New York, New York
Loved loved loved this show! The singing, dancing and acting was phenomenal! Couldn’t put together a better cast. It’s a beautiful story of old time New York. Felt like a combo of Guys and Dolls and In the Heights. Makes me proud to call NYC home. GO SEE IT!
Fun cute little thang
Great amazing! Loved it! (Edited)
Closing night 10/10 (Edited)
When thinking of NYC, what comes to mind? Is it the hustle and bustle of the city? Perhaps it’s all of the people crammed together in one locale despite differences in class and homeland. For whatever picture you are painting of the Big Apple experience, there is a Broadway show that has tried to simulate it onstage, and NEW YORK, NEW YORK is no different. In all honesty, my experience with this show was colored by the events of the day: a slew of negative reviews had hit the presses that morning, and my seat was in the mezzanine off to the side amid a non-vocal patch of audience. Any of these could have justified my lack of engagement with the story or interest in its characters, but I’ve concluded that NEW YORK, NEW YORK lacks soul because this show is an evident business venture. Don’t get me wrong, I was stunned again and again by the sheer amount of Beowulf Boritt’s set pieces and backdrops, by the spectacular lighting tricks and glitzy gags that kept the audience on our toes. But not even the copious stacks of money backing this production can replace earnest artistry. Attempting to rouse morale for the largest city in the nation with a collection of seemingly randomly selected stories of half-baked characters held together by a golden-age Hollywood aesthetic that is no longer relevant isn’t gonna cut it. Throw every trick you have in the book at us, but most New Yorkers need something bigger to dream and fight for than settling in your relationship and being bullied into living somewhere because everyone else says it’s the best. (Don’t even get me started on our “protagonist,” who suffers from the same narcissistic pitfalls as Andy’s boyfriend from the film THE DEVIL WEARS PRADA.) If it’s surprising and entertaining spectacle that you’re looking for, this is the show for you. But if you’re seeking to support artists in the City, I’d recommend saving your money and spending far less on an indie performing troupe. Heck, I’d even recommend streaming WEST SIDE STORY, (either one,) to get your fill of the city that never sleeps packaged as a musical.
New York, New York has many good parts, but needs a strong editor to trim and fit them all together. Inspired by a 1977 film by Martin Scorsese, the production gets too distracted by multiple interconnecting plots to focus on what really works: the performances of its two leads, Colton Ryan and Anna Uzele. The best sequences involved Ryan dashing around the stage to play as many instruments as fit on the set, or Uzele bringing the house down with a rendition of the classic, New York, New York, but it takes a long time to get there. With multiple plots ranging from an immigrant violinist searching for a teacher to a music-loving son fighting against his parent’s expectations, the storyline drags the audience along from enchanting dance sequence to flashy musical number, many of which are quite good, despite the narrative problems. This production is the last from musical legends Kander and Ebb, Fred Ebb died in 2004, and Lin Manuel-Miranda was brought in to finish the lyrics, so it’s easy to see why producers would be reluctant to insist on too many edits. Why question the knowledge and prowess of the writers who brought us Chicago, Cabaret, and Hamilton? But the musical is worse for it. With a bit more trimming, New York, New York could have been a wonderful flashback to musical times past. It already has a great set and fabulous dance sequences. Instead it’s a fun, but messy piece with a few too many characters and not quite enough coherence.
Beautiful, yet boring. With a beautiful set, costumes, lighting, and dancing I really wanted to like NY, NY but I found the story to be confusing (why are they going to the top of a sky scraper getting built), and full of characters I had a hard time caring about.
Committed the cardinal sin of being boring
1–12 of 12 comments
highlight was scaffolding tap dance