On the Evolutionary Function of Shame
LOVED this. Can’t say I’ve seen anything quite like it, and most definitely have not seen characters like me often as a gay and trans man. The nuances and the family struggles were all so very real, especially when it comes down to extremely damaging but “well-meaning” loved ones to trans people. The og Adam and Eve were delightful, but I wasn’t quite able to tell how their storyline was wrapped up in the main one. Nonetheless, thoroughly enjoyed this.
Without spoiling too much, On The Evolutionary Function of Shame is a play that grapples with a huge existential question that cuts deep into the intersection of queerness, politics, and science. Taking place at the beginning of everything, and in a future that doesn’t seem that distant at all, tensions run extremely high between the lofty ideals of the world some hope to create, and the devastating truths of the world we currently live in. Prepare to get uncomfortable and get challenged by this one. Tonight was the first preview, so I’m sure there is a bunch of tightening and polishing ahead, but overall really solid performances and dramatic momentum, especially after *that* moment really sets the play off. The production also had a really cool scenic design (You-Shin Chen) and sound design (Bailey Trierweiler) to help jump between settings. And mad respect to the SM team (Genevieve Ortiz and Nat Kelley DiMario) and crew as well, there are multiple scenic moves, and so many particulates on stage to deal with! I go back and forth on how I feel about the biblical interludes, so I’d definitely be curious to hear other folks thoughts on those!
SO. As a Jewish trans man who has my own relationship with the themes of this show I feel beyond qualified to talk about it. No spoilers but it is incredibly thought-provoking, confronting, and startling. A recurring motif/phrase of “I love you. Is that enough?” In the face of some really uncomfortable things really strikes a chord. It made me want to have more conversations, which is a sign of a good play. My cis friend had a good time too! The main negative I will say is that they need to do a better job about accessibility and letting people know there are flashing lights especially at top of show.
PHENOMENAL SHOW! I cried twice. It was so relatable as an autistic queer parent with an autistic queer child
A tough show to watch because it was so emotional, but very thought provoking. Everyone is a human being and deserves respect no matter how much hate spews from Washington and the far right lunatics. All the actors did a great job and the set was beautiful.
Interesting play with religious and scientific themes. I loved the complexity of the relationships. It was a very authentic portrayal of an unrealistic situation
With a title like that, I was excited to see that the pre-show set was greenery arranged to spell “EDEN” - looks like we’re starting from the very beginning! And we do; the play opens with the original Adam and Eve creeping onstage and follows their journey into old age inter-spliced with scenes from a different story of a modern-day pair, also named Adam and Eve. Trans man Adam navigates his first trimester of pregnancy while begrudgingly receiving prenatal care from his twin sister Eve, who just so happens to work in genetic engineering. When he finds out that his partner, Fox, has known about his sister’s research into eliminating gender dysphoria in newborns and has withheld this information from him, Adam begins to spiral into doubt, questioning his own firmly held beliefs as well as who he can trust. Doubt, which often lurks among feelings of shame and dysphoria, is a central theme in this play. There is a moment where Adam and Eve question which came first: doubt or creation? The audience is challenged to investigate our own beliefs surrounding artistry, assimilation, and even the importance of love - does it really have as large of an impact on other people as we think it does? These themes are hit home by the unseen “dads,” (yes, that includes G-d himself,) and their influence on the motivations and fears of the characters we see onstage. Playwright D. A. Mindell’s writing excels in moments of vulnerable dialogue, portraying raw humanity, joy, and pain. Second Stage’s production excellently elevates the intended themes of his play, especially with the direction, which is especially touching during the intimate moments between the romantic couples and a particular monologue between parent and child. Ryan Jamaal Swain, who embodies confident, cozy, and conflicted gender fluidity in all of its glory, gives a standout performance. The set and lighting designs depict stark binaries, (a desert sun followed by thunderous rain, clinical white against isolating darkness, and the first man alongside the first woman,) while also challenging them with the modern set eventually integrating into the ancient one, with EDEN’s greenery doubling as a backdrop for a birthday party, and with the very existences of a pregnant Adam and a nonbinary Fox. THE EVOLUTIONARY FUNCTION OF SHAME addresses humanity’s capacity for evil both in Cain’s murder and in the rejection of trans people that drives them to death so young. As we open the news every morning to more freedoms and rights being taken from us by the government, these moments of evil strike a deeply personal and solemn chord with the audience. I applaud the creative team for bringing these discussions to the forefront, and I hope that artists continue to resist terror by raising awareness and generating empathy through storytelling. (Edited)
This show is so beautiful. It covers the topic of trans people’s journey in a deeply moving way. It’s a very short run (sadly) so if you can see it, don’t hesitate!
I will be thinking quite a bit about this one. There is a lot that was really interesting throughout, mostly the conversations around lgbtq+ themes, as well as neurodivergence. But it doesn’t all necessarily leave you feeling fulfilled in the end. I attended an early preview performance - a lot to be worked on around, especially scenic transitions - but I am actually really curious to see how this play evolves throughout the preview process, which is a great thing. There is potential here, it just needs tightening and focus. Mostly struggled with the blend of the “before” times with the “near future”, whose scenes were making me lean in more. Props to 2ndStage for producing a play that features these themes at this particular time. May we continue to center them when it’s most needed. I do hope to catch it later in its run and see where it might land a few weeks from now. (Edited)
I struggled with this play, but I so wanted to love it! I thought the themes were easy to identify but I felt the acting was overdone at times. The set changes felt clunky and the dialogue in certain scenes just didn’t flow or make sense. The ending felt abrupt…I was so confused. It felt incomplete & rushed. I really wanted to love it but it just fell flat for me…6/10 (Edited)
I'm glad this play was programmed since it covers very important topics. Elizabeth Ramos and Ryan Jamaal Swain were standouts for their grounded yet nuanced performances. However, several scenes felt stilted, actors lacked chemistry, and lines were fumbled so the show often felt like a dress rehearsal rather than a polished production.
Poignant. Ending needs working.
It’s so boring. The middle school-level writing and acting had me dozing off. And paint over those Home Depot buckets used to pour sand on the stage. Home Depot donated huge amounts to Trump.
1–16 of 16 comments
An incredibly timely new play. As someone who is part of the LGBTQ+ community and neurodivergent, this play brings up some very relevant topics that hit close to home. Playwright D.A Mindell artfully writes characters that feel real, and gets his message across without feeling “preachy.” The show has a strong cast (standouts to me were Cody Sloan and Elizabeth Ramos). It was great to see an autistic character played by an autistic actor (Imani Russell). The end of the play left me wanting more. I would have happily sat through a second act. The set, lighting, sound, and costuming also all worked together well to create the world and tell the story. I am curious to hear reactions from audience members who are less familiar with trans folks. I think some of this may be confusing to them, but hope that they will leave with a bit more knowledge, curiosity, and empathy. You don’t need to understand someone fully in order to love them and fight for them. I saw the first preview, and while there were some small bumps, I really enjoyed this show and recommend it. I am interested to hear what changes may be made by opening. (Edited)