Not Ready for Prime Time
It was a cute show. I enjoyed it and I learned a little bit about the SNL actors from the original SNL. The set was great also
I loved this show! I didn’t know a lot about the history of SNL prior to seeing it and thoroughly enjoyed learning more about that! The live orchestra really contributed to the energy and feeling of a Saturday Night Live taping. This was such a fun watch!
A must-see for fans of early SNL! The ensemble is excellent, with especially standout performances from Jared Grimes (Garrett Morris) and Evan Rubin (Gilda Radnee).
Loved it!!!
-the band was fantastic! -the set was amazing! -great direction! -no bad seats in the place except maybe on the sides in the front row. The actors do a great job including people no matter where you sit. -Some of these actors were phenomenal, some felt a bit actory and flat. The guy playing Garrett Morris blew me away. -The writing was not bad. It sometimes felt like it was more written for tv where the jokes would work better with a cut or an edit. But they try with the lighting cues and it’s not bad. -the scenes that were just women felt a bit like men asking themselves “…hmmm what should we write for the women talk about? Let’s make sure to include them and their feelings” like rather than getting real women’s input on how women hang out and interact and support each other. -the nostalgia of sketches was fun -overall would totally recommend.
Review: Not Ready For Prime Time The Robert W. Wilson MCC Theater – Newman Mills Theater (Seen During Previews) Directed by Conor Bagley Written by Erik J. Rodriguez & Charles A. Sothers The premise had promise — the untold story of how Saturday Night Live became late-night legend — but this one feels stuck in rehearsal. While the cast gives safe, comfortable performances, few impersonations truly land, leaving the characters more echo than embodiment. The clear standouts are Jared Grimes and Evan Rubin, who inject real energy and charisma and consistently ground the show whenever they’re onstage. But the writing keeps the ensemble grounded when it should let them soar. The set design is ambitious and impressively detailed, though several transitions need tightening. The live band brings excitement, but the balance often buries the dialogue and kills the comic timing. There are interesting origin tidbits about SNL, yet the pacing drags and genuine laughs are scarce. Ironically, the curtain call — when the cast finally cuts loose — is the most electric moment of the night. Final Verdict: ✈️✈️ (2/5) — Not Ready For Prime Time taxis on the runway but struggles to lift off; the few sparks of energy aren’t enough to carry the full flight.
Not Ready for Prime Time is a play with high aspirations, much like sketch show it strives to honor. Fans of Saturday Night Live know that when the jokes land, the show soars but when they miss the mark, it makes for a very long evening. In that way, Not Ready for Prime Time and SNL have a lot in common. There are many aspects of this show that really work. From the second audiences walk into the theatre we are transported back 50 years to the NBC soundstage thanks to the detailed set designed by Justin and Christopher Swader. Complimenting the set and creating immaculate pre-show vibes is the house band led by, Annastasia Victory. There are few Off-Broadway plays with a band as charming and invigorating as this one. Victory not only wrote and orchestrated fantastic arrangements to some of the best songs of that time period, but also composed new pieces that fit seamlessly into the show. Playing these famous comedians live leaves the cast with huge shoes to fill. For the most part they deliver the necessary nuances and comedic timing one would expect. Ryan Crout gives an impressive performance as John Belushi, bringing the larger than life energy the legendary comedian was known for. Woodrow Proctor portrays Chevy Chase with an unexpected humanity, often funnier than the real Chase could ever hope to be. Even still, there are two true standouts in the cast. It would be easy to dismiss Caitlin Houlahan’s performance as Jane Curtin since Curtin was known as the “straight woman” in Season 1 of SNL. However, in a play stuffed with so much plot and big personalities, Houlahan’s ability to ground the piece, keep the pace moving and make us laugh all at the same time is astounding. Houlahan embodies Curtin’s star power and sincerity capturing the audience in a way not many can. Garrett Morris’ struggles with isolation during the early years of SNL are tastefully explored and I can’t imagine anyone playing the role with more grace than Tony Nominee, Jared Grimes. Grimes brings great range to the role. He is absolutely hilarious one moment and deeply troubled the next. The result is a beautifully nuanced character that is