Machinal
It was ok. Tap dancing was tremendous.
it was an interesting performance but definitely mixed feelings
An opportunity to see one of the greatest American texts of the 20th century, this production crosses its t’s and dots its i’s with movement, grid work, and yes, tap dancing. These single-use metaphors wear thin quickly, and begin to eat at the natural rhythm of the text and the plotting of the story. Also reused are the set pieces from the first scene, the only scene to take place in an office, and the Ayn Rand-ish costumes that press the cast of characters and their worldviews into uniformity. These gestures, while they may not serve the text, definitely give the production much purpose and direction, and it’s all impressively rehearsed and executed. A commendable if overdecorated revival of a great New York play.
Machinal, the inaugural production from NYTC, brings inventive staging and an ensemble dynamic to a century old play. I think that the concept was the strongest element of the production, utilizing foley and dance to build out a world and exemplify the turmoil characters were facing, although it didn’t work all of the time. I felt that it was best when in moderation, with much of the first act feeling as thought it was in nonstop motion and avoiding the weight of stillness and silence. The NYCC black box space venue lended itself to this effect, as it amplified the noise to fill the entire space and enabled dynamic visual stagings on the perimeter of the stage, immersing the audience. While I thought the concept intriguing, the script felt a bit too long (whether that is the original text or a reworked adaptation), and I think that a shortened one act version would have been better suited to the production. The dynamics and psychological tension that seemed to build throughout the first act took time some to build up again at the start of the second, and I felt myself struggling to connect with many characters, including the protagonist due to an overly complicated narrative. Several of the secondary characters performances stood out as highlights of the show for me, either in appearing as caricatures of the archetypal characters they played (with these being a majority of the production, feeling almost in excess to me) or in bringing welcome sincerity in contrast. Following the debut with Machinal, NYTC’s artistic direction and vision should be a promising one to watch unfold in coming productions. (Edited)
This production very much felt like college experimental theatre gone wrong. I typically love a good tap dance but this incessant trope just did not work.
21–26 of 26 comments
A well done revival of a play that really didn't need one. Madison Hilligoss's choreography shines while Sophie Treadwell's dated text pales in comparison. While seemingly "of the moment," the story is bland and relies on characters "telling" the audience of things that have happened rather than taking advantage of the theatrical medium. This production, however, takes good care to use the theatrical medium, filling the theater with music, dance, beautiful rhythms, and live foley. Unfortunately, these attention grabbing additions ultimately undermine the text, revealed all that is left to be desired. In spite of the issues I had with the play, these were some great performances — Hannah Snow as Helen was phenomenal, and Veronica Simpson was beyond impressive. Possibly worth it just to see some really satisfying tap dancing. Would recommend to people interested in historical drama or movement based theater.