Kenrex
I went in knowing nothing about this show and thoroughly enjoyed myself! I’m not sure I’d personally classify as a thriller but the questions of justice were super interesting and the performance was fantastic
Two guys play 20 characters in an extraordinary play based a true crime story. Just don’t sit upstairs
Wonderful acting,minimalistic but highly functional stage setting, and a powerful and thought-provoking ending.
You’re telling me you wouldn’t have been in the parking lot that day? 📻 How much do people need to hate you to cover up for what they did to you? @kenrextheplay is a one-man tour de force that kept me on the edge of my seat. I didn’t even realize this was a true story—a deep dive into a community’s moral decay, exploring what happens when fear and resentment drive people to take justice into their own hands. It’s a thrilling reminder of how far we can fall when we abandon truth. This is, hands down, the best show I’ve seen all year. If you love gripping, socially charged theater, this is a must-see!
Same day rush available at the box office. Great seat! And thoroughly enjoyed the show from start to finish.
Great play and use of mics and the stage. The musician was so good as well!
I’ve recommended it to so many people This was an amazing experience. No wonder it kept selling out in London I can’t wait to see it again!!
The play follows the tiny farming town of Skidmore as years of violence, intimidation, fear, and legal failure slowly push the community toward a breaking point. Told through interviews, depositions, courtroom testimony, radio broadcasts, phone calls, and fractured recollections, KENREX slowly pieces together how an entire town became trapped under the weight of one man. And what makes the show work so well is that it never feels like some clean little true crime reenactment. It feels tense from the second it starts. There’s this constant low level dread hanging over the entire evening where every conversation feels like it could suddenly turn dangerous. The audience knows very early that something terrible is eventually coming. The suspense comes from watching the pressure inside this town slowly build scene by scene until everybody starts emotionally cracking under it. At the center of the production is Jack Holden giving one of the most impressive performances currently happening Off Broadway. Yes, he’s playing dozens of characters. But what makes the performance so effective is that Holden never turns it into some flashy acting gimmick. Entire people suddenly appear through tiny changes in posture, breathing, rhythm, or eye contact. The shifts are so sharp and controlled that you stop thinking about the mechanics of the performance pretty quickly and just start getting pulled deeper into the story. And then there’s Ken Rex himself. The second Holden shifts into Ken, the entire atmosphere changes. What makes the performance so creepy is how quiet it is. Holden never plays him like some over the top movie psychopath. Half the time he barely raises his voice. But every interaction suddenly feels dangerous the second he walks into a room. Conversations tighten. People physically recoil from him. Entire scenes start feeling like they could explode without warning. There’s a sequence involving Ken, a barking dog, and a crowded tavern that had people around me visibly shrinking back in their seats. Another grocery store confrontation becomes almost unbearable because the tension underneath it keeps tightening and tightening long before anything actually happens. The production understands that anticipation is often scarier than violence itself. That’s what makes KENREX so effective. The show is far less interested in the murder than it is in the emotional exhaustion surrounding it. The longer these people live under fear, the more normal fear itself becomes. Nobody in Skidmore feels completely innocent anymore. Everybody feels worn down. Everybody feels morally exhausted. And that slow emotional decay hanging over the town becomes far more disturbing than any single act of violence ever could. Visually and sonically, the production does an incredible job maintaining that tension. Joshua Pharo’s lighting and video design constantly floods the stage with shadows, headlights, smoke, silhouettes, and sudden bursts of harsh light that make the entire evening feel closer to psychological horror than traditional stage drama. Giles Thomas’ sound design layers static, barking dogs, overlapping voices, engines, and distorted radio chatter in genuinely unnerving ways that make the theater itself feel unsettled. John Patrick Elliott’s live Americana inspired score hangs over the production like some ghost story drifting out of a roadside bar at 2am. I did think the sound occasionally pushed slightly too hard during a few sequences, swallowing smaller moments that may have landed even harder with a little more restraint. But that feels relatively minor compared to how completely KENREX manages to tighten its grip on the audience throughout the night. Because by the end, this stops feeling like a murder mystery entirely. It starts feeling like watching an entire town slowly rot from fear. And somehow, that’s much darker. The silence hanging over the audience by the final moments said everything.
MY TAKE ON: KenRex, a True Crime Thriller, Lucille Lortel Theatre, Thursday, April 30, 2026 That this wholly American story of vigilante justice in podunk Missouri should have been birthed in London is one astonishing aspect of “KenRex: A True Crime Thriller.” Also astonishing is the production itself, which conjures genuine suspense from a taut script, simple sets (a doorway, a stairway and a platform); bar-brawling music by a raucous one-man band (John Patrick Elliott); and moody, smokey effects, striking lighting and bold sound design. Most astonishing is that the entire town of Skidmore – some 35 characters in all – are played with abandon as fully formed unique individuals by Jack Holden, who wrote the play with the director, Ed Stamboullouian. (Holden won the UK’s highest acting honor for his performance.) Holden is scarily menacing as the deep-voiced title character, Ken Rex McElroy, who terrorized Skidmore, Mo., for decades. With the help of a weaselly but slick lawyer (also Holden), McElroy dodged prison 21 times on charges including animal cruelty, burglary, arson, assault, child molestation and statutory rape (his wife – also Holden – gave birth at 14). But the town itself did something astonishing: In 1981, it had had enough and fought back; McElroy paid the ultimate price. Even more astonishing: No one has ever been charged in his death. The people of Skidmore, all of them, said they saw nothing and knew nothing.
Loved it!! Jack Holden was amazing!!
Tour de force performance. Not to be missed!
Run to see this show. One of the best shows I’ve ever seen.
Unmissable theatrical event
Absolutely incredible! This is a must see! No wonder it kept selling out in London
Stunning
you HAVE to see this
Absolutely amazing!!! A must watch!!!
There’s a theme unfolding at the Lucille Lortel. The last one-man show I saw here was Andrew Scott playing eight characters in Vanya, and now comes Kenrex, starring another Brit, Jack Holden. The intimacy of the Lortel suits this kind of work; with one actor carrying the whole play, the space gets out of the way. Holden’s range is considerable—his accent work alone would convince you he grew up in rural Missouri—but what really elevates the show is the world built around him. Composer John Patrick Elliott performs live onstage, cycling through guitars, drums, banjo, and keyboard to ground the Skidmore, Missouri setting in thick Americana. The sound and lighting design add to the setting and tension beautifully, layering in ambient chatter that pulls you into the town rather than distracting from it. Holden’s turn as Ken Rex McElroy, the real-life villain at the story’s center, is genuinely unsettling, providing a glimpse at the dread he inflicted on Skidmore. Where the show loses me is structure. It opens with a frantic 911 call in the aftermath of the shooting, then rewinds to trace how Skidmore got there. The non-chronological approach broken into chapters is clearly intentional, but it diluted the momentum for me; the emotional throughline felt disjointed, and a few scenes stretched past their weight. For a story with an ending this disturbing, I expected to leave shaken. Instead, I left impressed by the craft but not quite moved. Whether that says more about the play or me, I honestly can’t tell.
Great performance by the British actor playing a multitude of small town Americans. This guy is MOVING the whole time and his effort is admirable. The story is involving , but it’s kind of empty in the end. I also thought there is a misunderstanding of America somewhere here, where everyone was just too pat and portrayed as mud kicking country bumpkins. Bottom line, the performance is worth seeing but the play itself is a bit flawed.
1–20 of 30 comments
So much talent from one actor! Story is also incredible and well told. Music was interesting and not sure how it fits (maybe I missed the link) but overall the quality of the music was excellent. Really glad I got to experience this award winning show! Sound design is brilliant ! Especially in this small space.