unmatched. Houlahan and Grimes’ performances bring the whole production to another level. I’m not sure I would have enjoyed the show nearly as much without their contributions. The play, co-authored by Erik J. Rodriguez and Charles A. Sothers, examines many different stories over a wide range of time. Overall the script itself is satisfying. However, at times the co-authors seemed more excited about recreating famous sketches than exploring the lives of the comedians, making a lot of moments feel unfocused. In a play that runs a full two hours and thirty minutes, any lack of clear direction has audiences shifting in their seats. On the topic of direction, the work done by Director Conor Bagley is sadly a major weak spot. While exploring the story of SNL, creating a cohesive cast in controlled chaos is key. However, not only does Bagley fail to focus the piece, but their lack of vision creates a type of chaos that’s distracting rather than honoring the spirit of the show. Ian Bouillion’s performance as Lorne Michaels feels similarly weak. It is as if Bouillion is more focused on doing an impression of an icon rather than inhabiting a character. Overall, Not Ready for Prime Time is a healthy dose of nostalgia and laughs for any fan of the TV show. Sure, it has its flaws, but so did the first season of SNL. I appreciate its ambition and with many of the cast members making their Off-Broadway debuts, it’s inspiring to see new stars honoring the comedians that came before them. Not Ready for Prime Time is not quite ready to open Off-Broadway, but it’s so close you may just have to go see it for yourself.
Entertaining and funny with some amazingly spot on impersonations (Belushi, Gilda Radner) and some that weren’t so spot on, but still enjoyable (Chevy Chase, Dan Aykroyd). The key to a successful viewing of this show is to be a big SNL fan and very familiar with the original cast. I was and had a good time. But if I didn’t know who these people were it would have been a real slog.
The show lacks clear vision and not all the cast have done their homework. However, it’s fun to see some of the iconic sketches. Shout out to Jared Grimes for continuing to put in the work.
Erik J. Rodriguez and Charles A. Sother’s NOT READY FOR PRIME TIME takes us back to 1975, when Saturday Night Live was just an idea and no one could have predicted it would become a cultural phenomenon. The play offers a behind-the-scenes look at how Lorne Michaels and a group of unknowns (Dan Aykroyd, John Belushi, Chevy Chase, Jane Curtin, Garrett Morris, Laraine Newman, Gilda Radner, and eventually Bill Murray) helped reinvent late-night television. The concept is compelling, but the production struggles to find its own voice. Framed as a flashback from Lorne Michaels’ perspective, the play moves through key historical moments, the casting, the creative chaos, the first live show, without fully exploring their emotional or comedic impact. The first act in particular feels like a series of checkboxes: Belushi being wild, Chevy being arrogant, Gilda being sweet. Individually, these moments are fine, but they don’t coalesce into something memorable, and the pacing drags. The second act improves, with looser scenes and more genuine character interactions, enough to make the story engaging. However, the structure becomes uneven. Narration jumps between characters unpredictably, and some scenes feel disjointed, as if the production ran out of energy or rehearsal time. The cast is clearly talented and committed, even if the script doesn’t fully support them. Jared Grimes charms as Garrett Morris, Evan Rubin captures warmth and vulnerability as Gilda Radner, Kristian Lugo is fun as Dan Aykroyd, and Caitlin Houlahan brings grounded intelligence as Jane Curtin. The performers’ efforts are evident, but the original spontaneity and unpredictability of the SNL cast remain elusive. At its heart, “Not Ready for Prime Time” aims to be a fast, funny backstage comedy about a groundbreaking cultural moment. Instead, it often feels like a dramatized encyclopedia entry: all the facts, little of the fizz. There are laughs, but for a story about comedy legends, the humor can be surprisingly light. Still, the show’s ambition and the cast’s dedication are clear, and glimpses of real charm in the second act hint at the potential for a sharper, more fully realized production.
Slightly amusing but tedious. I didn't expect carbon copies of the original SNL comedians altho those playing Garrett Morris & Gilda Radner do credible jobs, but the backstage shenanigans of the players (e.g. who was sleeping with who, who had drug problems, etc.) will only be of interest to diehard fans of the original cast. Others may not care. Stretched over 2 acts, it's a longish slog.
1–12 of 12 comments
Fun for fans of snl! Intimate setting and fun atmosphere