Messy White Gays
Review: Messy White Gays (Seen during Previews) The Duke on 42nd Street Directed by Mike Donahue | Written by Drew Droege Even in previews, Messy White Gays lives up to its title — loud, chaotic, messy, and impossible not to watch. Drew Droege is at his best here, finding humor in the things we’d rather not face. A dead ex hidden in a credenza during brunch becomes more than a farce; it’s a mirror for the queer community, reflecting the parts of ourselves we love, hate, and secretly recognize — all while keeping you laughing. I laughed — actual belly laughs — from start to finish. Droege’s writing is loaded with razor-sharp one-liners, but beneath the absurdity is an honest look at performative kindness, gossip, body obsession, and quiet judgment. It’s exaggerated, messy, hilarious — and painfully true. The cast dives fully into the chaos, each performance a perfect storm of timing, energy, and audacity. They find the humor in the mess while grounding it enough to feel real. Small preview slips? They only added to the buzz of a room alive with unpredictable energy. The sleek, stylish set gives the perfect stage for all the wild physical comedy, letting the audience laugh, gasp, and groan all at once. It’s not for everyone — some jokes are sharp, some truths uncomfortable — but that’s the point. It’s messy, loud, funny, and at its core, incredibly human. Final Verdict: This one’s cleared for takeoff — grab your bottle of rosé, buckle in, and enjoy the wildly comical ride at 30,000 feet.
Drew Droge is a treasure - and his play is just beautifully stupid funny - laughed all the way through. Go see this.
It was a pretty good show, Thacker was the absolute best part of the show and he had me laughing so hard! The commitment to the role is amazing!!
So campy!! So many queer puns. We couldn’t stop laughing!! I highly recommend it if you’re a fan of queer culture and comedy!
I thought it was very funny. You don’t have to be gay to find it fun but it certainly does help. There is some specific New York jokes in it that you might not get if not from NYC, but there’s so many jokes that missing one doesn’t affect the show.
Perfectly bitchy. I want that apartment!
Great show. The actors were superb and not bad to look at either. A must see comedy
Very funny
The set was great. Seating was amazing (any seat was a good seat). This is the one play where the women’s bathroom won’t have a line! lol. I loved all the cutesy stuff outside just the set. (See pics- plus there’s more). As a Black queer and nonbinary woman … I think this play was funny BUT there were times when I was like this is a bit much on the out of line side (a lot of like…. Let’s make a joke then have the horrified woke white gay be like “Omg no we never fat shame/ make fun of Black folks/ show ableism!” It was one of those , and u can only tolerate so much of those kind of jokes before u start looking side eyed and wanting to fight. They def read each other down— all of the characters. So that was funny. I feel like 1- I don’t usually enjoy “white frat boy humor” but I am enjoying this sub genre of “white gay fem male comedy/theatre” that is getting stronger as a niche this year. And 2- it feels to me like this is kind of what ginger twinsies wanted to be. This kind of outrageous queer humor, but for me it didn’t work in that show but worked in this one. Prob because they focused more on the plot and being gay and messy and playing that trope out rather than putting the emphasis on the time period and the references to outside pop culture (which they did A LOT in this show but without trying too hard). Def a cute show but if you’re BIPOC or other type of marginalized (besides white and gay), go with your ppl. It did feel weird to be one of the like 2 Black ppl in the audience (and by myself) when they’re making so many jokes that run the gamut and often end in “we love Black ppl but it’s not our fault we have no Black friends!” All that said, I still recommend and was laughing out loud plenty of times!
A fun little diversion, but not much more. The writer knows he’s making a stupid-fun play, but it would’ve been much stronger if it was grounded with a touch of reality. The thin plot exists so the actors can drop sassy quips à la Drag Race and mention the names of 20+ Hell’s Kitchen restaurants and gay bars. The [mainly gay, white, male] audience ate it up — and if you’re in the mood for stupid comedy, you can certainly have fun — but I wish there’d been slightly more there there.
front row. a fun ensemble. script felt a bit corny at times but had some really funny moments too.
More of a read off than a satire. Pete Zias was a highlight. (Edited)
A show comprised of hundreds of one liners instead of plot, and only about a quarter of them really land. But I’ll see anything Drew does.
Drew Droege is great. However the others need to slow the f down, deliver their line, and pause. Timing queens, timing. It’s like watching a high school play. It’s not a race.
I love some of the people in this and came to support their work. I thought it gained steam towards the end and enjoyed the performances, but felt like the writing needed a lot of work. It sounded exactly like it was written from the perspective of an older generation looking at a younger one. Didn't love it.
The humor doesn’t fully land
Stupid
1–18 of 18 comments
Campy and fun in a laughing with us not at us kind of way. The physical comedy of the actors added so much to the bizarre premise. An added small pleasure was that the audience was majorly gay men and it was the first time I've seen the men's room line substantially longer than the women's. (-: