McNeal
A divisive play about a pretty divisive issue in our society with a great performance from Robert Downey Jr, MCNEAL is sure to spark conversation and mess with audience heads
RDJ did a great job and so did rest of the crew. Really enjoyed it.
WOW incredible performances and very cool and clever story. script and writing is so good and interesting, very relevant. Downey is amazing and the whole cast gives 110%. what a joy, highly recommend.
One of the best this summer/fall.
Excellent staging, real theater experience
It was well acted unique story
Great show!
Great play! Very entertaining. Robert Downey Jr. is amazing, as usual. The whole cast is great! I loved it!
Robert Downey, Jr is incredible!
Great!!!
I can't help it. I just love the star.
My GOD what a show! What a SHOW! So so damn relevant in the day and age of AI.
Just wow, AI empowered and such an actors, such an acting…. Very modern as well!
"McNeal" presents an intriguing, socially relevant premise that immediately caught my interest, examining the impact of AI on the artistic integrity of individuals, particularly writers. As someone who uses ChatGPT myself, I found the play's realistic portrayal of its usage to be quite clever. I loved the set design, the configuration of the theater, and the visual projections—it even included some really cool floor projections, which were impressive. Robert Downey Jr. was fantastic as McNeal, clearly carrying much of the play on his own. However, while I loved the story’s concept and message, I feel it wasn’t maximized to its full potential. I struggled to hear the actors in the theater, especially in the loge section, and they were speaking so fast that it was hard to keep up and understand what was happening. I started losing interest in the middle of the performance due to a lack of comedic timing to regain my attention. I only really enjoyed the beginning and near the end, and honestly, the ChatGPT prompts were funnier than their dialogue. I wanted more drama and emotion from the rest of the cast. I also wished that the writing could have explored more of the concept and shown more effects of AI usage. The ending was just underwhelming and didn’t leave a lasting impact. I think what would have made a big difference was if there had been some memorable lines or a surprising twist. Overall, the topic of AI dependence is something I genuinely worry about, especially for future generations, and "McNeal" was able to present a glimpse of that horror. I just wished it could have pushed its message further with more creativity because it ultimately left me wanting more.
Obviously, RDJ is the big draw and he did an excellent job. I thought the two standout performances were Andrea Martin and Melora Hardin. I found the script to be overwrought at times and questioned some of the choices. I'd say it's worth seeing at a lower price point, but it's definitely not a must-see.
Worth it to see RDJ live, but overall somewhat disjointed. For a play that’s marketed about AI and its morality, it doesn’t spend much time actually talking about AI and it’s morality
Second preview performance. Was it intriguing? Sure. Was seeing RDJ act live really cool? Yeahhh. Were the supporting actors mostly good? Of course. Was the book anything to write home about? Eh. Was the technology as cool as I was anticipating? Double ehh. Glad I saw it, wouldn’t see again.
admittedly did not stay for the entire thing due to personal circumstances, but only missed the last 10 minutes… with that being said, McNeal does muddle through the plot but I think that the point. Yes it’s a story about plagiarism and we really don’t get to really “feel” McNeal and see him deeper even though he’s a writer, but I also think all of these things are the point. essentially, AI is not smarter than a human being, no matter what we want to say I believe it is just general plagiarism, and so the thought of computer plagiarism versus human plagiarism is a conversational point that needs to be had because what is AI if not just stealing of experience and pattern recognition. OVERALL: if you can get through some clunky writing have the money to see it it is visually stunning and I do think the conversation is interesting.
Robert Downey Jr was entertaining and exactly what you expect in his Broadway. An interesting play that shines when it focuses on questions around AI, but isn't super compelling when it starts into character side plots.
21–40 of 76 comments
Great cast. Relevant story for today’s times.