fully believed his decline into mental illness. And overall, the pacing could have moved with more urgency to match the tense emotions with faster delivery. Overall, I wish this show took more risks.
This is a really good play in a very weak, muddily-directed production. I saw the original, which was heads above this one, mainly due to the exacting direction of the performances. Here, we have two capable screen actors (Edebiri and Cheadle) who seem somewhat lost on stage, especially Cheadle (as much as it pains me to say that). Both are somewhat flat, and even Young (who I normally love) and Ha don’t fare that well either, mainly because the direction is so nonexistent. I think the Broadway community too highly regards Thomas Kail. He’s not necessarily a great director — he may have just gotten really lucky by pairing up with Lin-Manuel Miranda. It’s a shame…. I have very fond memories of this play, but feel like I wasted my time on this bland, underwhelming production.
Seats we’re comfortable with a good view. Show was fabulous and the Theatre seller, Wendy, was a pleasure to communicate with.
Loved the acting talent on this stage and storyline was unique! Pace was a bit slow at times but made up for it with surprise comedic lines.
WOW! Acting in th thus was top tier. Way to go Ayo! The lighting was also pretty appealing. Will definitely catch this again.
Loved the story loved the acting, fun inventive set just wish the pacing was better - it so slow and just not much going on. The last ten minutes however is incredible. I feel like they could have a done a lot more with the direction. Overall, I would recommend it!
81–100 of 130 comments
Loved it