Pirates! The Penzance Musical
Best show and best cast
Hilarious show !!
Amazing! Hilarious! Must see!
One of the greatest shows I’m seen in a long time
Best thing I’ve ever seen
Just a fun time!
Loved it!!! Just a lot of fun!!
Fun! Funny!
Musical Comedy at its finest!
Loved it! (Edited)
The best show ever
𝐀𝐇𝐎𝐘! 𝐓𝐇𝐈𝐒 𝐒𝐇𝐎𝐖 𝐃𝐈𝐃 𝐍𝐎𝐓 𝐁𝐑𝐈𝐍𝐆 𝐌𝐄 𝐉𝐎𝐘! Pirates! is one of those comedy musicals that offers pure fun but not much substance. This show was not on my radar at all, and the poster did not really spark my interest in seeing it. Still, I gave it a shot to see if it might surprise me, but it ended up being exactly what I expected. Just mindless fun without much heart. I kept waiting for some emotional depth throughout the show, but I never felt anything or cared about the characters’ stories. However, it did have some funny moments. David Hyde Pierce was hilarious, and every time he was on stage, I couldn’t help but laugh. The set and costumes were also beautiful and visually pleasing. But these elements were not enough to make me enjoy the show overall. The entire cast did a great job, and the choreography was incredible. I loved how in sync everyone was. With all the dancing, you could tell how exhausting the numbers were, but they still pulled them off with energy and precision. As for the music, I was not a fan of it, although there were a few beats I liked. The genre just isn’t for me, but it does match the pirate theme of the musical. Overall, Pirates! was an okay experience. I am not disappointed because the cast delivered an incredible performance. I just was not that entertained by the show itself. (Edited)
I loved the jazz stylings of multiple of the classic numbers, and Ramin Karimloo was just phenomenal. I didn’t love the altered ending but I understand why they did it. (Edited)
Strong cast and great fun, if you appreciate the silliness of Gilbert & Sullivan. The resetting to New Orleans felt not quite complete and some of the rewriting seemed heavy handed and awkward. But it’s still a very enjoyable evening.
Pretty Woman Moment In 1990, that one line drove me to see this. As a revival, I was curious: what’s changed since its last full-year run? Honestly, I’d love a side-by-side breakdown. The show flirts with camp—and when it does, it works. It never takes itself too seriously, which is both its charm and maybe its biggest flaw. Because sometimes, it should take itself more seriously—especially when it comes to editing (looking at you, Act Two). Instead, it leans a little too hard into being a “tiring” crowd-pleaser—pleasing, but exhausting. It either needs to fully commit to being a rhinestone-studded campfest or lean into what the story is actually trying to say. Right now, it hovers in the middle. It’s not good. It’s not bad. And that’s… okay. But maybe I walked in hoping for a full “pee-in-my-pants” Vivian Ward moment
3.5/5⭐️ Wacky pirate theme party. Weird, dated humor musical with a thin plot. David really delivers with the comedy, acting, and singing! Maybe not your thing: Jinx’s not the best vocals, Ramin doesn’t get to show off his singing, super gendered plot. Diversity: little. Starring a trans actor in a side character. Ensemble includes a few people of color. 2 hour 20 mins; 1 intermission
This was so silly but also so stupid. But like why does it exist!?!? There were certainly some joyous highlights — like DHP’s performance! But otherwise I was unconvinced that we needed this revival or this rewrite. Act two dragged, but act one was fun.
“A Clever, Colorful Pirates! That Knows Exactly What It Is” I didn’t expect to enjoy Pirates! The Penzance Musical as much as I did. Typically, pun-heavy humor sails right past me—Shucked felt like torture, and Spamalot left me unexcited. But this production of Pirates! won me over with its sharp wordplay and unexpectedly clever charm. It delivers the kind of breezy, self-aware comedy I had hoped for in other punny shows that I had not enjoyed. The production bursts with color and energy, from the gorgeously vibrant costumes to the big, Broadway-caliber dance numbers—complete with some tap that feels delightfully retro in all the right ways. There’s a sense of joy baked into every moment, and the show leans into its own absurdity with refreshing confidence. Ramin Karimloo (the “Pirate King”) is a standout (when is he not?) bringing his signature vocal power and magnetic stage presence to the role. His voice adds a rich texture that elevates the show’s silliness with just the right touch of sincerity. David Hyde Pierce (“Major-General Stanley”) is effective, though I struggled to make out some of his lyrics—an issue that felt more rooted in the fast-paced speed of the underlying material than in his performance. Jinkx Monsoon (“Ruth”) delivered a strong performance as well, but I felt as though the role’s more limited presence in the show kept me from seeing the full range of Jinkx’s talent. The story itself is admittedly thin. The setup takes a while to get going, and the ending comes too abruptly to feel fully earned. But this is a musical that knows exactly what it is: light, silly, and built for fun, not depth. Running gags—like spoiler alert: the Pirate King’s refusal to attack anyone who claims to be an orphan (because he’s an orphan too)—give the show a charming, almost vaudevillian rhythm. This won’t be everyone’s cup of tea. The humor is fast-paced and occasionally lost under a booming orchestra. If the style doesn’t click for you early on, it may never fully land. But for me, it did. And I left smiling.
Paradoxically, the second act which is totally razzle dazzle beefed up LAGS BIG TIME! But whenever David Hyde Pierce is on stage it just SOARS!
81–100 of 130 comments
Amazing hilarious JINKX