Operation Mincemeat
If you’re pressed for time and don’t have a British sense of humor, you could pass on this show. It’s very hard to understand the dialogue, and English is my native language. This would be practically incomprehensible to someone who speaks English as a second language.
Tony Hype Crash I was never fully on board with Mincemeat, but I gave the Tonys the benefit of the doubt. Boy, was I wrong. It’s an interesting historical story wrapped in British humor that just never gels — in fact, it becomes genuinely annoying. And at 2.5 hours with a lengthy intermission, it just dragged on and on. There were way too many songs that felt unnecessary and ultimately diluted what is, at its core, a compelling story. It has glimmers of greatness, but it never really took off for me. The British tones might be what earned it Tony love, which is a shame — there was much stronger content this season.
I'm not going to lie and say the casting was bad bc the actors themselves were very good. My issue is with the show itself and how they handle their female characters, so there will be spoilers in my review!!! There's a whole song about how one of the characters wants to be known (and thusly cant bc shes a woman) which ultimately ends in someone else convincing her to seduce one of the male characters to see if he's giving secrets to the Nazi's. Because no, she cant dream of getting a statue or recognition because haha shes a woman! But hey, if she does something that no one else can do (which is apparently seducing someone) then she can save the operation and make a change (but not get recognition, and that is made ABUNDANTLY clear) so yada yada she seduces him. Turns out hes not even giving any information to the Nazi's! So she seduced him... for what? Literally. Nothing. There is no reason in the end for why she went against her better judgement and seduced him. Even though the whole song was about how she could make a (secret) change and save the mission instead of, idk, wishing for something more? What the fuck? And okay maybe it would've been fine if the musical ended with the lead saying "hey look she helped too!" But no. It ends with her getting nothing because shes a woman. Which I GUESS is true to history but god its a musical and its weirdly trying to be 'uplifting woman' (because thats the vibe I got from the song?) But it fails at that spectacularly. It surprises me that there were women in the writing room that let this pass, but to each their own! Overall the cast was good, the plot was... ehhh, and the ending tried to come off as happy and fun and good but ended up leaving me with a sour taste in my mouth.
I was so shocked at how bad this show is after hearing all the hype around it! Seems like it’s aiming for campy but completely misses the mark. It falls flat in all regards; the book, the score, the acting, the production value. Operation Mincemeat is dive bar drag show caliber, nowhere near Broadway quality. The characters seem likable on paper but come across rather irritating for most of the performance. The story ultimately left me with a sense of wasted potential. (Edited)
Couldn’t understand many of the lyrics (guess it’s the British accents) and did not find it funny at all.
I personally did not enjoy the show. I was very excited after seeing the comments here, but this is the first time I had a totally opposite feeling compared to most of the reviews here.
I really hated it Walked out in the intermission in London
Too schticky. Still enjoyable at times. Lyric writing excellent at times. Standout performance from Jak Malone.
The cast is extremely talented and I really enjoyed everyone's performances but I unfortunately really disliked the show itself. I kept waiting for it to win me over but it never happened
A disappointment given all the hype. It felt like one long Monty Python sketch with songs. The cast is incredibly talented.
thought it was a little slow moving, and the best song was the last one!
Weak music. Boring set. Weird casting. Loved the movie. They had great material to work with. Need a better director.
Such overrated show, it’s more like a improv sketch show with some music and rap. Not exactly musical like you think. Only if you are into British humor and some silly jokes
Can’t lie was really boring
The humor was amusing, but not funny. Plot was interesting, but not engaging. Singing was too fast and hard to understand.
Not my cuppa tea. Too over the top.
Sleepy time during act I
681–700 of 708 comments
I think I over-hyped myself. I have heard about this show since it was playing in London. When I watched them on the Tonys, I forgave not understanding most of the words (mumbled) and context confusion. I shouldn’t have waived those off. I had the same experience watching the actual show. Granted, I was tired, but thought it was meh overall.