Operation Mincemeat
I get why this was the number one show of 2025! Such a fun show. The entire cast was amazing. The ‘dear bill’ moment had me bawling. Would definitely go again!
If you like fun, you will love Operation Mincemeat. A brilliantly hysterical way to tell this (bizarrely) true story. Well executed on just about every front, and it manages to still be funny and at times, very surprisingly so, without sacrificing their narrative and story. This cast are having the absolute most fun onstage and it shows. If you have listened to Dear Bill on Spotify, it absolutely hits different in person, and Jak Malone proves why he won the Tony hands down. Natasha Hodgson is also a stellar Montagu, and the whole cast’s ability to swap characters so seamlessly should be studied. I had a fantastic time and definitely recommend this show to anyone needing a blast of joy with a lot of heart behind it, because that’s what this show is at its core.
Brilliant cast and musical! So much fun, but also with moments that will bring tears to your eyes. A cast of 5, playing somewhere around 87 characters in total, using costumes, props, and set pieces in some clever and cute ways. We had a blast and I know I will be going back to see it again! Based on a true and crazy story. I felt lucky to meet the cast afterwards at the stage door (performers stage door-ing is never a guarantee), and they were so nice and genuinely appreciative of their audience. They deserve all the accolades! The music has been running through my head all through the next day! Sail on, boys!
The sound design of the golden is rough. BUT this show is worth it!!! I recommend either sitting in the ORCH or just giving a listen to the cast album beforehand. I prom it doesn’t spoil anything to do so. Another thing I will warn you about, this show has an understudy culture. That means if you are seeing an understudy or a swing you are seeing someone who goes on all the time and they are just as amazing as the as written leads. I went to see it and had 4 out of 5 of the roles played by understudies. Guess what, the show was phenomenal. Particularly Gerianne Perez and Sam Haft are incredible as Monty and Hester. Pls believe me, this show is insanely hilarious, heartbreaking, and heartwarming no matter where you see it or who you see it with.
I wanted to see this again bc David Cumming was out the first time, and it was worth the rewatch. This is such a quirky way to tell the real history and I love this cast and knowing that three of them wrote the book makes this more special!
Won the lottery for this and went in not knowing anything about the show and was more than pleasantly surprised. It was funny, entertaining, educational (I didn’t know this story at all), and the performers were incredible. The stamina they all have is mind blowing! Such a great watch! (Edited)
Such a fun show, I was cracking up. Had Brandon Contreras understudy for David Cumming and he crushed it!
A genuinely fun night of theater! Sat in the very last row of the mezz and had no trouble seeing everything. (I love a show that puts half of their scenic budget into a single scene)
Loved the show - fun, fast, witty. Jeff Kready as Hester was amazing - earned an extended applause. Listened to the soundtrack after the show since I missed a few of the lyrics. Would definitely go again.
An absolute blast!!!! Lexi Rabadi was on for Jean Leslie (& others), having debuted at the matinee that day (so I saw their second ever Broadway performance!!), and she was absolutely PHENOMENAL. really, the whole cast was!! they were also all very lovely and kind at stage door after. 12/10 would go again
Such a phenomenal surprise, even after going in hearing good things. This show is so smart on so many levels and the material lives and dies by its cast - and the cast DELIVERS. We saw one of the Monty covers (Gerianne) who, along with the rest of the cast, was incredible. My one note is I didn’t love the sound design in the Booth, which made some things difficult to hear (which would’ve helped when there’s fast patter to give the audience a chance at understanding - had no issues when I could hear, but sometimes actors were slightly drowned out)
This was a last minute add to our Broadway 2025 trip and I’m so happy I added it. We saw it in early previews, and the cast was amazing. I didn’t know what to expect, but it’s really funny and has so much heart. The 5 actors play about 30 characters seamlessly.
laughing the entire time!! the cast is so talented. I just can’t believe this is a true story!
A very fun show! It was slow for the first 5-7 minutes so I was worried but it picked right up and by intermission I couldn’t wait to see what happened next. The second act completely blew us away!! A bloody brilliant show!!
Saw it Spring ‘26, a fun musical with half a dozen cast - no 600 toes tapping or stomping. I didn’t miss it. Forgot the cast was small. They made the complex story clear, the weird and odd story odd, and had us rooting for each major character. I knew the true story and was still awestruck by it.
Fantastic fantastic fantastic. And I would probably even like it more if I didn’t miss a lot of the jokes lol I’m not a laugh out loud kinda guy usually, but I was hootin and hollerin
This musical had no right to make me cry twice.
21–40 of 708 comments
Fun, the actors aknowleged the crowd (broke the 4th wall), made everyone burst out laughing multiple times! Stagedoored and 4/5 members came out, and they were all so very nice! Seating Tip: It doesn’t matter much where you sit, it’s a very small theater- you’ll be able to see it perfectly fine from anywhere in my opinion!